The Private Memoirs And Confessions
Of A Justified Sinner
by James Hogg
TO THE HON. WILLIAM SMITH,
LORD PROVOST OF GLASGOW,
&c. &c. &c.
THIS WORK IS RESPECTFULLY INSCRIBED,
AS A SMALL MARK OF
ESTEEM FOR HIM AS A MAN,
AND RESPECT FOR HIM AS A MAGISTRATE.
THE EDITOR'S NARRATIVE.
It appears from tradition, as well as some parish registers still
extant, that the lands of Dalcastle (or Dalchastel, as it is often
spelled) were possessed by a family of the name of Colwan, about one
hundred and fifty years ago, and for at least a century previous to
that period. That family was supposed to have been a branch of the
ancient family of Colquhoun, and it is certain that from it spring the
Cowans that spread towards the Border. I find, that in the year 1687,
George Colwan succeeded his uncle of the same name, in the lands of
Dalchastel and Balgrennan; and this being all I can gather of the
family from history, to tradition I must appeal for the remainder of
the motley adventures of that house. But of the matter furnished by the
latter of these powerful monitors, I have no reason to complain: It
has been handed down to the world in unlimited abundance; and I am
certain, that in recording the hideous events which follow, I am only
relating to the greater part of the inhabitants of at least four
counties of Scotland, matters of which they were before perfectly well
This George was a rich man, or supposed to be so, and was married,
when considerably advanced in life, to the sole heiress and reputed
daughter of a Baillie Orde, of Glasgow. This proved a conjunction any
thing but agreeable to the parties contracting. It is well known, that
the Reformation principles had long before that time taken a powerful
hold of the hearts and affections of the people of Scotland, although
the feeling was by no means general, or in equal degrees; and it so
happened that this married couple felt completely at variance on the
subject. Granting it to have been so, one would have thought that the
laird, owing to his retired situation, would have been the one that
inclined to the stern doctrines of the reformers; and that the young
and gay dame from the city would have adhered to the free principles
cherished by the court party, and indulged in rather to extremity, in
opposition to their severe and carping contemporaries.
The contrary, however, happened to be the case. The laird was what
his country neighbours called "a droll, careless chap," with a very
limited proportion of the fear of God in his heart, and very nearly as
little of the fear of man. The laird had not intentionally wronged or
offended either of the parties, and perceived not the necessity of
deprecating their vengeance. He had hitherto believed that he was
living in most cordial terms with the greater part of the inhabitants
of the earth, and with the powers above in particular: but woe be unto
him if he was not soon convinced of the fallacy of such damning
security! for his lady was the most severe and gloomy of all bigots to
the principles of the Reformation. Hers were not the tenets of the
great reformers, but theirs mightily overstrained and deformed. Theirs
was an unguent hard to be swallowed; but hers was that unguent
embittered and overheated until nature could not longer bear it. She
had imbibed her ideas from the doctrines of one flaming predestinarian
divine alone; and these were so rigid, that they became a
stumbling-block to many of his brethren, and a mighty handle for the
enemies of his party to turn the machine of the state against them.
The wedding festivities at Dalcastle partook of all the gaiety, not
of that stern age, but of one previous to it. There was feasting,
dancing, piping, and singing: the liquors were handed around in great
fulness, the ale in large wooden bickers, and the brandy in capacious
horns of oxen. The laird gave full scope to his homely glee. He
danced,—he snapped his fingers to the music,—clapped his hands and
shouted at the turn of the tune. He saluted every girl in the hall
whose appearance was any thing tolerable, and requested of their
sweethearts to take the same freedom with his bride, by way of
retaliation. But there she sat at the head of the hall in still and
blooming beauty, absolutely refusing to tread a single measure with any
gentleman there. The only enjoyment in which she appeared to partake,
was in now and then stealing a word of sweet conversation with her
favourite pastor about divine things; for he had accompanied her home
after marrying her to her husband, to see her fairly settled in her new
dwelling. He addressed her several times by her new name, Mrs. Colwan;
but she turned away her head disgusted, and looked with pity and
contempt towards the old inadvertent sinner, capering away in the
height of his unregenerated mirth. The minister perceived the workings
of her pious mind, and thenceforward addressed her by the courteous
title of Lady Dalcastle, which sounded somewhat better, as not coupling
her name with one of the wicked: and there is too great reason to
believe, that for all the solemn vows she had come under, and these
were of no ordinary binding, particularly on the laird's part, she at
that time despised, if not abhorred him, in her heart.
The good parson again blessed her, and went away. She took leave of
him with tears in her eyes, entreating him often to visit her in that
heathen land of the Amorite, the Hittite, and the Girgashite: to which
he assented, on many solemn and qualifying conditions, —and then the
comely bride retired to her chamber to pray.
It was customary, in those days, for the bride's-man and maiden, and
a few select friends, to visit the new married couple after they had
retired to rest, and drink a cup to their healths, their happiness, and
a numerous posterity. But the laird delighted not in this: he wished to
have his jewel to himself; and, slipping away quietly from his jovial
party, he retired to his chamber to his beloved, and bolted the door.
He found her engaged with the writings of the Evange-lists, and
terribly demure. The laird went up to caress her; but she turned away
her head, and spoke of the follies of aged men, and something of the
broad way that leadeth to destruction. The laird did not thoroughly
comprehend this allusion; but being considerably flustered by
drinking, and disposed to take all in good part, he only remarked, as
he took off his shoes and stockings, "that whether the way was broad or
narrow, it was time that they were in their bed."
"Sure, Mr. Colwan, you won't go to bed to-night, at such an
important period of your life, without first saying prayers for
yourself and me."
When she said this, the laird had his head down almost to the
ground, loosing his shoe-buckle; but when he heard of prayers, on such
a night, he raised his face suddenly up, which was all over as flushed
and red as a rose, and answered,—
"Prayers, Mistress! Lord help your crazed head, is this a night
He had better have held his peace. There was such a torrent of
profound divinity poured out upon him, that the laird became ashamed,
both of himself and his new-made spouse, and wist not what to say: but
the brandy helped him out.
"It strikes me, my dear, that religious devotion would be somewhat
out of place to-night," said he. "Allowing that it is ever so
beautiful, and ever so beneficial, were we to ride on the rigging of it
at all times, would we not be constantly making a farce of it: It would
be like reading the Bible and the jest-book, verse about, and would
render the life of man a medley of absurdity and confusion."
But against the cant of the bigot or the hypocrite, no reasoning can
aught avail. If you would argue until the end of life, the infallible
creature must alone be right. So it proved with the laird. One
Scripture text followed another, not in the least connected, and one
sentence of the profound Mr. Wringhim's sermons after another, proving
the duty of family worship, till the laird lost patience, and, tossing
himself into bed, said, carelessly, that he would leave that duty upon
her shoulders for one night.
The meek mind of Lady Dalcastle was somewhat disarranged by this
sudden evolution. She felt that she was left rather in an awkward
situation. However, to show her unconscionable spouse that she was
resolved to hold fast her integrity, she kneeled down and prayed in
terms so potent, that she deemed she was sure of making an impression
on him. She did so; for in a short time the laird began to utter a
response so fervent, that she was utterly astounded, and fairly driven
from the chain of her orisons. He began, in truth, to sound a nasal
bugle of no ordinary calibre,—the notes being little inferior to
those of a military trumpet. The lady tried to proceed, but every
returning note from the bed burst on her ear with a louder twang, and
a longer peal, till the concord of sweet sounds became so truly
pathetic, that the meek spirit of the dame was quite overcome; and
after shedding a flood of tears, she arose from her knees, and retired
to the chimney-corner with her Bible in her lap, there to spend the
hours in holy mediation till such time as the inebriated trumpeter
should awaken to a sense of propriety.
The laird did not awake in any reasonable time; for, he being
overcome with fatigue and wassail, his sleep became sounder, and his
Morphean measures more intense. These varied a little in their
structure; but the general run of the bars sounded something in this
way,—"Hic-hoc-wheew!" It was most profoundly ludicrous; and could not
have missed exciting risibility in any one, save a pious, a
disappointed, and humbled bride.
The good dame wept bitterly. She could not for her life go and
awaken the monster, and request him to make room for her: but she
retired somewhere; for the laird, on awaking next morning, found that
he was still lying alone. His sleep had been of the deepest and most
genuine sort; and all the time that it lasted, he had never once
thought of either wives, children, or sweethearts, save in the way of
dreaming about them; but as his spirit began again by slow degrees to
verge towards the boundaries of reason, it became lighter and more
buoyant from the effects of deep repose, and his dreams partook of that
buoyancy, yea, to a degree hardly expressible. He dreamed of the reel,
the jig, the strathspey, and the corant; and the elasticity of his
frame was such, that he was bounding over the heads of the maidens, and
making his feet skimmer against the ceiling, enjoying, the while, the
most extatic emotions. These grew too fervent for the shackles of the
drowsy god to restrain. The nasal bugle ceased its prolonged sounds in
one moment, and a sort of hectic laugh took its place. "Keep it
going,—play up, you devils!" cried the laird, without changing his
position on the pillow. But this exertion to hold the fiddlers at their
work, fairly awakened the delighted dreamer; and though he could not
refrain from continuing his laugh, he at length, by tracing out a
regular chain of facts, came to be sensible of his real situation.
"Rabina, where are you? What's become of you, my dear?" cried the
laird. But there was no voice, nor any one that answered or regarded.
He flung open the curtains, thinking to find her still on her knees, as
he had seen her; but she was not there, either sleeping or waking,
"Rabina! Mrs. Colwan!" shouted he, as loud as he could call, and then
added, in the same breath, "God save the king,— I have lost my
He sprung up and opened the casement: the daylight was beginning to
streak the east, for it was spring, and the nights were short, and the
mornings very long. The laird half dressed himself in an instant, and
strode through every room in the house, opening the windows as he went,
and scrutinizing every bed and every corner. He came into the hall
where the wedding festival had held; and, as he opened the various
window-boards, loving couples flew off like hares surprised too late in
the morning among the early braird. "Hoo-boo! Fie, be frightened!"
cried the laird. "Fie, rin like fools, as if ye were caught in an ill
turn!"—His bride was not among them; so he was obliged to betake
himself to farther search. "She will be praying in some corner, poor
woman," said he to himself. "It is an unlucky thing this praying. But,
for my part, I fear I have behaved very ill; and I must endeavour to
The laird continued his search, and at length found his beloved in
the same bed with her Glasgow cousin, who had acted as bride's-maid.
"You sly and malevolent imp," said the laird; "you have played me such
a trick when I was fast asleep! I have not known a frolic so clever,
and, at the same time, so severe. Come along, you baggage you!"
"Sir, I will let you know, that I detest your principles and your
person alike," said she. "It shall never be said, Sir, that my person
was at the controul of a heathenish man of Belial,—a dangler among
the daughters of women,—a promiscuous dancer,— and a player at
unlawful games. Forego your rudeness, Sir, I say, and depart away from
my presence and that of my kinswoman."
"Come along, I say, my charming Rab. If you were the pink of all
puritans, and the saint of all saints, you are my wife, and must do as
I command you."
"Sir, I will sooner lay down my life than be subjected to your
godless will; therefore, I say, desist, and begone with you."
But the laird regarded none of these testy sayings: he rolled her in
a blanket, and bore her triumphantly away to his chamber, taking care
to keep a fold or two of the blanket always rather near to her mouth,
in case of any outrageous forthcoming of noise.
The next day at breakfast the bride was long in making her
appearance. Her maid asked to see her; but George did not choose that
any body should see her but himself: he paid her several visits, and
always turned the key as he came out. At length breakfast was served;
and during the time of refreshment the laird tried to break several
jokes; but it was remarked, that they wanted their accustomed
brilliancy, and that his nose was particularly red at the top.
Matters, without all doubt, had been very bad between the
new-married couple; for in the course of the day the lady deserted her
quarters, and returned to her father's house in Glasgow, after having
been a night on the road; stage-coaches and steam-boats having then no
existence in that quarter. Though Baillie Orde had acquiesced in his
wife's asseveration regarding the likeness of their only daughter to
her father, he never loved or admired her greatly; therefore this
behaviour nothing astounded him. He questioned her strictly as to the
grievous offence committed against her; and could discover nothing that
warranted a procedure so fraught with disagreeable consequences. So,
after mature deliberation, the baillie addressed her as follows:—
"Ay, ay, Raby! An' sae I find that Dalcastle has actually refused
to say prayers with you when you ordered him; an' has guidit you in a
rude indelicate manner, outstepping the respect due to my daughter,
—as my daughter. But wi' regard to what is due to his own wife, of
that he's a better judge nor me. However, since he has behaved in that
manner to my daughter, I shall be revenged on him for aince; for I
shall return the obligation to ane nearer to him: that is, I shall take
pennyworths of his wife,—an' let him lick at that."
"What do you mean, Sir?" said the astonished damsel.
"I mean to be revenged on that villain Dalcastle," said he, "for
what he has done to my daughter. Come hither, Mrs. Colwan, you shall
pay for this."
So saying, the baillie began to inflict corporal punishment on the
runaway wife. His strokes were not indeed very deadly, but he made a
mighty flourish in the infliction, pretending to be in a great rage
only at the Laird of Dalcastle. "Villain that he is!" exclaimed he, "I
shall teach him to behave in such a manner to a child of mine, be she
as she may; since I cannot get at himself, I shall lounder her that is
nearest to him in life. Take you that, and that, Mrs. Colwan, for your
The poor afflicted woman wept and prayed, but the baillie would not
abate aught of his severity. After fuming, and beating her with many
stripes, far drawn, and lightly laid down, he took her up to her
chamber, five stories high, locked her in, and there he fed her on
bread and water, all to be revenged on the presumptuous Laird of
Dalcastle; but ever and anon, as the baillie came down the stair from
carrying his daughter's meal, he said to himself, "I shall make the
sight of the laird the blithest she ever saw in her life."
Lady Dalcastle got plenty of time to read, and pray, and meditate;
but she was at a great loss for one to dispute with about religious
tenets; for she found, that without this advantage, about which there
was a perfect rage at that time, her reading, and learning of Scripture
texts, and sentences of intricate doctrine, availed her nought; so she
was often driven to sit at her casement and look out for the approach
of the heathenish Laird of Dalcastle.
That hero, after a considerable lapse of time, at length made his
appearance. Matters were not hard to adjust; for his lady found that
there was no refuge for her in her father's house; and so, after some
sighs and tears, she accompanied her husband home. For all that had
passed, things went on no better. She would convert the laird in spite
of his teeth: The laird would not be converted. She would have the
laird to say family prayers, both morning and evening: The laird would
neither pray morning nor evening. He would not even sing psalms, and
kneel beside her, while she performed the exercise; neither would he
converse at all times, and in all places, about the sacred mysteries of
religion, although his lady took occasion to contradict flatly every
assertion that he made, in order that she might spiritualize him by
drawing him into argument.
The laird kept his temper a long while, but at length his patience
wore out; he cut her short in all her futile attempts at
spiritualization, and mocked at her wire-drawn degrees of faith, hope,
and repentance. He also dared to doubt of the great standard doctrine
of absolute predestination, which put the crown on the lady's christian
resentment. She declared her helpmate to be a limb of Antichrist, and
one with whom no regenerated person could associate. She therefore
bespoke a separate establishment, and before the expiry of the first
six months, the arrangements of the separation were amicably adjusted.
The upper, or third story of the old mansion-house, was awarded to the
lady for her residence. She had a separate door, a separate stair, a
separate garden, and walks that in no instance intersected the laird's;
so that one would have thought the separation complete. They had each
their own parties, selected from their own sort of people; and though
the laird never once chafed himself about the lady's companies, it was
not long before she began to intermeddle about some of his.
"Who is that fat bouncing dame that visits the laird so often, and
always by herself?" said she to her maid Martha one day.
"O dear, mem, how can I ken? We're banished frae our acquaintances
here, as weel as frae the sweet gospel ordinances."
"Find me out who that jolly dame is, Martha. You, who hold communion
with the household of this ungodly man, can be at no loss to attain
this information. I observe that she always casts her eye up toward our
windows, both in coming and going; and I suspect that she seldom
departs from the house empty-handed."
That same evening Martha came with the information, that this august
visitor was a Miss Logan, an old and intimate acquaintance of the
laird's, and a very worthy respectable lady, of good connections, whose
parents had lost their patrimony in the civil wars.
"Ha! very well!" said the lady; "very well, Martha! But,
nevertheless, go thou and watch this respectable lady's motions and
behaviour the next time she comes to visit the laird,—and the next
after that. You will not, I see, lack opportunities."
Martha's information turned out of that nature, that prayers were
said in the uppermost story of Dalcastle-house against the Canaanitish
woman, every night and every morning; and great discontent prevailed
there, even to anathemas and tears. Letter after letter was dispatched
to Glasgow; and at length, to the lady's great consolation, the Rev.
Mr. Wringhim arrived safely and devoutly in her elevated sanctuary.
Marvellous was the conversation between these gifted people. Wringhim
had held in his doctrines that there were eight different kinds of
Faith, all perfectly distinct in their operations and effects. But the
lady, in her secluded state, had discovered other five,—making twelve
in all: the adjusting of the existence or fallacy of these five faiths
served for a most enlightened discussion of nearly seventeen hours; in
the course of which the two got warm in their arguments, always in
proportion as they receded from nature, utility, and common sense.
Wringhim at length got into unwonted fervour about some disputed point
between one of these faiths and TRUST; when the lady, fearing that zeal
was getting beyond its wonted barrier, broke in on his vehement
asseverations with the following abrupt discomfiture:—"But, Sir, as
long as I remember, what is to be done with this case of open and
The minister was struck dumb. He leaned him back on his chair,
stroked his beard, hemmed— considered, and hemmed again; and then
said, in an altered and softened tone,—"Why, that is a secondary
consideration; you mean the case between your husband and Miss Logan?"
"The same, Sir. I am scandalised at such intimacies going on under
my nose. The sufferance of it is a great and crying evil."
"Evil, madam, may be either operative, or passive. To them it is an
evil, but to us none. We have no more to do with the sins of the wicked
and unconverted here, than with those of an infidel Turk; for all
earthly bonds and fellowships are absorbed and swallowed up in the holy
community of the Reformed Church. However, if it is your wish, I shall
take him to task, and reprimand and humble him in such a manner, that
he shall be ashamed of his doings, and renounce such deeds for ever,
out of mere self-respect, though all unsanctified the heart, as well as
the deed, may be. To the wicked, all things are wicked; but to the
just, all things are just and right."
"Ah, that is a sweet and comfortable saying, Mr. Wringhim! How
delightful to think that a justified person can do no wrong! Who would
not envy the liberty wherewith we are made free? Go to my husband, that
poor unfortunate, blindfolded person, and open his eyes to his
degenerate and sinful state; for well are you fitted to the task."
"Yea, I will go in unto him, and confound him. I will lay the strong
holds of sin and Satan as flat before my face, as the dung that is
spread out to fatten the land."
"Master, there's a gentleman at the fore-door wants a private word
"Tell him I'm engaged: I can't see any gentleman to-night. But I
shall attend on him to-morrow as soon as he pleases."
"He's coming straight in, Sir.—Stop a wee bit, Sir, my master is
engaged. He cannot see you at present, Sir."
"Stand aside, thou Moabite! my mission admits of no delay. I come to
save him from the jaws of destruction!"
"An that be the case, Sir, it maks a wide difference; an', as the
danger may threaten us a', I fancy I may as weel let ye gang by as
fight wi'ye, sin' ye seem sae intent on't.—The man says he's comin'
to save ye, an' canna stop, Sir.—Here he is."
The laird was going to break out into a volley of wrath against
Waters, his servant; but before he got a word pronounced, the Rev. Mr.
Wringhim had stepped inside the room, and Waters had retired, shutting
the door behind him.
No introduction could be more mal-a-propos: it is impossible; for at
that very moment the laird and Arabella Logan were both sitting on one
seat, and both looking on one book, when the door opened. "What is it,
Sir?" said the laird fiercely.
"A message of the greatest importance, Sir," said the divine,
striding unceremoniously up to the chimney,—turning his back to the
fire, and his face to the culprits.—"I think you should know me,
Sir?" continued he, looking displeasedly at the laird, with his face
half turned round.
"I think I should," returned the laird. "You are a Mr.
How's-tey-ca'-him, of Glasgow, who did me the worst turn ever I got
done to me in my life. You gentry are always ready to do a man such a
turn. Pray, Sir, did you ever do a good job for any one to
counterbalance that? for, if you have not, you ought to be—."
"Hold, Sir, I say! None of your profanity before me. If I do evil to
any one on such occasions, it is because he will have it so; therefore,
the evil is not of my doing. I ask you, Sir,—before God and this
witness, I ask you, have you kept solemnly and inviolate the vows which
I laid upon you that day? Answer me?"
"Has the partner whom you bound me to, kept hers inviolate? Answer
me that, Sir? None can better do so than you, Mr. How's-tey-ca'-you."
"So, then, you confess your backslidings, and avow the profligacy of
your life. And this person here, is, I suppose, the partner of your
iniquity,— she whose beauty hath caused you to err! Stand up, both
of you, till I rebuke you, and show you what you are in the eyes of God
"In the first place, stand you still there, till I tell you what you
are in the eyes of God and man: You are, Sir, a presumptuous,
self-conceited pedagogue, a stirrer up of strife and commotion in
church, in state, in families, and communities. You are one, Sir, whose
righteousness consists in splitting the doctrines of Calvin into
thousands of undistinguishable films, and in setting up a system of
justifying-grace against all breaches of all laws, moral or divine. In
short, Sir, you are a mildew,—a canker-worm in the bosom of the
Reformed Church, generating a disease of which she will never be
purged, but by the shedding of blood. Go thou in peace, and do these
abominations no more; but humble thyself, lest a worse reproof come
Wringhim heard all this without flinching. He now and then twisted
his mouth in disdain, treasuring up, mean time, his vengeance against
the two aggressors; for he felt that he had them on the hip, and
resolved to pour out his vengeance and indignation upon them. Sorry am
I, that the shackles of modern decorum restrain me from penning that
famous rebuke; fragments of which have been attributed to every divine
of old notoriety throughout Scotland. But I have it by heart; and a
glorious morsel it is to put into the hands of certain incendiaries.
The metaphors were so strong, and so appalling, that Miss Logan could
only stand them a very short time: she was obliged to withdraw in
confusion. The laird stood his ground with much ado, though his face
was often crimsoned over with the hues of shame and anger. Several
times he was on the point of turning the officious sycophant to the
door; but good manners, and an inherent respect that he entertained for
the clergy, as the immediate servants of the Supreme Being, restrained
Wringhim, perceiving these symptoms of resentment, took them for
marks of shame and contrition, and pushed his reproaches farther than
ever divine ventured to do in a similar case. When he had finished, to
prevent further discussion, he walked slowly and majestically out of
the apartment, making his robes to swing behind him in a most
magisterial manner; he being, without doubt, elated with his high
conquest. He went to the upper story, and related to his metaphysical
associate his wonderful success; how he had driven the dame from the
house in tears and deep confusion, and left the backsliding laird in
such a quandary of shame and repentance, that he could neither
articulate a word, nor lift up his countenance. The dame thanked him
most cordially, lauding his friendly zeal and powerful eloquence; and
then the two again set keenly to the splitting of hairs, and making
distinctions in religion where none existed.
They being both children of adoption, and secured from falling into
snares, or any way under the power of the wicked one, it was their
custom, on each visit, to sit up a night in the same apartment, for the
sake of sweet spiritual converse; but that time, in the course of the
night, they differed so materially on a small point, somewhere between
justification and final election, that the minister, in the heat of his
zeal, sprung from his seat, paced the floor, and maintained his point
with such ardour, that Martha was alarmed, and, thinking they were
going to fight, and that the minister would be a hard match for her
mistress, she put on some clothes, and twice left her bed and stood
listening at the back of the door, ready to burst in should need
require it. Should any one think this picture overstrained, I can
assure him that it is taken from nature and from truth; but I will not
likewise aver, that the theologist was neither crazed nor inebriated.
If the listener's words were to be relied on, there was no love, no
accommodating principle manifested between the two, but a fiery burning
zeal, relating to points of such minor importance, that a true
Christian would blush to hear them mentioned, and the infidel and
profane make a handle of them to turn our religion to scorn.
Great was the dame's exultation at the triumph of her beloved pastor
over her sinful neighbours in the lower parts of the house; and she
boasted of it to Martha in high-sounding terms. But it was of short
duration; for, in five weeks after that, Arabella Logan came to reside
with the laird as his house-keeper, sitting at his table, and carrying
the keys as mistress-substitute of the mansion. The lady's grief and
indignation were now raised to a higher pitch than ever; and she set
every agent to work, with whom she had any power, to effect a
separation between these two suspected ones. Remonstrance was of no
avail: George laughed at them who tried such a course, and retained his
house-keeper, while the lady gave herself up to utter despair; for
though she would not consort with her husband herself, she could not
endure that any other should do so.
But, to countervail this grievous offence, our saintly and afflicted
dame, in due time, was safely delivered of a fine boy, whom the laird
acknowledged as his son and heir, and had him christened by his own
name, and nursed in his own premises. He gave the nurse permission to
take the boy to his mother's presence if ever she should desire to see
him; but, strange as it may appear, she never once desired to see him
from the day that he was born. The boy grew up, and was a healthful and
happy child; and, in the course of another year, the lady presented him
with a brother. A brother he certainly was, in the eye of the law, and
it is more than probable that he was his brother in reality. But the
laird thought otherwise; and, though he knew and acknowledged that he
was obliged to support and provide for him, he refused to acknowledge
him in other respects. He neither would countenance the banquet, nor
take the baptismal vows on him in the child's name; of course, the poor
boy had to live and remain an alien from the visible church for a year
and a day; at which time, Mr. Wringhim, out of pity and kindness, took
the lady herself as sponsor for the boy, and baptized him by the name
of Robert Wringhim,—that being the noted divine's own name.
George was brought up with his father, and educated partly at the
parish-school, and partly at home, by a tutor hired for the purpose. He
was a generous and kind-hearted youth; always ready to oblige, and
hardly ever dissatisfied with any body. Robert was brought up with Mr.
Wringhim, the laird paying a certain allowance for him yearly; and
there the boy was early inured to all the sternness and severity of his
pastor's arbitrary and unyielding creed. He was taught to pray twice
every day, and seven times on Sabbath days; but he was only to pray for
the elect, and, like David of old, doom all that were aliens from God
to destruction. He had never, in that family into which he had been as
it were adopted, heard ought but evil spoken of his reputed father and
brother; consequently he held them in utter abhorrence, and prayed
against them every day, often "that the old hoary sinner might be cut
off in the full flush of his iniquity, and be carried quick into hell;
and that the young stem of the corrupt trunk might also be taken from
a world that he disgraced, but that his sins might be pardoned, because
he knew no better."
Such were the tenets in which it would appear young Robert was bred.
He was an acute boy, an excellent learner, had ardent and ungovernable
passions, and withal, a sternness of demeanour from which other boys
shrunk. He was the best grammarian, the best reader, writer, and
accountant in the various classes that he attended, and was fond of
writing essays on controverted points of theology, for which he got
prizes, and great praise from his guardian and mother. George was much
behind him in scholastic acquirements, but greatly his superior in
personal prowess, form, feature, and all that constitutes gentility in
deportment and appearance. The laird had often manifested to Miss Logan
an earnest wish that the two young men should never meet, or at all
events that they should be as little conversant as possible; and Miss
Logan, who was as much attached to George as if he had been her own
son, took every precaution, while he was a boy, that he should never
meet with his brother; but as they advanced towards manhood, this
became impracticable. The lady was removed from her apartments in her
husband's house to Glasgow, to her great content; and all to prevent
the young laird being tainted with the company of her and her second
son; for the laird had felt the effects of the principles they
professed, and dreaded them more than persecution, fire, and sword.
During all the dreadful times that had overpast, though the laird had
been a moderate man, he had still leaned to the side of the kingly
prerogative, and had escaped confiscation and fines, without ever
taking any active hand in suppressing the Covenanters. But after
experiencing a specimen of their tenets and manner in his wife, from a
secret favourer of them and their doctrines, he grew alarmed at the
prevalence of such stern and factious principles, now that there was no
check nor restraint upon them; and from that time he began to set
himself against them, joining with the cavalier party of that day in
all their proceedings.
It so happened, that, under the influence of the Earls of Seafield
and Tullibardine, he was returned for a Member of Parliament in the
famous session that sat at Edinburgh, when the Duke of Queensberry was
commissioner, and in which party spirit ran to such an extremity. The
young laird went with his father to the court, and remained in town all
the time that the session lasted; and as all interested people of both
factions flocked to the town at that period, so the important Mr.
Wringhim was there among the rest, during the greater part of the time,
blowing the coal of revolutionary principles with all his might, in
every society to which he could obtain admission. He was a great
favourite with some of the west country gentlemen of that faction, by
reason of his unbending impudence. No opposition could for a moment
cause him either to blush, or retract one item that he had advanced.
Therefore the Duke of Argyle and his friends made such use of him as
sportsmen often do of terriers, to start the game, and make a great
yelping noise to let them know whither the chace is proceeding. They
often did this out of sport, in order to teaze their opponent; for of
all pesterers that ever fastened on man he was the most insufferable:
knowing that his coat protected him from manual chastisement, he spared
no acrimony, and delighted in the chagrin and anger of those with whom
he contended. But he was sometimes likewise of real use to the heads of
the presbyterian faction, and therefore was admitted to their tables,
and of course conceived himself a very great man.
His ward accompanied him; and very shortly after their arrival in
Edinburgh, Robert, for the first time, met with the young laird his
brother, in a match at tennis. The prowess and agility of the young
squire drew forth the loudest plaudits of approval from his associates,
and his own exertion alone carried the game every time on the one side,
and that so far as all along to count three for their one. The hero's
name soon ran round the circle, and when his brother Robert, who was
an onlooker, learned who it was that was gaining so much applause, he
came and stood close beside him all the time that the game lasted,
always now and then putting in a cutting remark by way of mockery.
George could not help perceiving him, not only on account of his
impertinent remarks, but he, moreover, stood so near him that he
several times impeded him in his rapid evolutions, and of course got
himself shoved aside in no very ceremonious way. Instead of making him
keep his distance, these rude shocks and pushes, accompanied sometimes
with hasty curses, only made him cling the closer to this king of the
game. He seemed determined to maintain his right to his place as an
onlooker, as well as any of those engaged in the game, and if they had
tried him at an argument, he would have carried his point: or perhaps
he wished to quarrel with this spark of his jealousy and aversion, and
draw the attention of the gay crowd to himself by these means; for,
like his guardian, he knew no other pleasure but what consisted in
opposition. George took him for some impertinent student of divinity,
rather set upon a joke than any thing else. He perceived a lad with
black clothes, and a methodistical face, whose countenance and eye he
disliked exceedingly, several times in his way, and that was all the
notice he took of him the first time they two met. But the next day,
and every succeeding one, the same devilish-looking youth attended him
as constantly as his shadow; was always in his way as with intention to
impede him, and ever and anon his deep and malignant eye met those of
his elder brother with a glance so fierce that it sometimes startled
The very next time that George was engaged at tennis, he had not
struck the ball above twice till the same intrusive being was again in
his way. The party played for considerable stakes that day, namely, a
dinner and wine at the Black Bull tavern; and George, as the hero and
head of his party, was much interested in its honour; consequently, the
sight of this moody and hellish-looking student affected him in no very
pleasant manner. "Pray, Sir, be so good as keep without the range of
the ball," said he.
"Is there any law or enactment that can compel me to do so?" said
the other, biting his lip with scorn.
"If there is not, they are here that shall compel you," returned
George: "so, friend, I rede you to be on your guard."
As he said this, a flush of anger glowed in his handsome face, and
flashed from his sparkling blue eye; but it was a stranger to both, and
momently took its departure. The black-coated youth set up his cap
before, brought his heavy brows over his deep dark eyes, put his hands
in the pockets of his black plush breeches, and stepped a little
farther into the semi-circle, immediately on his brother's right hand,
than he had ever ventured to do before. There he set himself firm on
his legs, and, with a face as demure as death, seemed determined to
keep his ground. He pretended to be following the ball with his eyes;
but every moment they were glancing aside at George. One of the
competitors chanced to say rashly, in the moment of exultation, "That's
a d—d fine blow, George!" On which the intruder took up the word, as
characteristic of the competitors, and repeated it every stroke that
was given, making such a ludicrous use of it, that several of the
on-lookers were compelled to laugh immoderately; but the players were
terribly nettled at it, as he really contrived, by dint of sliding in
some canonical terms, to render the competitors and their game
But matters at length came to a crisis that put them beyond sport.
George, in flying backward to gain the point at which the ball was
going to light, came inadvertently so rudely in contact with this
obstreperous interloper, that he not only overthrew him, but also got a
grievous fall over his legs; and, as he arose, the other made a spurn
at him with his foot, which, if it had hit to its aim, would
undoubtedly have finished the course of the young laird of Dalcastle
and Balgrennan. George, being irritated beyond measure, as may well be
conceived, especially at the deadly stroke aimed at him, struck the
assailant with his racket, rather slightly, but so that his mouth and
nose gushed out blood; and, at the same time, he said, turning to his
cronies,—"Does any of you know who the infernal puppy is?"
"Do you not know, Sir?" said one of the onlookers, a stranger: "The
gentleman is your own brother, Sir—Mr. Robert Wringhim Colwan!"
"No, not Colwan, Sir," said Robert, putting his hands in his
pockets, and setting himself still farther forward than before,—"not
a Colwan, Sir; henceforth I disclaim the name."
"No, certainly not," repeated George: "My mother's son you may
be,—but not a Colwan! There you are right." Then turning round to his
informer, he said, "Mercy be about us, Sir! is this the crazy
minister's son from Glasgow?"
This question was put in the irritation of the moment; but it was
too rude, and too far out of place, and no one deigned any answer to
it. He felt the reproof, and felt it deeply; seeming anxious for some
opportunity to make an acknowledgment, or some reparation.
In the meantime, young Wringhim was an object to all of the
uttermost disgust. The blood flowing from his mouth and nose he took no
pains to stem, neither did he so much as wipe it away; so that it
spread over all his cheeks, and breast, even off at his toes. In that
state did he take up his station in the middle of the competitors; and
he did not now keep his place, but ran about, impeding every one who
attempted to make at the ball. They loaded him with execrations, but it
availed nothing; he seemed courting persecution and buffetings, keeping
stedfastly to his old joke of damnation, and marring the game so
completely, that, in spite of every effort on the part of the players,
he forced them to stop their game, and give it up. He was such a
rueful-looking object, covered with blood, that none of them had the
heart to kick him, although it appeared the only thing he wanted; and
as for George, he said not another word to him, either in anger or
When the game was fairly given up, and the party were washing their
hands in the stone fount, some of them besought Robert Wringhim to wash
himself; but he mocked at them, and said, he was much better as he
was. George, at length, came forward abashedly toward him, and
said,—"I have been greatly to blame, Robert, and am very sorry for
what I have done. But, in the first instance, I erred through
ignorance, not knowing you were my brother, which you certainly are;
and, in the second, through a momentary irritation, for which I am
ashamed. I pray you, therefore, to pardon me, and give me your hand."
As he said this, he held out his hand toward his polluted brother;
but the froward predestinarian took not his from his breeches pocket,
but lifting his foot, he gave his brother's hand a kick. "I'll give you
what will suit such a hand better than mine," said he, with a sneer.
And then, turning lightly about, he added,—"Are there to be no more
of these d—d fine blows, gentlemen? For shame, to give up such a
profitable and edifying game!"
"This is too bad," said George. "But, since it is thus, I have the
less to regret." And, having made this general remark, he took no more
note of the uncouth aggressor. But the persecution of the latter
terminated not on the play-ground: he ranked up among them, bloody and
disgusting as he was, and, keeping close by his brother's side, he
marched along with the party all the way to the Black Bull. Before they
got there, a great number of boys and idle people had surrounded them,
hooting and incommoding them exceedingly, so that they were glad to get
into the inn; and the unaccountable monster actually tried to get in
alongst with them, to make one of the party at dinner. But the
innkeeper and his men, getting the hint, by force prevented him from
entering, although he attempted it again and again, both by telling
lies and offering a bribe. Finding he could not prevail, he set to
exciting the mob at the door to acts of violence; in which he had like
to have succeeded. The landlord had no other shift, at last, but to
send privately for two officers, and have him carried to the
guard-house; and the hilarity and joy of the party of young gentlemen,
for the evening, was quite spoiled, by the inauspicious termination of
The Rev. Robert Wringhim was now to send for, to release his beloved
ward. The messenger found him at table, with a number of the leaders of
the Whig faction, the Marquis of Annandale being in the chair; and the
prisoner's note being produced, Wringhim read it aloud, accompanying it
with some explanatory remarks. The circumstances of the case being thus
magnified and distorted, it excited the utmost abhorrence, both of the
deed and the perpetrators, among the assembled faction. They declaimed
against the act as an unnatural attempt on the character, and even the
life, of an unfortunate brother, who had been expelled from his
father's house. And, as party spirit was the order of the day, an
attempt was made to lay the burden of it to that account. In short, the
young culprit got some of the best blood of the land to enter as his
securities, and was set at liberty. But when Wringhim perceived the
plight that he was in, he took him, as he was, and presented him to his
honourable patrons. This raised the indignation against the young laird
and his associates a thousand fold, which actually roused the party to
temporary madness. They were, perhaps, a little excited by the wine
and spirits they had swallowed; else a casual quarrel between two
young men, at tennis, could not have driven them to such extremes. But
certain it is, that from one at first arising to address the party on
the atrocity of the offence, both in a moral and political point of
view, on a sudden there were six on their feet, at the same time,
expatiating on it; and, in a very short time thereafter, every one in
the room was up, talking with the utmost vociferation, all on the same
subject, and all taking the same side in the debate.
In the midst of this confusion, some one or other issued from the
house, which was at the back of the Canongate, calling out,—"A plot,
a plot! Treason, treason! Down with the bloody incendiaries at the
The concourse of people that were assembled in Edinburgh at that
time was prodigious; and as they were all actuated by political
motives, they wanted only a ready-blown coal to set the mountain on
fire. The evening being fine, and the streets thronged, the cry ran
from mouth to mouth through the whole city. More than that, the mob
that had of late been gathered to the door of the Black Bull, had, by
degrees, dispersed; but, they being young men, and idle vagrants, they
had only spread themselves over the rest of the street to lounge in
search of farther amusement: consequently, a word was sufficient to
send them back to their late rendezvous, where they had previously
witnessed something they did not much approve of.
The master of the tavern was astonished at seeing the mob again
assembling; and that with such hurry and noise. But his inmates being
all of the highest respectability, he judged himself sure of
protection, or, at least, of indemnity. He had two large parties in his
house at the time; the largest of which was of the Revolutionist
faction. The other consisted of our young tennis-players, and their
associates, who were all of the Jacobite order; or, at all events,
leaned to the Episcopal side. The largest party were in a front-room;
and the attack of the mob fell first on their windows, though rather
with fear and caution. Jingle went one pane; then a loud hurra; and
that again was followed by a number of voices, endeavouring to restrain
the indignation from venting itself in destroying the windows, and to
turn it on the inmates. The Whigs, calling the landlord, inquired what
the assault meant: he cunningly answered, that he suspected it was some
of the youths of the Cavalier, or High-Church party, exciting the mob
against them. The party consisted mostly of young gentlemen, by that
time in a key to engage in any row; and, at all events, to suffer
nothing from the other party, against whom their passions were mightily
The landlord, therefore, had no sooner given them the spirit-rousing
intelligence, than every one, as by instinct, swore his own natural
oath, and grasped his own natural weapon. A few of those of the highest
rank were armed with swords, which they boldly drew; those of the
subordinate orders immediately flew to such weapons as the room,
kitchen, and scullery afforded;—such as tongs, pokers, spits, racks,
and shovels; and breathing vengeance on the prelatic party, the
children of Antichrist and the heirs of d—n—t—n! the barterers of
the liberties of their country, and betrayers of the most sacred
trust,— thus elevated, and thus armed, in the cause of right,
justice, and liberty, our heroes rushed to the street, and attacked the
mob with such violence, that they broke the mass in a moment, and
dispersed their thousands like chaff before the wind. The other party
of young Jacobites, who sat in a room farther from the front, and were
those against whom the fury of the mob was meant to have been
directed, knew nothing of this second uproar, till the noise of the
sally made by the Whigs assailed their ears; being then informed that
the mob had attacked the house on account of the treatment they
themselves had given to a young gentleman of the adverse faction, and
that another jovial party had issued from the house in their defence,
and was now engaged in an unequal combat, the sparks likewise flew to
the field to back their defenders with all their prowess, without
troubling their heads about who they were.
A mob is like a spring-tide in an eastern storm, that retires only
to return with more overwhelming fury. The crowd was taken by surprise,
when such a strong and well-armed party issued from the house with so
great fury, laying all prostrate that came in their way. Those who were
next to the door, and were, of course, the first whom the imminent
danger assailed, rushed backward among the crowd with their whole
force. The Black Bull standing in a small square half way between the
High Street and the Cowgate, and the entrance to it being by two
closes, into these the pressure outward was simultaneous, and thousands
were moved to an involuntary flight they knew not why.
But the High Street of Edinburgh, which they soon reached, is a
dangerous place in which to make an open attack upon a mob. And it
appears that the entrances to the tavern had been somewhere near to the
Cross, on the south side of the street; for the crowd fled with great
expedition, both to the east and west, and the conquerors, separating
themselves as chance directed, pursued impetuously, wounding and
maiming as they flew. But, it so chanced, that before either of the
wings had followed the flying squadrons of their enemies for the space
of a hundred yards each way, the devil an enemy they had to pursue! the
multitude had vanished like so many thousands of phantoms! What could
our heroes do?—Why, they faced about to return toward their citadel,
the Black Bull. But that feat was not so easily, nor so readily
accomplished, as they divined. The unnumbered alleys on each side of
the street had swallowed up the multitude in a few seconds; but from
these they were busy reconnoitring; and, perceiving the deficiency in
the number of their assailants, the rush from both sides of the street
was as rapid, and as wonderful, as the disappearance of the crowd had
been a few minutes before. Each close vomited out its levies, and
these better armed with missiles than when they sought it for a
temporary retreat. Woe then to our two columns of victorious Whigs! The
mob actually closed around them as they would have swallowed them up;
and, in the meanwhile, shower after shower of the most abominable
weapons of offence were rained in upon them. If the gentlemen were
irritated before, this inflamed them still farther; but their danger
was now so apparent, they could not shut their eyes on it, therefore,
both parties, as if actuated by the same spirit, made a desperate
effort to join, and the greater part effected it; but some were
knocked down, and others were separated from their friends, and blithe
to become silent members of the mob.
The battle now raged immediately in front of the closes leading to
the Black Bull; the small body of Whig gentlemen was hardly bested, and
it is likely would have been overcome and trampled down every man, had
they not been then and there joined by the young Cavaliers; who, fresh
to arms, broke from the wynd, opened the head of the passage, laid
about them manfully, and thus kept up the spirits of the exasperated
Whigs, who were the men in fact that wrought the most deray among the
The town-guard was now on the alert; and two companies of the
Cameronian regiment, with the Hon. Captain Douglas, rushed down from
the Castle to the scene of action; but, for all the noise and hubbub
that these caused in the street, the combat had become so close and
inveterate, that numbers of both sides were taken prisoners fighting
hand to hand, and could scarcely be separated when the guardsmen and
soldiers had them by the necks.
Great was the alarm and confusion that night in Edinburgh; for every
one concluded that it was a party scuffle, and, the two parties being
so equal in power, the most serious consequences were anticipated. The
agitation was so prevailing, that every party in the town, great and
small, was broken up; and the lord-commissioner thought proper to go
to the council-chamber himself, even at that late hour, accompanied by
the sheriffs of Edinburgh and Linlithgow, with sundry noblemen besides,
in order to learn something of the origin of the affray.
For a long time the court was completely puzzled. Every gentleman
brought in exclaimed against the treatment he had received, in most
bitter terms, blaming a mob set on him and his friends by the adverse
party, and matters looked extremely ill, until at length they began to
perceive that they were examining gentlemen of both parties, and that
they had been doing so from the beginning, almost alternately, so
equally had the prisoners been taken from both parties. Finally, it
turned out, that a few gentlemen, two-thirds of whom were strenuous
Whigs themselves, had joined in mauling the whole Whig population of
Edinburgh. The investigation disclosed nothing the effect of which was
not ludicrous; and the Duke of Queensberry, whose aim was at that time
to conciliate the two factions, tried all that he could to turn the
whole fracas into a joke—an unlucky frolic, where no ill was meant on
either side, and which yet had been productive of a great deal.
The greater part of the people went home satisfied; but not so the
Rev. Robert Wringhim. He did all that he could to inflame both judges
and populace against the young Cavaliers, especially against the young
Laird of Dalcastle, whom he represented as an incendiary, set on by an
unnatural parent to slander his mother, and make away with a hapless
and only brother; and, in truth, that declaimer against all human merit
had that sort of powerful, homely, and bitter eloquence, which seldom
missed affecting his hearers: the consequence at that time was, that
he made the unfortunate affair between the two brothers appear in
extremely bad colours, and the populace retired to their homes
impressed with no very favourable opinion of either the Laird of
Dalcastle or his son George, neither of whom were there present to
speak for themselves.
As for Wringhim himself, he went home to his lodgings, filled with
gall and with spite against the young laird, whom he was made to
believe the aggressor, and that intentionally. But most of all was he
filled with indignation against the father, whom he held in abhorrence
at all times, and blamed solely for this unmannerly attack made on his
favourite ward, namesake, and adopted son; and for the public
imputation of a crime to his own reverence, in calling the lad his son,
and thus charging him with a sin against which he was well known to
have levelled all the arrows of church censure with unsparing might.
But, filled as his heart was with some portion of these bad
feelings, to which all flesh is subject, he kept, nevertheless, the
fear of the Lord always before his eyes so far as never to omit any of
the external duties of religion, and farther than that, man hath no
power to pry. He lodged with the family of a Mr. Miller, whose lady was
originally from Glasgow, and had been a hearer, and, of course, a great
admirer of Mr. Wringhim. In that family he made public worship every
evening; and that night, in his petitions at a throne of grace, he
prayed for so many vials of wrath to be poured on the head of some
particular sinner, that the hearers trembled, and stopped their ears.
But that he might not proceed with so violent a measure, amounting to
excommunication, without due scripture warrant, he began the exercise
of the evening by singing the following verses, which it is a pity
should ever have been admitted into a Christian psalmody, being so
adverse to all its mild and benevolent principles:—
Set thou the wicked over him,
And upon his right hand
Give thou his greatest enemy,
Even Satan, leave to stand.
And when by thee he shall be judged,
Let him remembered be;
And let his prayer be turned to sin,
When he shall call on thee. Few be his days; and in his room
His charge another take;
His children let be fatherless;
His wife a widow make:
Let God his father's wickedness
Still to remembrance call;
And never let his mother's sin
Be blotted out at all.
As he in cursing pleasure took,
So let it to him fall;
As he delighted not to bless,
So bless him not at all.
As cursing he like clothes put on,
Into his bowels so,
Like water, and into his bones
Like oil, down let it go.
Young Wringhim only knew the full purport of this spiritual song;
and went to his bed better satisfied than ever, that his father and
brother were cast-aways, reprobates, aliens from the church and the
true faith, and cursed in time and eternity.
The next day George and his companions met as usual,—all who were
not seriously wounded of them. But as they strolled about the city, the
rancorous eye and the finger of scorn was pointed against them. None of
them was at first aware of the reason; but it threw a damp over their
spirits and enjoyments, which they could not master. They went to take
a forenoon game at their old play of tennis, not on a match, but by way
of improving themselves; but they had not well taken their places till
young Wringhim appeared in his old station, at his brother's right
hand, with looks more demure and determined than ever. His lips were
primmed so close that his mouth was hardly discernible, and his dark
deep eye flashed gleams of holy indignation on the godless set, but
particularly on his brother. His presence acted as a mildew on all
social intercourse or enjoyment; the game was marred, and ended ere
ever it was well begun. There were whisperings apart—the party
separated; and, in order to shake off the the blighting influence of
this dogged persecutor, they entered sundry houses of their
acquaintances, with an understanding that they were to meet on the
Links for a game at cricket.
They did so; and, stripping off part of their clothes, they began
that violent and spirited game. They had not played five minutes, till
Wringhim was stalking in the midst of them, and totally impeding the
play. A cry arose from all corners of "O, this will never do. Kick him
out of the playground! Knock down the scoundrel; or bind him, and let
him lie in peace."
"By no means," cried George: "it is evident he wants nothing else.
Pray do not humour him so much as to touch him with either foot or
finger." Then turning to a friend, he said in a whisper, "Speak to
him, Gordon; he surely will not refuse to let us have the ground to
ourselves, if you request it of him."
Gordon went up to him, and requested of him, civilly, but ardently,
"to retire to a certain distance, else none of them could or would be
answerable, however sore he might be hurt."
He turned disdainfully on his heel, uttered a kind of pulpit hem!
and then added, "I will take my chance of that; hurt me, any of you, at
The young gentlemen smiled, through spite and disdain of the dogged
animal. Gordon followed him up, and tried to remonstrate with him; but
he let him know that "it was his pleasure to be there at that time;
and, unless he could demonstrate to him what superior right he and his
party had to that ground, in preference to him, and to the exclusion of
all others, he was determined to assert his right, and the rights of
his fellow-citizens, by keeping possession of whatsoever part of that
common field he chose."
"You are no gentleman, Sir," said Gordon.
"Are you one, Sir?" said the other.
"Yes, Sir, I will let you know that I am, by G—!"
"Then, thanks be to Him whose name you have profaned, I am none. If
one of the party be a gentleman, I do hope in God I am not!"
It was now apparent to them all that he was courting obloquy and
manual chastisement from their hands, if by any means he could provoke
them to the deed; and, apprehensive that he had some sinister and
deep-laid design in hunting after such a singular favour, they wisely
restrained one another from inflicting the punishment that each of them
yearned to bestow, personally, and which he so well deserved.
But the unpopularity of the Younger George Colwan could no longer be
concealed from his associates. It was manifested wherever the populace
were assembled; and his young and intimate friend, Adam Gordon, was
obliged to warn him of the circumstance, that he might not be surprised
at the gentlemen of their acquaintance withdrawing themselves from his
society, as they could not be seen with him without being insulted.
George thanked him; and it was agreed between them, that the former
should keep himself retired during the daytime while he remained in
Edinburgh, and that at night they should always meet together, along
with such of their companions as were disengaged.
George found it every day more and more necessary to adhere to this
system of seclusion; for it was not alone the hisses of the boys and
populace that pursued him,—a fiend of more malignant aspect was ever
at his elbow, in the form of his brother. To whatever place of
amusement he betook himself, and however well he concealed his
intentions of going there from all flesh living, there was his brother
Wringhim also, and always within a few yards of him, generally about
the same distance, and ever and anon darting looks at him that chilled
his very soul. They were looks that cannot be described; but they were
felt piercing to the bosom's deepest core. They affected even the
on-lookers in a very particular manner, for all whose eyes caught a
glimpse of these hideous glances followed them to the object toward
which they were darted: the gentlemanly and mild demeanour of that
object generally calmed their startled apprehensions; for no one ever
yet noted the glances of the young man's eye in the black coat, at the
face of his brother, who did not at first manifest strong symptoms of
George became utterly confounded; not only at the import of this
persecution, but how in the world it came to pass that this
unaccountable being knew all his motions, and every intention of his
heart, as it were intuitively. On consulting his own previous feelings
and resolutions, he found that the circumstances of his going to such
and such a place were often the most casual incidents in nature—the
caprice of a moment had carried him there, and yet he had never sat or
stood many minutes till there was the self-same being, always in the
same position with regard to himself, as regularly as the shadow is
cast from the substance, or the ray of light from the opposing denser
For instance, he remembered one day of setting out with the
intention of going to attend divine worship in the High Church, and
when within a short space of its door, he was overtaken by young
Kilpatrick of Closeburn, who was bound to the Grey-Friars to see his
sweetheart, as he said; "and if you will go with me, Colwan," said he,
"I will let you see her too, and then you will be just as far forward
as I am."
George assented at once, and went; and after taking his seat, he
leaned his head forward on the pew to repeat over to himself a short
ejaculatory prayer, as had always been his custom on entering the house
of God. When he had done, he lifted his eyes naturally toward that
point on his right hand where the fierce apparition of his brother had
been wont to meet his view: there he was, in the same habit, form,
demeanour, and precise point of distance, as usual! George again laid
down his head, and his mind was so astounded, that he had nearly fallen
into a swoon. He tried shortly after to muster up courage to look at
the speaker, at the congregation, and at Captain Kilpatrick's
sweetheart in particular; but the fiendish glances of the young man in
the black clothes were too appalling to be withstood,—his eye caught
them whether he was looking that way or not: at length his courage was
fairly mastered, and he was obliged to look down during the remainder
of the service.
By night or by day it was the same. In the gallery of the Parliament
House, in the boxes of the play-house, in the church, in the assembly,
in the streets, suburbs, and the fields; and every day, and every hour,
from the first rencounter of the two, the attendance became more and
more constant, more inexplicable, and altogether more alarming and
insufferable, until at last George was fairly driven from society, and
forced to spend his days in his own and his father's lodgings with
closed doors. Even there, he was constantly harassed with the idea,
that the next time he lifted his eyes, he would to a certainty see that
face, the most repulsive to all his feelings of aught the earth
contained. The attendance of that brother was now become like the
attendance of a demon on some devoted being that had sold himself to
destruction; his approaches as undiscerned, and his looks as fraught
with hideous malignity. It was seldom that he saw him either following
him in the streets, or entering any house or church after him; he only
appeared in his place, George wist not how, or whence; and, having
sped so ill in his first friendly approaches, he had never spoken to
his equivocal attendant a second time.
It came at length into George's head, as he was pondering, by
himself, on the circumstances of this extraordinary attendance, that
perhaps his brother had relented, and, though of so sullen and
unaccommodating a temper that he would not acknowledge it, or beg a
reconciliation, it might be for that very purpose that he followed his
steps night and day in that extraordinary manner. "I cannot for my life
see for what other purpose it can be," thought he. "He never offers to
attempt my life; nor dares he, if he had the inclination; therefore,
although his manner is peculiarly repulsive to me, I shall not have my
mind burdened with the reflection, that my own mother's son yearned for
a reconciliation with me, and was repulsed by my haughty and insolent
behaviour. The next time he comes to my hand, I am resolved that I will
accost him as one brother ought to address another, whatever it may
cost me; and, if I am still flouted with disdain, then shall the blame
rest with him."
After this generous resolution, it was a good while before his
gratuitous attendant appeared at his side again; and George began to
think that his visits were discontinued. The hope was a relief that
could not be calculated; but still George had a feeling that it was
too supreme to last. His enemy had been too pertinacious to abandon his
design, whatever it was. He, however, began to indulge in a little more
liberty, and for several days he enjoyed it with impunity.
George was, from infancy, of a stirring active disposition, and
could not endure confinement; and, having been of late much restrained
in his youthful exercises by this singular persecutor, he grew uneasy
under such restraint, and, one morning, chancing to awaken very early,
he arose to make an excursion to the top of Arthur's Seat, to breathe
the breeze of the dawning, and see the sun arise out of the eastern
ocean. The morning was calm and serene; and as he walked down the south
back of the Canongate, toward the Palace, the haze was so close around
him that he could not see the houses on the opposite side of the way.
As he passed the lord-commissioner's house, the guards were in
attendance, who cautioned him not to go by the Palace, as all the gates
would be shut and guarded for an hour to come, on which he went by the
back of St. Anthony's gardens, and found his way into that little
romantic glade adjoining to the Saint's chapel and well. He was still
involved in a blue haze, like a dense smoke, but yet in the midst of
it the respiration was the most refreshing and delicious. The grass and
the flowers were loaden with dew; and, on taking off his hat to wipe
his forehead, he perceived that the black glossy fur of which his
chaperon was wrought, was all covered with a tissue of the most
delicate silver— a fairy web, composed of little spheres, so minute
that no eye could discern any one of them; yet there they were shining
in lovely millions. Afraid of defacing so beautiful and so delicate a
garnish, he replaced his hat with the greatest caution, and went on his
way light of heart.
As he approached the swire at the head of the dell,—that little
delightful verge from which in one moment the eastern limits and shores
of Lothian arise on the view,—as he approached it, I say, and a
little space from the height, he beheld, to his astonishment, a bright
halo in the cloud of haze, that rose in a semi-circle over his head
like a pale rainbow. He was struck motionless at the view of the lovely
vision; for it so chanced that he had never seen the same appearance
before, though common at early morn. But he soon perceived the cause of
the phenomenon, and that it proceeded from the rays of the sun from a
pure unclouded morning sky striking upon this dense vapour which
refracted them. But the better all the works of nature are understood,
the more they will be ever admired. That was a scene that would have
entranced the man of science with delight, but which the uninitiated
and sordid man would have regarded less than the mole rearing up his
hill in silence and in darkness.
George did admire this halo of glory, which still grew wider, and
less defined, as he approached the surface of the cloud. But, to his
utter amazement and supreme delight, he found, on reaching the top of
Arthur's Seat, that this sublunary rainbow, this terrestrial glory, was
spread in its most vivid hues beneath his feet. Still he could not
perceive the body of the sun, although the light behind him was
dazzling; but the cloud of haze lying dense in that deep dell that
separates the hill from the rocks of Salisbury, and the dull shadow of
the hill mingling with that cloud, made the dell a pit of darkness. On
that shadowy cloud was the lovely rainbow formed, spreading itself on a
horizontal plain, and having a slight and brilliant shade of all the
colours of the heavenly bow, but all of them paler and less defined.
But this terrestrial phenomenon of the early morn cannot be better
delineated than by the name given of it by the shepherd boys, "The
little wee ghost of the rainbow."
Such was the description of the morning, and the wild shades of the
hill, that George gave to his father and Mr. Adam Gordon that same day
on which he had witnessed them; and it is necessary that the reader
should comprehend something of their nature, to understand what follows.
He seated himself on the pinnacle of the rocky precipice, a little
within the top of the hill to the westward, and, with a light and
buoyant heart, viewed the beauties of the morning, and inhaled its
salubrious breeze. "Here," thought he, "I can converse with nature
without disturbance, and without being intruded on by any appalling or
obnoxious visitor." The idea of his brother's dark and malevolent looks
coming at that moment across his mind, he turned his eyes instinctively
to the right, to the point where that unwelcome guest was wont to make
his appearance. Gracious Heaven! What an apparition was there presented
to his view! He saw, delineated in the cloud, the shoulders, arms, and
features of a human being of the most dreadful aspect. The face was the
face of his brother, but dilated to twenty times the natural size. Its
dark eyes gleamed on him through the mist, while every furrow of its
hideous brow frowned deep as the ravines on the brow of the hill.
George started, and his hair stood up in bristles as he gazed on this
horrible monster. He saw every feature, and every line of the face,
distinctly, as it gazed on him with an intensity that was hardly
brookable. Its eyes were fixed on him, in the same manner as those of
some carnivorous animal fixed on its prey; and yet there was fear and
trembling, in these unearthly features, as plainly depicted as
murderous malice. The giant apparition seemed sometimes to be cowering
down as in terror, so that nothing but its brow and eyes were seen;
still these never turned one moment from their object —again it rose
imperceptibly up, and began to approach with great caution; and as it
neared, the dimensions of its form lessened, still continuing, however,
far above the natural size.
George conceived it to be a spirit. He could conceive it to be
nothing else; and he took it for some horrid demon by which he was
haunted, that had assumed the features of his brother in every
lineament, but in taking on itself the human form, had miscalculated
dreadfully on the size, and presented itself thus to him in a blown-up,
dilated frame of embodied air, exhaled from the caverns of death or
the regions of devouring fire. He was farther confirmed in the belief
that it was a malignant spirit, on perceiving that it approached him
across the front of a precipice, where there was not footing for thing
of mortal frame. Still, what with terror and astonishment, he continued
rivetted to the spot, till it approached, as he deemed, to within two
yards of him; and then, perceiving that it was setting itself to make a
violent spring on him, he started to his feet and fled distractedly in
the opposite direction, keeping his eye cast behind him lest he had
been seized in that dangerous place. But the very first bolt that he
made in his flight he came in contact with a real body of flesh and
blood, and that with such violence that both went down among some
scragged rocks, and George rolled over the other. The being called out
"Murder;" and, rising, fled precipitately. George then perceived that
it was his brother; and, being confounded between the shadow and the
substance, he knew not what he was doing or what he had done; and there
being only one natural way of retreat from the brink of the rock, he
likewise arose and pursued the affrighted culprit with all his speed
towards the top of the hill. Wringhim was braying out "Murder!
murder!" at which George being disgusted, and his spirits all in a
ferment from some hurried idea of intended harm, the moment he came up
with the craven he seized him rudely by the shoulder, and clapped his
hand on his mouth. "Murder, you beast!" said he; "what do you mean by
roaring out murder in that way? Who the devil is murdering you, or
offering to murder you?"
Wringhim forced his mouth from under his brother's hand, and roared
with redoubled energy, "Eh! Egh! murder! murder!" &c. George had felt
resolute to put down this shocking alarm, lest some one might hear it
and fly to the spot, or draw inferences widely different from the
truth; and, perceiving the terror of this elect youth to be so great
that expostulation was vain, he seized him by the mouth and nose with
his left hand, so strenuously, that he sunk his fingers into his
cheeks. But the poltroon still attempting to bray out, George gave him
such a stunning blow with his fist on the left temple, that he
crumbled, as it were, to the ground, but more from the effects of
terror than those of the blow. His nose, however, again gushed out
blood, a system of defence which seemed as natural to him as that
resorted to by the race of stinkards. He then raised himself on his
knees and hams, and raising up his ghastly face, while the blood
streamed over both ears, he besought his life of his brother, in the
most abject whining manner, gaping and blubbering most piteously.
"Tell me then, Sir," said George, resolved to make the most of the
wretch's terror—"tell me for what purpose it is that you thus haunt
my steps? Tell me plainly, and instantly, else I will throw you from
the verge of that precipice."
"Oh, I will never do it again! I will never do it again! Spare my
life, dear, good brother! Spare my life! Sure I never did you any hurt?"
"Swear to me, then, by the God that made you, that you will never
henceforth follow after me to torment me with your hellish threatening
looks; swear that you will never again come into my presence without
being invited. Will you take an oath to this effect?"
"O yes! I will, I will!"
"But this is not all: you must tell me for what purpose you sought
me out here this morning?"
"Oh, brother! for nothing but your good. I had nothing at heart but
your unspeakable profit, and great and endless good."
"So then, you indeed knew that I was here?"
"I was told so by a friend, but I did not believe him; a—a—at
least I did not know it was true till I saw you."
"Tell me this one thing, then, Robert, and all shall be forgotten
and forgiven,—Who was that friend?"
"You do not know him."
"How then does he know me?"
"I cannot tell."
"Was he here present with you to-day?"
"Yes; he was not far distant. He came to this hill with me."
"Where then is he now?"
"I cannot tell."
"Then, wretch, confess that the devil was that friend who told you I
was here, and who came here with you? None else could possibly know of
my being here."
"Ah! how little you know of him! Would you argue that there is
neither man nor spirit endowed with so much foresight as to deduce
natural conclusions from previous actions and incidents but the devil?
Alas, brother! But why should I wonder at such abandoned notions and
principles? It was fore-ordained that you should cherish them, and
that they should be the ruin of your soul and body, before the world
was framed. Be assured of this, however, that I had no aim in seeking
you but your good!"
"Well, Robert, I will believe it. I am disposed to be hasty and
passionate: it is a fault in my nature; but I never meant, or wished
you evil; and God is my witness that I would as soon stretch out my
hand to my own life, or my father's, as to yours."—At these words,
Wringhim uttered a hollow exulting laugh, put his hands in his pockets,
and withdrew a space to his accustomed distance. George continued: "And
now, once for all, I request that we may exchange forgiveness, and that
we may part and remain friends."
"Would such a thing be expedient, think you? Or consistent with the
glory of God? I doubt it."
"I can think of nothing that would be more so. Is it not consistent
with every precept of the Gospel? Come, brother, say that our
reconciliation is complete."
"O yes, certainly! I tell you, brother, according to the flesh: it
is just as complete as the lark's is with the adder; no more so, nor
ever can. Reconciled, forsooth! To what would I be reconciled?"
As he said this, he strode indignantly away. From the moment that he
heard his life was safe, he assumed his former insolence and revengeful
looks —and never were they more dreadful than on parting with his
brother that morning on the top of the hill. "Well, go thy ways," said
George; "some would despise, but I pity thee. If thou art not a limb
of Satan, I never saw one."
The sun had now dispelled the vapours; and the morning being lovely
beyond description, George sat himself down on the top of the hill, and
pondered deeply on the unaccountable incident that had befallen to him
that morning. He could in nowise comprehend it; but, taking it with
other previous circumstances, he could not get quit of a conviction
that he was haunted by some evil genius in the shape of his brother, as
well as by that dark and mysterious wretch himself. In no other way
could he account for the apparition he saw that morning on the face of
the rock, nor for several sudden appearances of the same being, in
places where there was no possibility of any foreknowledge that he
himself was to be there, and as little that the same being, if he were
flesh and blood like other men, could always start up in the same
position with regard to him. He determined, therefore, on reaching
home, to relate all that had happened, from beginning to end, to his
father, asking his counsel and his assistance, although he knew full
well that his father was not the fittest man in the world to solve such
a problem. He was now involved in party politics, over head and ears;
and, moreover, he could never hear the names of either of the Wringhims
mentioned without getting into a quandary of disgust and anger; and
all that he would deign to say of them was, to call them by all the
opprobrious names he could invent.
It turned out as the young man from the first suggested: old
Dalcastle would listen to nothing concerning them with any patience.
George complained that his brother harassed him with his presence at
all times, and in all places. Old Dal asked why he did not kick the dog
out of his presence, whenever he felt him disagreeable? George said, he
seemed to have some demon for a familiar. Dal answered, that he did not
wonder a bit at that, for the young spark was the third in a direct
line who had all been children of adultery; and it was well known that
all such were born half deils themselves, and nothing was more likely
than that they should hold intercourse with their fellows. In the same
style did he sympathise with all his son's late sufferings and
In Mr. Adam Gordon, however, George found a friend who entered into
all his feelings, and had seen and knew every thing about the matter.
He tried to convince him, that at all events there could be nothing
supernatural in the circumstances; and that the vision he had seen on
the rock, among the thick mist, was the shadow of his brother
approaching behind him. George could not swallow this, for he had seen
his own shadow on the cloud, and, instead of approaching to aught like
his own figure, he perceived nothing but a halo of glory round a point
of the cloud, that was whiter and purer than the rest. Gordon said, if
he would go with him to a mountain of his father's, which he named, in
Aberdeenshire, he would show him a giant spirit of the same dimensions,
any morning at the rising of the sun, provided he shone on that spot.
This statement excited George's curiosity exceedingly; and, being
disgusted with some things about Edinburgh, and glad to get out of the
way, he consented to go with Gordon to the Highlands for a space. The
day was accordingly set for their departure, the old laird's assent
obtained; and the two young sparks parted in a state of great
impatience for their excursion.
One of them found out another engagement, however, the instant after
this last was determined on. Young Wringhim went off the hill that
morning, and home to his upright guardian again, without washing the
blood from his face and neck; and there he told a most woful story
indeed: How he had gone out to take a morning's walk on the hill, where
he had encountered with his reprobate brother among the mist, who had
knocked him down and very near murdered him; threatening dreadfully,
and with horrid oaths, to throw him from the top of the cliff.
The wrath of the great divine was kindled beyond measure. He cursed
the aggressor in the name of the Most High; and bound himself, by an
oath, to cause that wicked one's transgressions return upon his own
head sevenfold. But before he engaged farther in the business of
vengeance, he kneeled with his adopted son, and committed the whole
cause unto the Lord, whom he addressed as one coming breathing burning
coals of juniper, and casting his lightnings before him, to destroy and
root out all who had moved hand or tongue against the children of the
promise. Thus did he arise confirmed, and go forth to certain conquest.
We cannot enter into the detail of the events that now occurred,
without forestalling a part of the narrative of one who knew all the
circumstances—was deeply interested in them, and whose relation is of
higher value than any thing that can be retailed out of the stores of
tradition and old registers; but, his narrative being different from
these, it was judged expedient to give the account as thus publicly
handed down to us. Suffice it, that, before evening, George was
apprehended, and lodged in jail, on a criminal charge of an assault and
battery, to the shedding of blood, with the intent of committing
fratricide. Then was the old laird in great consternation, and blamed
himself for treating the thing so lightly, which seemed to have been
gone about, from the beginning, so systematically, and with an intent
which the villains were now going to realize, namely, to get the young
laird disposed of, and then his brother, in spite of the old
gentleman's teeth, would be laird himself.
Old Dal now set his whole interest to work among the noblemen and
lawyers of his party. His son's case looked exceedingly ill, owing to
the former assault before witnesses, and the unbecoming expressions
made use of by him on that occasion, as well as from the present
assault, which George did not deny, and for which no moving cause or
motive could be made to appear.
On his first declaration before the sheriff, matters looked no
better: but then the sheriff was a Whig. It is well known how
differently the people of the present day, in Scotland, view the cases
of their own party-men, and those of opposite political principles. But
this day is nothing to that in such matters, although, God knows, they
are still sometimes barefaced enough. It appeared, from all the
witnesses in the first case, that the complainant was the first
aggressor—that he refused to stand out of the way, though apprised of
his danger; and when his brother came against him inadvertently, he had
aimed a blow at him with his foot, which, if it had taken effect, would
have killed him. But as to the story of the apparition in fair
day-light—the flying from the face of it—the running foul of his
brother —pursuing him, and knocking him down, why the judge smiled at
the relation; and saying, "It was a very extraordinary story," he
remanded George to prison, leaving the matter to the High Court of
When the case came before that court, matters took a different turn.
The constant and sullen attendance of the one brother upon the other
excited suspicions; and these were in some manner, confirmed, when the
guards at Queensberry-house deponed, that the prisoner went by them on
his way to the hill that morning, about twenty minutes before the
complainant, and when the latter passed, he asked if such a young man
had passed before him, describing the prisoner's appearance to them;
and that, on being answered in the affirmative, he mended his pace and
The Lord Justice, on hearing this, asked the prisoner if he had any
suspicions that his brother had a design on his life.
He answered, that all along, from the time of their first
unfortunate meeting, his brother had dogged his steps so constantly,
and so unaccountably, that he was convinced it was with some intent out
of the ordinary course of events; and that if, as his lordship
supposed, it was indeed his shadow that he had seen approaching him
through the mist, then, from the cowering and cautious manner that it
advanced, there was too little doubt that his brother's design had been
to push him headlong from the cliff that morning.
A conversation then took place between the Judge and the Lord
Advocate; and, in the mean time, a bustle was seen in the hall; on
which the doors were ordered to be guarded,—and, behold, the precious
Mr. R. Wringhim was taken into custody, trying to make his escape out
of court. Finally it turned out, that George was honourably acquitted,
and young Wringhim bound over to keep the peace, with heavy penalties
That was a day of high exultation to George and his youthful
associates, all of whom abhorred Wringhim; and the evening being spent
in great glee, it was agreed between Mr. Adam Gordon and George, that
their visit to the Highlands, though thus long delayed, was not to be
abandoned; and though they had, through the machinations of an
incendiary, lost the season of delight, they would still find plenty of
sport in deer-shooting. Accordingly, the day was set a second time for
their departure; and, on the day preceding that, all the party were
invited by George to dine with him once more at the sign of the Black
Bull of Norway. Every one promised to attend, anticipating nothing but
festivity and joy. Alas, what short-sighted improvident creatures we
are, all of us; and how often does the evening cup of joy lead to
sorrow in the morning!
The day arrived—the party of young noblemen and gentlemen met, and
were as happy and jovial as men could be. George was never seen so
brilliant, or so full of spirits; and exulting to see so many gallant
young chiefs and gentlemen about him, who all gloried in the same
principles of loyalty, (perhaps this word should have been written
disloyalty,) he made speeches, gave toasts, and sung songs, all leaning
slily to the same side, until a very late hour. By that time he had
pushed the bottle so long and so freely, that its fumes had taken
possession of every brain to such a degree, that they held Dame Reason
rather at the staff's end, overbearing all her counsels and
expostulations; and it was imprudently proposed by a wild inebriated
spark, and carried by a majority of voices, that the whole party should
adjourn to a bagnio for the remainder of the night.
They did so; and it appears from what follows, that the house to
which they retired, must have been somewhere on the opposite side of
the street to the Black Bull Inn, a little farther to the eastward.
They had not been an hour in that house, till some altercation chanced
to arise between George Colwan and a Mr. Drummond, the younger son of a
nobleman of distinction. It was perfectly casual, and no one
thenceforward, to this day, could ever tell what it was about, if it
was not about the misunderstanding of some word, or term, that the one
had uttered. However it was, some high words passed between them; these
were followed by threats; and in less than two minutes from the
commencement of the quarrel, Drummond left the house in apparent
displeasure, hinting to the other that they two should settle that in a
more convenient place.
The company looked at one another, for all was over before any of
them knew such a thing was begun. "What the devil is the matter?" cried
one. "What ails Drummond?" cried another. "Who has he quarrelled with?"
asked a third.
"Don't know."—"Can't tell, on my life."—"He has quarrelled with
his wine, I suppose, and is going to send it a challenge."
Such were the questions, and such the answers that passed in the
jovial party, and the matter was no more thought of.
But in the course of a very short space, about the length of which
the ideas of the company were the next day at great variance, a sharp
rap came to the door: It was opened by a female; but there being a
chain inside, she only saw one side of the person at the door. He
appeared to be a young gentleman, in appearance like him who had lately
left the house, and asked, in a low whispering voice, "if young
Dalcastle was still in the house?" The woman did not know,—"If he
is," added he, "pray tell him to speak with me for a few minutes." The
woman delivered the message before all the party, among whom there were
then sundry courteous ladies of notable distinction, and George, on
receiving it, instantly rose from the side of one of them, and said, in
the hearing of them all, "I will bet a hundred merks that is
Drummond."—"Don't go to quarrel with him, George," said one.—"Bring
him in with you," said another. George stepped out; the door was again
bolted, the chain drawn across, and the inadvertent party, left within,
thought no more of the circumstance till the next morning, that the
report had spread over the city, that a young gentleman had been slain,
on a little washing-green at the side of the North Loch, and at the
very bottom of the close where this thoughtless party had been
Several of them, on first hearing the report, hasted to the
dead-room in the old Guard-house, where the corpse had been deposited,
and soon discovered the body to be that of their friend and late
entertainer, George Colwan. Great were the consternation and grief of
all concerned, and, in particular, of his old father and Miss Logan;
for George had always been the sole hope and darling of both, and the
news of the event paralysed them so as to render them incapable of all
thought or exertion. The spirit of the old laird was broken by the
blow, and he descended at once from a jolly, good-natured, and active
man, to a mere driveller, weeping over the body of his son, kissing his
wound, his lips, and his cold brow alternately; denouncing vengeance on
his murderers, and lamenting that he himself had not met the cruel
doom, so that the hope of his race might have been preserved. In short,
finding that all further motive of action and object of concern or of
love, here below, were for ever removed from him, he abandoned himself
to despair, and threatened to go down to the grave with his son.
But although he made no attempt to discover the murderers, the arm
of justice was not idle; and it being evident to all, that the crime
must infallibly be brought home to young Drummond, some of his friends
sought him out, and compelled him, sorely against his will, to retire
into concealment till the issue of the proof that should be led was
made known. At the same time, he denied all knowledge of the incident
with a resolution that astonished his intimate friends and relations,
who to a man suspected him guilty. His father was not in Scotland, for
I think it was said to me that this young man was second son to a John,
Duke of Melfort, who lived abroad with the royal family of the Stuarts;
but this young gentleman lived with the relations of his mother, one of
whom, an uncle, was a Lord of Session: these having thoroughly effected
his concealment, went away, and listened to the evidence; and the
examination of every new witness convinced them that their noble young
relative was the slayer of his friend.
All the young gentlemen of the party were examined, save Drummond,
who, when sent for, could not be found, which circumstance sorely
confirmed the suspicions against him in the minds of judges and
jurors, friends and enemies; and there is little doubt, that the care
of his relations in concealing him, injured his character, and his
cause. The young gentlemen, of whom the party was composed, varied
considerably, with respect to the quarrel between him and the deceased.
Some of them had neither heard nor noted it; others had, but not one of
them could tell how it began. Some of them had heard the threat uttered
by Drummond on leaving the house, and one only had noted him lay his
hand on his sword. Not one of them could swear that it was Drummond who
came to the door, and desired to speak with the deceased, but the
general impression on the minds of them all, was to that effect; and
one of the women swore that she heard the voice distinctly at the door,
and every word that voice pronounced; and at the same time heard the
deceased say, that it was Drummond's.
On the other hand, there were some evidences on Drummond's part,
which Lord Craigie, his uncle, had taken care to collect. He produced
the sword which his nephew had worn that night, on which there was
neither blood nor blemish; and above all, he insisted on the evidence
of a number of surgeons, who declared that both the wounds which the
deceased had received, had been given behind. One of these was below
the left arm, and a slight one; the other was quite through the body,
and both evidently inflicted with the same weapon, a two-edged sword,
of the same dimensions as that worn by Drummond.
Upon the whole, there was a division in the court, but a majority
decided it. Drummond was pronounced guilty of the murder; outlawed for
not appearing, and a high reward offered for his apprehension. It was
with the greatest difficulty that he escaped on board of a small
trading vessel, which landed him in Holland, and from thence, flying
into Germany, he entered into the service of the Emperor Charles VI.
Many regretted that he was not taken, and made to suffer the penalty
due for such a crime, and the melancholy incident became a pulpit theme
over a great part of Scotland, being held up as a proper warning to
youth to beware of such haunts of vice and depravity, the nurses of all
that is precipitate, immoral, and base, among mankind.
After the funeral of this promising and excellent young man, his
father never more held up his head. Miss Logan, with all her art,
could not get him to attend to any worldly thing, or to make any
settlement whatsoever of his affairs, save making her over a present of
what disposable funds he had about him. As to his estates, when they
were mentioned to him, he wished them all in the bottom of the sea, and
himself along with them. But whenever she mentioned the circumstance of
Thomas Drummond having been the murderer of his son, he shook his head,
and once made the remark, that "It was all a mistake, a gross and fatal
error; but that God, who had permitted such a flagrant deed, would
bring it to light in his own time and way." In a few weeks he followed
his son to the grave, and the notorious Robert Wringhim took possession
of his estates as the lawful son of the late laird, born in wedlock,
and under his father's roof. The investiture was celebrated by prayer,
singing of psalms, and religious disputation. The late guardian and
adopted father, and the mother of the new laird, presided on the grand
occasion, making a conspicuous figure in all the work of the day; and
though the youth himself indulged rather more freely in the bottle,
than he had ever been seen to do before, it was agreed by all present,
that there had never been a festivity so sanctified within the great
hall of Dalcastle. Then, after due thanks returned, they parted
rejoicing in spirit; which thanks, by the by, consisted wholly in
telling the Almighty what he was; and informing him, with very
particular precision, what they were who addressed him; for Wringhim's
whole system of popular declamation consisted it seems in this,—to
denounce all men and women to destruction, and then hold out hopes to
his adherents that they were the chosen few, included in the promises,
and who could never fall away. It would appear that this pharisaical
doctrine is a very delicious one, and the most grateful of all others
to the worst characters.
But the ways of heaven are altogether inscrutable, and soar as far
above and beyond the works and the comprehensions of man, as the sun,
flaming in majesty, is above the tiny boy's evening rocket. It is the
controller of Nature alone, that can bring light out of darkness, and
order out of confusion. Who is he that causeth the mole, from his
secret path of darkness, to throw up the gem, the gold, and the
precious ore? The same, that from the mouths of babes and sucklings can
extract the perfection of praise, and who can make the most abject of
his creatures instrumental in bringing the most hidden truths to light.
Miss Logan had never lost the thought of her late master's
prediction, that Heaven would bring to light the truth concerning the
untimely death of his son. She perceived that some strange conviction,
too horrible for expression, preyed on his mind from the moment that
the fatal news reached him, to the last of his existence; and in his
last ravings, he uttered some incoherent words about justification by
faith alone, and absolute and eternal predestination having been the
ruin of his house. These, to be sure, were the words of superannuation,
and of the last and severest kind of it; but for all that, they sunk
deep into Miss Logan's soul, and at last she began to think with
herself, "Is it possible the Wringhims, and the sophisticating wretch
who is in conjunction with them, the mother of my late beautiful and
amiable young master, can have effected his destruction? if so, I will
spend my days, and my little patrimony, in endeavours to rake up and
expose the unnatural deed."
In all her outgoings and incomings, Mrs. Logan (as she was now
styled) never lost sight of this one object. Every new disappointment
only whetted her desire to fish up some particulars concerning it; for
she thought so long, and so ardently upon it, that by degrees it became
settled in her mind as a sealed truth. And as woman is always most
jealous of her own sex in such matters, her suspicions were fixed on
her greatest enemy, Mrs. Colwan, now the Lady Dowager of Dalcastle. All
was wrapt in a chaos of confusion and darkness; but at last by dint of
a thousand sly and secret inquiries, Mrs. Logan found out where Lady
Dalcastle had been, on the night that the murder happened, and likewise
what company she had kept, as well as some of the comers and goers; and
she had hopes of having discovered a cue, which, if she could keep hold
of the thread, would lead her through darkness to the light of truth.
Returning very late one evening from a convocation of family
servants, which she had drawn together in order to fish something out
of them, her maid having been in attendance on her all the evening,
they found on going home, that the house had been broken, and a number
of valuable articles stolen therefrom. Mrs. Logan had grown quite
heartless before this stroke, having been altogether unsuccessful in
her inquiries, and now she began to entertain some resolutions of
giving up the fruitless search.
In a few days thereafter, she received intelligence that her clothes
and plate were mostly recovered, and that she for one was bound over to
prosecute the depredator, provided the articles turned out to be hers,
as libelled in the indictment, and as a king's evidence had given out.
She was likewise summoned, or requested, I know not which, being
ignorant of these matters, to go as far as the town of Peebles on
Tweedside, in order to survey these articles on such a day, and make
affidavit to their identity before the Sheriff. She went accordingly;
but on entering the town by the North Gate, she was accosted by a poor
girl in tattered apparel, who with great earnestness inquired if her
name was not Mrs. Logan? On being answered in the affirmative, she said
that the unfortunate prisoner in the tolbooth requested her, as she
valued all that was dear to her in life, to go and see her before she
appeared in court, at the hour of cause, as she (the prisoner) had
something of the greatest moment to impart to her. Mrs. Logan's
curiosity was excited, and she followed the girl straight to the
tolbooth, who by the way said to her, that she would find in the
prisoner a woman of a superior mind, who had gone through all the
vicissitudes of life. "She has been very unfortunate, and I fear very
wicked," added the poor thing, "but she is my mother, and God knows,
with all her faults and failings, she has never been unkind to me. You,
madam, have it in your power to save her; but she has wronged you, and
therefore if you will not do it for her sake, do it for mine, and the
God of the fatherless will reward you."
Mrs. Logan answered her with a cast of the head, and a hem! and only
remarked, that "the guilty must not always be suffered to escape, or
what a world must we be doomed to live in!"
She was admitted to the prison, and found a tall emaciated figure,
who appeared to have once possessed a sort of masculine beauty in no
ordinary degree, but was now considerably advanced in years. She viewed
Mrs. Logan with a stern, steady gaze, as if reading her features as a
margin to her intellect; and when she addressed her it was not with
that humility, and agonized fervor, which are natural for one in such
circumstances to address to another, who has the power of her life and
death in her hands.
"I am deeply indebted to you, for this timely visit, Mrs. Logan,"
said she. "It is not that I value life, or because I fear death, that I
have sent for you so expressly. But the manner of the death that awaits
me, has something peculiarly revolting in it to a female mind. Good
God! when I think of being hung up, a spectacle to a gazing, gaping
multitude, with numbers of which I have had intimacies and connections,
that would render the moment of parting so hideous, that, believe me,
it rends to flinders a soul born for another sphere than that in which
it has moved, had not the vile selfishness of a lordly fiend ruined all
my prospects, and all my hopes. Hear me then; for I do not ask your
pity: I only ask of you to look to yourself, and behave with womanly
prudence. If you deny this day, that these goods are yours, there is no
other evidence whatever against my life, and it is safe for the
present. For as for the word of the wretch who has betrayed me, it is
of no avail; he has prevaricated so notoriously to save himself. If you
deny them, you shall have them all again to the value of a mite, and
more to the bargain. If you swear to the identity of them, the process
will, one way and another, cost you the half of what they are worth."
"And what security have I for that?" said Mrs. Logan.
"You have none but my word," said the other proudly, "and that never
yet was violated. If you cannot take that, I know the worst you can
do— But I had forgot—I have a poor helpless child without,
waiting, and starving about the prison door —Surely it was of her
that I wished to speak. This shameful death of mine will leave her in a
"The girl seems to have candour and strong affections," said Mrs.
Logan; "I grievously mistake if such a child would not be a thousand
times better without such a guardian and director."
"Then will you be so kind as come to the Grass Market, and see me
put down?" said the prisoner. "I thought a woman would estimate a
woman's and a mother's feelings, when such a dreadful throw was at
stake, at least in part. But you are callous, and have never known any
feelings but those of subordination to your old unnatural master. Alas,
I have no cause of offence! I have wronged you; and justice must take
its course. Will you forgive me before we part?"
Mrs. Logan hesitated, for her mind ran on something else: On which
the other subjoined, "No, you will not forgive me, I see. But you will
pray to God to forgive me? I know you will do that."
Mrs. Logan heard not this jeer, but looking at the prisoner with an
absent and stupid stare, she said, "Did you know my late master?"
"Ay, that I did, and never for any good," said she. "I knew the old
and the young spark both, and was by when the latter was slain."
This careless sentence affected Mrs. Logan in a most peculiar
manner. A shower of tears burst from her eyes ere it was done, and when
it was, she appeared like one bereaved of her mind. She first turned
one way and then another, as if looking for something she had dropped.
She seemed to think she had lost her eyes, instead of her tears, and at
length, as by instinct, she tottered close up to the prisoner's face,
and looking wistfully and joyfully in it, said, with breathless
earnestness, "Pray, mistress, what is your name?"
"My name is Arabella Calvert," said the other: "Miss, mistress, or
widow, as you chuse, for I have been all the three, and that not once
nor twice only —Ay, and something beyond all these. But as for you,
you have never been any thing!"
"Ay, ay! and so you are Bell Calvert? Well, I thought so—I thought
so," said Mrs. Logan; and helping herself to a seat, she came and sat
down close by the prisoner's knee. "So you are indeed Bell Calvert, so
called once. Well, of all the world you are the woman whom I have
longed and travailed the most to see. But you were invisible; a being
to be heard of, not seen."
"There have been days, madam," returned she, "when I was to be seen,
and when there were few to be seen like me. But since that time there
have indeed been days on which I was not to be seen. My crimes have
been great, but my sufferings have been greater. So great, that neither
you nor the world can ever either know or conceive them. I hope they
will be taken into account by the Most High. Mine have been crimes of
utter desperation. But whom am I speaking to? You had better leave me
to myself, mistress."
"Leave you to yourself? That I will be loth to do, till you tell me
where you were that night my young master was murdered?"
"Where the devil would, I was! Will that suffice you? Ah, it was a
vile action! A night to be remembered that was! Won't you be going? I
want to trust my daughter with a commission."
"No, Mrs. Calvert, you and I part not, till you have divulged that
mystery to me."
"You must accompany me to the other world, then, for you shall not
have it in this."
"If you refuse to answer me, I can have you before a tribunal, where
you shall be sifted to the soul."
"Such miserable inanity! What care I for your threatenings of a
tribunal? I who must so soon stand before my last earthly one? What
could the word of such a culprit avail? Or if it could, where is the
judge that could enforce it?"
"Did you not say that there was some mode of accommodating matters
on that score?"
"Yes, I prayed you to grant me my life, which is in your power. The
saving of it would not have cost you a plack, yet you refused to do it.
The taking of it will cost you a great deal, and yet to that purpose
you adhere. I can have no parley with such a spirit. I would not have
my life in a present from its motions, nor would I exchange courtesies
with its possessor."
"Indeed, Mrs. Calvert, since ever we met, I have been so busy
thinking about who you might be, that I know not what you have been
proposing. I believe, I meant to do what I could to save you. But once
for all, tell me every thing that you know concerning that amiable
young gentleman's death, and here is my hand there shall be nothing
wanting that I can effect for you."
"No, I despise all barter with such mean and selfish curiosity; and,
as I believe that passion is stronger with you, than fear is with me,
we part on equal terms. Do your worst; and my secret shall go to the
gallows and the grave with me."
Mrs. Logan was now greatly confounded, and after proffering in vain
to concede every thing she could ask in exchange, for the particulars
relating to the murder, she became the suppliant in her turn. But the
unaccountable culprit, exulting in her advantage, laughed her to scorn;
and finally, in a paroxysm of pride and impatience, called in the
jailor and had her expelled, ordering him in her hearing not to grant
her admittance a second time, on any pretence.
Mrs. Logan was now hard put to it, and again driven almost to
despair. She might have succeeded in the attainment of that she
thirsted for most in life so easily, had she known the character with
which she had to deal with—Had she known to have soothed her high and
afflicted spirit: but that opportunity was past, and the hour of
examination at hand. She once thought of going and claiming her
articles, as she at first intended; but then, when she thought again of
the Wringhims swaying it at Dalcastle, where she had been wont to hear
them held in such contempt, if not abhorrence, and perhaps of holding
it by the most diabolical means, she was withheld from marring the only
chance that remained of having a glimpse into that mysterious affair.
Finally, she resolved not to answer to her name in the court, rather
than to appear and assert a falsehood, which she might be called on to
certify by oath. She did so; and heard the Sheriff give orders to the
officers to make inquiry for Miss Logan from Edinburgh, at the various
places of entertainment in town, and to expedite her arrival in court,
as things of great value were in dependence. She also heard the man who
had turned king's evidence against the prisoner, examined for the
second time, and sifted most cunningly. His answers gave any thing but
satisfaction to the Sheriff, though Mrs. Logan believed them to be
mainly truth. But there were a few questions and answers that struck
her above all others.
"How long is it since Mrs. Calvert and you became acquainted?"
"About a year and a half."
"State the precise time, if you please; the day, or night, according
to your remembrance."
"It was on the morning of the 28th of February, 1705."
"What time of the morning?"
"Perhaps about one."
"So early as that? At what place did you meet then?"
"It was at the foot of one of the north wynds of Edinburgh."
"Was it by appointment that you met?"
"No, it was not."
"For what purpose was it then?"
"For no purpose."
"How is it that you chance to remember the day and hour so minutely,
if you met that woman, whom you have accused, merely by chance, and for
no manner of purpose, as you must have met others that night, perhaps
to the amount of hundreds, in the same way?"
"I have good cause to remember it, my lord."
"What was that cause?—No answer?—You don't choose to say what
that cause was?"
"I am not at liberty to tell."
The Sheriff then descended to other particulars, all of which tended
to prove that the fellow was an accomplished villain, and that the
principal share of the atrocities had been committed by him. Indeed the
Sheriff hinted, that he suspected the only share Mrs. Calvert had in
them, was in being too much in his company, and too true to him. The
case was remitted to the Court of Justiciary; but Mrs. Logan had heard
enough to convince her that the culprits first met at the very spot,
and the very hour, on which George Colwan was slain; and she had no
doubt that they were incendiaries set on by his mother, to forward her
own and her darling son's way to opulence. Mrs. Logan was wrong, as
will appear in the sequel; but her antipathy to Mrs. Colwan made her
watch the event with all care. She never quitted Peebles as long as
Bell Calvert remained there, and when she was removed to Edinburgh, the
other followed. When the trial came on, Mrs. Logan and her maid were
again summoned as witnesses before the jury, and compelled by the
prosecutor for the Crown to appear.
The maid was first called; and when she came into the witnesses'
box, the anxious and hopeless looks of the prisoner were manifest to
all: But the girl, whose name, she said, was Bessy Gillies, answered in
so flippant and fearless a way, that the auditors were much amused.
After a number of routine questions, the depute-advocate asked her if
she was at home on the morning of the fifth of September last, when her
mistress's house was robbed?
"Was I at hame, say ye? Na, faith-ye, lad! An I had been at hame,
there had been mair to dee. I wad hae raised sic a yelloch!"
"Where were you that morning?"
"Where was I, say you? I was in the house where my mistress was,
sitting dozing an' half sleeping in the kitchen. I thought aye she
would be setting out every minute, for twa hours."
"And when you went home, what did you find?"
"What found we? Be my sooth, we found a broken lock, an' toom kists."
"Relate some of the particulars, if you please."
"O, sir, the thieves didna stand upon particulars: they were
halesale dealers in a' our best wares."
"I mean, what passed between your mistress and you on the occasion?"
"What passed, say ye? O, there wasna' muckle: I was in a great
passion, but she was dung doitrified a wee. When she gaed to put the
key i' the door, up it flew to the fer wa'.—'Bess, ye jaud, what's
the meaning o' this?' quo she. 'Ye hae left the door open, ye tawpie!'
quo she. 'The ne'er o' that I did,' quo I, 'or may my shakel bane never
turn another key.' When we got the candle lightit, a' the house was in
a hoad-road. 'Bessy, my woman,' quo she, 'we are baith ruined and
undone creatures.' 'The deil a bit,' quo I; 'that I deny positively.
H'mh! to speak o' a lass o' my age being ruined and undone! I never had
muckle except what was within a good jerkin, an' let the thief ruin me
there wha can.'"
"Do you remember ought else that your mistress said on the occasion?
Did you hear her blame any person?"
"O, she made a great deal o' grumphing an' groaning about the
misfortune, as she ca'd it, an' I think she said it was a part o' the
ruin wrought by the Ringans, or some sic name,—'they'll hae't a'!
they'll hae't a'!' cried she, wringing her hands; 'they'll hae't a',
an' hell wi't, an' they'll get them baith.' 'Aweel, that's aye some
satisfaction,' quo I."
"Whom did she mean by the Ringans, do you know?"
"I fancy they are some creatures that she has dreamed about, for I
think there canna be as ill folks living as she ca's them."
"Did you never hear her say that the prisoner at the bar there, Mrs.
Calvert, or Bell Calvert, was the robber of her house; or that she was
one of the Ringans?"
"Never. Somebody tauld her lately, that ane Bell Calvert robbed her
house, but she disna believe it. Neither do I."
"What reasons have you for doubting it?"
"Because it was nae woman's fingers that broke up the bolts an' the
locks that were torn open that night."
"Very pertinent, Bessy. Come then within the bar, and look at these
articles on the table. Did you ever see these silver spoons before?"
"I hae seen some very like them, and whaever has seen siller spoons,
has done the same."
"Can you swear you never saw them before?"
"Na, na, I wadna swear to ony siller spoons that ever war made,
unless I had put a private mark on them wi' my ain hand, an' that's
what I never did to ane."
"See, they are all marked with a C."
"Sae are a' the spoons in Argyle, an' the half o' them in Edinburgh
I think. A C is a very common letter, an' so are a' the names that
begin wi't. Lay them by, lay them by, an' gie the poor woman her spoons
again. They are marked wi' her ain name, an' I hae little doubt they
are hers, an' that she has seen better days."
"Ah, God bless her heart!" sighed the prisoner; and that blessing
was echoed in the breathings of many a feeling breast.
"Did you ever see this gown before, think you?"
"I hae seen ane very like it."
"Could you not swear that gown was your mistress's once?"
"No, unless I saw her hae't on, an' kend that she had paid for't. I
am very scrupulous about an oath. Like is an ill mark. Sae ill indeed,
that I wad hardly swear to ony thing."
"But you say that gown is very like one your mistress used to wear.
"I never said sic a thing. It is like one I hae seen her hae out
airing on the hay raip i' the back green. It is very like ane I hae
seen Mrs. Butler in the Grass Market wearing too; I rather think it is
the same. Bless you, sir, I wadna swear to my ain fore finger, if it
had been as lang out o' my sight, an' brought in an' laid on that
"Perhaps you are not aware, girl, that this scrupulousness of yours
is likely to thwart the purposes of justice, and bereave your mistress
of property to the amount of a thousand merks?" (From the Judge.)
"I canna help that, my lord: that's her lookout. For my part, I am
resolved to keep a clear conscience, till I be married, at any rate."
"Look over these things and see if there is any one article among
them which you can fix on as the property of your mistress."
"No ane o' them, sir, no ane o' them. An oath is an awfu' thing,
especially when it is for life or death. Gie the poor woman her things
again, an' let my mistress pick up the next she finds: that's my
When Mrs. Logan came into the box, the prisoner groaned, and laid
down her head. But how she was astonished when she heard her deliver
herself something to the following purport!—That whatever penalties
she was doomed to abide, she was determined she would not bear witness
against a woman's life, from a certain conviction that it could not be
a woman who broke her house. "I have no doubt that I may find some of
my own things there," added she, "but if they were found in her
possession, she has been made a tool, or the dupe, of an infernal set,
who shall be nameless here. I believe she did not rob me, and for that
reason I will have no hand in her condemnation."
The Judge. "This is the most singular perversion I have ever
witnessed. Mrs. Logan, I entertain strong suspicions that the prisoner,
or her agents, have made some agreement with you on this matter, to
prevent the course of justice."
"So far from that, my lord, I went into the jail at Peebles to this
woman, whom I had never seen before, and proffered to withdraw my part
in the prosecution, as well as my evidence, provided she would tell me
a few simple facts; but she spurned at my offer, and had me turned
insolently out of the prison, with orders to the jailor never to admit
me again on any pretence."
The prisoner's counsel, taking hold of this evidence, addressed the
jury with great fluency; and finally, the prosecution was withdrawn,
and the prisoner dismissed from the bar, with a severe reprimand for
her past conduct, and an exhortation to keep better company.
It was not many days till a caddy came with a large parcel to Mrs.
Logan's house, which parcel he delivered into her hands, accompanied
with a sealed note, containing an inventory of the articles, and a
request to know if the unfortunate Arabella Calvert would be admitted
to converse with Mrs. Logan.
Never was there a woman so much overjoyed as Mrs. Logan was at this
message. She returned compliments: Would be most happy to see her; and
no article of the parcel should be looked at, or touched, till her
arrival.—It was not long till she made her appearance, dressed in
somewhat better style than she had yet seen her; delivered her over the
greater part of the stolen property, besides many things that either
never had belonged to Mrs. Logan, or that she thought proper to deny,
in order that the other might retain them.
The tale that she told of her misfortunes was of the most
distressing nature, and was enough to stir up all the tender, as well
as abhorrent feelings in the bosom of humanity. She had suffered every
deprivation in fame, fortune, and person. She had been imprisoned; she
had been scourged, and branded as an impostor; and all on account of
her resolute and unmoving fidelity and truth to several of the very
worst of men, every one of whom had abandoned her to utter destitution
and shame. But this story we cannot enter on at present, as it would
perhaps mar the thread of our story, as much as it did the anxious
anticipations of Mrs. Logan, who sat pining and longing for the
relation that follows.
"Now I know, Mrs. Logan, that you are expecting a detail of the
circumstances relating to the death of Mr George Colwan; and in
gratitude for your unbounded generosity, and disinterestedness, I will
tell you all that I know, although, for causes that will appear obvious
to you, I had determined never in life to divulge one circumstance of
it. I can tell you, however, that you will be disappointed, for it was
not the gentleman who was accused, found guilty, and would have
suffered the utmost penalty of the law, had he not made his escape. It
was not he, I say, who slew your young master, nor had he any hand in
"I never thought he had. But, pray, how do you come to know this?"
"You shall hear. I had been abandoned in York, by an artful and
consummate fiend; found guilty of being art and part concerned in the
most heinous atrocities, and, in his place, suffered what I yet shudder
to think of. I was banished the county—begged my way with my poor
outcast child up to Edinburgh, and was there obliged, for the second
time in my life, to betake myself to the most degrading of all means
to support two wretched lives. I hired a dress, and betook me,
shivering, to the High Street, too well aware that my form and
appearance would soon draw me suitors enow at that throng and
intemperate time of the parliament. On my very first stepping out to
the street, a party of young gentlemen was passing. I heard by the
noise they made, and the tenor of their speech, that they were more
than mellow, and so I resolved to keep near them, in order, if
possible, to make some of them my prey. But just as one of them began
to eye me, I was rudely thrust into a narrow close by one of the
guardsmen. I had heard to what house the party was bound, for the men
were talking exceedingly loud, and making no secret of it: so I hasted
down the close, and round below to the one where their rendezvous was
to be; but I was too late, they were all housed and the door bolted. I
resolved to wait, thinking they could not all stay long; but I was
perishing with famine, and was like to fall down. The moon shone as
bright as day, and I perceived, by a sign at the bottom of the close,
that there was a small tavern of a certain description up two stairs
there. I went up and called, telling the mistress of the house my plan.
She approved of it mainly, and offered me her best apartment, provided
I could get one of these noble mates to accompany me. She abused Lucky
Sudds, as she called her, at the inn where the party was, envying her
huge profits, no doubt, and giving me afterward something to drink, for
which I really felt exceedingly grateful in my need. I stepped down
stairs in order to be on the alert. The moment that I reached the
ground, the door of Lucky Sudds' house opened and shut, and down came
the Honourable Thomas Drummond, with hasty and impassioned strides, his
sword rattling at his heel. I accosted hm in a soft and soothing tone.
He was taken with my address; for he instantly stood still and gazed
intently at me, then at the place, and then at me again. I beckoned him
to follow me, which he did without farther ceremony, and we soon found
ourselves together in the best room of a house where every thing was
wretched. He still looked about him, and at me; but all this while he
had never spoken a word. At length, I asked if he would take any
refreshment? 'If you please,' said he. I asked what he would have? but
he only answered, 'Whatever you choose, madam.' If he was taken with my
address, I was much more taken with his; for he was a complete
gentleman, and a gentleman will ever act as one. At length, he began as
"'I am utterly at a loss to account for this adventure, madam. It
seems to me like enchantment, and I can hardly believe my senses. An
English lady, I judge, and one, who from her manner and address should
belong to the first class of society, in such a place as this, is
indeed matter of wonder to me. At the foot of a close in Edinburgh! and
at this time of the night! Surely it must have been no common reverse
of fortune that reduced you to this?' I wept, or pretended to do so; on
which he added. 'Pray, madam, take heart. Tell me what has befallen
you; and if I can do any thing for you, in restoring you to your
country or your friends, you shall command my interest.'
"I had great need of a friend then, and I thought now was the time
to secure one. So I began and told him the moving tale I have told you.
But I soon perceived that I had kept by the naked truth too
unvarnishedly, and thereby quite overshot my mark. When he learned that
he was sitting in a wretched corner of an irregular house, with a
felon, who had so lately been scourged, and banished as a swindler and
impostor, his modest nature took the alarm, and he was shocked, instead
of being moved with pity. His eye fixed on some of the casual stripes
on my arm, and from that moment he became restless and impatient to be
gone. I tried some gentle arts to retain him, but in vain; so, after
paying both the landlady and me for pleasures he had neither tasted nor
asked, he took his leave.
I showed him down stairs; and just as he turned the corner of the
next land, a man came rushing violently by him; exchanged looks with
him, and came running up to me. He appeared in great agitation, and was
quite out of breath; and, taking my hand in his, we ran up stairs
together without speaking, and were instantly in the apartment I had
left, where a stoup of wine still stood untasted. 'Ah, this is
fortunate!' said my new spark, and helped himself. In the mean while,
as our apartment was a corner one, and looked both east and north, I
ran to the easter casement to look after Drummond. Now, note me well: I
saw him going eastward in his tartans and bonnet, and the gilded hilt
of his claymore glittering in the moon; and, at the very same time, I
saw two men, the one in black, and the other likewise in tartans,
coming toward the steps from the opposite bank, by the foot of the
loch; and I saw Drummond and they eying each other as they passed. I
kept view of him till he vanished towards Leith Wynd, and by that time
the two strangers had come close up under our window. This is what I
wish you to pay particular attention to. I had only lost sight of
Drummond, (who had given me his name and address,) for the short space
of time that we took in running up one pair of short stairs; and during
that space he had halted a moment, for, when I got my eye on him again,
he had not crossed the mouth of the next entry, nor proceeded above ten
or twelve paces, and, at the same time, I saw the two men coming down
the bank on the opposite side of the loch, at about three hundred paces
distance. Both he and they were distinctly in my view, and never within
speech of each other, until he vanished into one of the wynds leading
toward the bottom of the High Street, at which precise time the two
strangers came below my window; so that it was quite clear he neither
could be one of them, nor have any communication with them.
"Yet, mark me again; for of all things I have ever seen, this was
the most singular. When I looked down at the two strangers, one of
them was extremely like Drummond. So like was he, that there was not
one item in dress, form, feature, nor voice, by which I could
distinguish the one from the other. I was certain it was not he,
because I had seen the one going and the other approaching at the same
time, and my impression at the moment was, that I looked upon some
spirit, or demon, in his likeness. I felt a chillness creep all round
my heart, my knees tottered, and, withdrawing my head from the open
casement that lay in the dark shade, I said to the man who was with me,
'Good God, what is this!'
"'What is it, my dear?' said he, as much alarmed as I was.
"'As I live, there stands an apparition!' said I.
"He was not so much afraid when he heard me say so, and peeping
cautiously out, he looked and listened a-while, and then drawing back,
he said in a whisper, 'They are both living men, and one of them is he
I passed at the corner.'
"'That he is not,' said I, emphatically. 'To that I will make oath.'
"He smiled and shook his head, and then added, 'I never then saw a
man before, whom I could not know again, particularly if he was the
very last I had seen. But what matters it whether it be or not? As it
is no concern of ours, let us sit down and enjoy ourselves.'
"'But it does matter a very great deal with me, sir,' said
I.—'Bless me, my head is giddy—my breath quite gone, and I feel as
if I were surrounded with fiends. Who are you, sir?'
"'You shall know that ere we two part, my love,' said he: 'I cannot
conceive why the return of this young gentleman to the spot he so
lately left, should discompose you? I suppose he got a glance of you as
he passed, and has returned to look after you, and that is the whole
secret of the matter.'
"'If you will be so civil as to walk out and join him then, it will
oblige me hugely,' said I, 'for I never in my life experienced such
boding apprehensions of evil company. I cannot conceive how you should
come up here without asking my permission? Will it please you to
begone, sir?'—I was within an ace of prevailing. He took out his
purse—I need not say more—I was bribed to let him remain. Ah, had I
kept by my frail resolution of dismissing him at that moment, what a
world of shame and misery had been evited! But that, though uppermost
still in my mind, has nothing ado here.
"When I peeped over again, the two men were disputing in a whisper,
the one of them in violent agitation and terror, and the other
upbraiding him, and urging him on to some desperate act. At length I
heard the young man in the Highland garb say indignantly, 'Hush,
recreant! It is God's work which you are commissioned to execute, and
it must be done. But if you positively decline it, I will do it myself,
and do you beware of the consequences.'
"'Oh, I will, I will!' cried the other in black clothes, in a
wretched beseeching tone. 'You shall instruct me in this, as in all
"I thought all this while I was closely concealed from them, and
wondered not a little when he in tartans gave me a sly nod, as much as
to say, 'What do you think of this?' or, 'Take note of what you see,'
or something to that effect, from which I perceived, that whatever he
was about, he did not wish it to be kept a secret. For all that, I was
impressed with a terror and anxiety that I could not overcome, but it
only made me mark every event with the more intense curiosity. The
Highlander, whom I still could not help regarding as the evil genius
of Thomas Drummond, performed every action, as with the quickness of
thought. He concealed the youth in black in a narrow entry, a little to
the westward of my windows, and as he was leading him across the
moonlight green by the shoulder, I perceived, for the first time, that
both of them were armed with rapiers. He pushed him without resistance
into the dark shaded close, made another signal to me, and hasted up
the close to Lucky Sudds' door. The city and the morning were so still,
that I heard every word that was uttered, on putting my head out a
little. He knocked at the door sharply, and after waiting a
considerable space, the bolt was drawn, and the door, as I conceived,
edged up as far as the massy chain would let it. 'Is young Dalcastle
still in the house?' said he sharply.
"I did not hear the answer, but I heard him say, shortly after, 'If
he is, pray tell him to speak with me for a few minutes.' He then
withdrew from the door, and came slowly down the close, in a lingering
manner, looking oft behind him. Dalcastle came out; advanced a few
steps after him, and then stood still, as if hesitating whether or not
he should call out a friend to accompany him; and that instant the
door behind him was closed, chained, and the iron bolt drawn; on
hearing of which, he followed his adversary without farther hesitation.
As he passed below my window, I heard him say, 'I beseech you, Tom, let
us do nothing in this matter rashly;' but I could not hear the answer
of the other, who had turned the corner.
"I roused up my drowsy companion, who was leaning on the bed, and we
both looked together from the north window. We were in the shade, but
the moon shone full on the two young gentlemen. Young Dalcastle was
visibly the worse of liquor, and his back being turned toward us, he
said something to the other which I could not make out, although he
spoke a considerable time, and, from his tones and gestures, appeared
to be reasoning. When he had done, the tall young man in the tartans
drew his sword, and his face being straight to us, we heard him say
distinctly, 'No more words about it, George, if you please; but if you
be a man, as I take you to be, draw your sword, and let us settle it
"Dalcastle drew his sword, without changing his attitude; but he
spoke with more warmth, for we heard his words, 'Think you that I fear
you, Tom? Be assured, sir, I would not fear ten of the best of your
name, at each other's backs: all that I want is to have friends with us
to see fair play, for if you close with me, you are a dead man.'
"The other stormed at these words. 'You are a braggart, sir,' cried
he, 'a wretch—a blot on the cheek of nature—a blight on the
Christian world—a reprobate—I'll have your soul, sir—You must
play at tennis, and put down elect brethren in another world
to-morrow.' As he said this, he brandished his rapier, exciting
Dalcastle to offence. He gained his point: The latter, who had
previously drawn, advanced in upon his vapouring and licentious
antagonist, and a fierce combat ensued. My companion was delighted
beyond measure, and I could not keep him from exclaiming, loud enough
to have been heard, 'that's grand! that's excellent!' For me, my heart
quaked like an aspen. Young Dalcastle either had a decided advantage
over his adversary, or else the other thought proper to let him have
it; for he shifted, and wore, and flitted from Dalcastle's thrusts like
a shadow, uttering ofttimes a sarcastic laugh, that seemed to provoke
the other beyond all bearing. At one time, he would spring away to a
great distance, then advance again on young Dalcastle with the
swiftness of lightning. But that young hero always stood his ground,
and repelled the attack: he never gave way, although they fought nearly
twice round the bleaching green, which you know is not a very small
one. At length they fought close up to the mouth of the dark entry,
where the fellow in black stood all this while concealed, and then the
combatant in tartans closed with his antagonist, or pretended to do so;
but the moment they began to grapple, he wheeled about, turning
Colwan's back towards the entry, and then cried out, 'Ah, hell has it!
My friend, my friend!'
"That moment the fellow in black rushed from his cover with his
drawn rapier, and gave the brave young Dalcastle two deadly wounds in
the back, as quick as arm could thrust, both of which I thought pierced
through his body. He fell, and rolling himself on his back, he
perceived who it was that had slain him thus foully, and said, with a
dying emphasis, which I never heard equalled, 'Oh, dog of hell, is it
you who has done this!'
"He articulated some more, which I could not hear for other sounds;
for the moment that the man in black inflicted the deadly wound, my
companion called out, 'That's unfair, you rip! That's damnable! to
strike a brave fellow behind! One at a time, you cowards! &c.' to all
which the unnatural fiend in the tartans answered with a loud exulting
laugh; and then, taking the poor paralysed murderer by the bow of the
arm, he hurried him into the dark entry once more, where I lost sight
of them for ever."
Before this time, Mrs. Logan had risen up; and when the narrator had
finished, she was standing with her arms stretched upward at their full
length, and her visage turned down, on which were pourtrayed the lines
of the most absolute horror. "The dark suspicions of my late benefactor
have been just, and his last prediction is fulfilled," cried she. "The
murderer of the accomplished George Colwan has been his own brother,
set on, there is little doubt, by her who bare them both, and her
directing angel, the self-justified bigot. Aye, and yonder they sit,
enjoying the luxuries so dearly purchased, with perfect impunity! If
the Almighty do not hurl them down, blasted with shame and confusion,
there is no hope of retribution in this life. And, by his might, I will
be the agent to accomplish it! Why did the man not pursue the foul
murderers? Why did he not raise the alarm, and call the watch?"
"He? The wretch! He durst not move from the shelter he had
obtained,—no, not for the soul of him. He was pursued for his life,
at the moment when he first flew into my arms. But I did not know it;
no, I did not then know him. May the curse of heaven, and the blight of
hell, settle on the detestable wretch! He pursue for the sake of
justice! No; his efforts have all been for evil, but never for good.
But I raised the alarm; miserable and degraded as I was, I pursued and
raised the watch myself. Have you not heard the name of Bell Calvert
coupled with that hideous and mysterious affair?"
"Yes, I have. In secret often I have heard it. But how came it that
you could never be found? How came it that you never appeared in
defence of the Honourable Thomas Drummond; you, the only person who
could have justified him?"
"I could not, for I then fell under the power and guidance of a
wretch, who durst not for the soul of him be brought forward in the
affair. And what was worse, his evidence would have overborne mine,
for he would have sworn, that the man who called out and fought Colwan,
was the same he met leaving my apartment, and there was an end of it.
And moreover, it is well known, that this same man,—this wretch of
whom I speak, never mistook one man for another in his life, which
makes the mystery of the likeness between this incendiary and Drummond
the more extraordinary."
"If it was Drummond, after all that you have asserted, then are my
surmises still wrong."
"There is nothing of which I can be more certain, than that it was
not Drummond. We have nothing on earth but our senses to depend upon:
if these deceive us, what are we to do. I own I cannot account for it;
nor ever shall be able to account for it as long as I live."
"Could you know the man in black, if you saw him again?"
"I think I could, if I saw him walk or run: his gait was very
particular: He walked as if he had been flat-soled, and his legs made
of steel, without any joints in his feet or ancles."
"The very same! The very same! The very same! Pray will you take a
few days' journey into the country with me, to look at such a man?"
"You have preserved my life, and for you I will do any thing. I will
accompany you with pleasure: and I think I can say that I will know
him, for his form left an impression on my heart not soon to be
effaced. But of this I am sure, that my unworthy companion will
recognize him, and that he will be able to swear to his identity every
day as long as he lives."
"Where is he? Where is he? O! Mrs. Calvert, where is he?"
"Where is he? He is the wretch whom you heard giving me up to the
death; who, after experiencing every mark of affection that a poor
ruined being could confer, and after committing a thousand atrocities
of which she was ignorant, became an informer to save his diabolical
life, and attempted to offer up mine as a sacrifice for all. We will go
by ourselves first, and I will tell you if it is necessary to send any
The two dames, the very next morning, dressed themselves like
country goodwives; and, hiring two stout ponies furnished with
pillions, they took their journey westward, and the second evening
after leaving Edinburgh they arrived at the village about two miles
below Dalcastle, where they alighted. But Mrs. Logan, being anxious to
have Mrs. Calvert's judgment, without either hint or preparation, took
care not to mention that they were so near to the end of their journey.
In conformity with this plan, she said, after they had sat a while,
"Heigh-ho, but I am weary! What suppose we should rest a day here
before we proceed farther on our journey?"
Mrs. Calvert was leaning on the casement, and looking out when her
companion addressed these words to her, and by far too much engaged to
return any answer, for her eyes were riveted on two young men who
approached from the farther end of the village; and at length, turning
round her head, she said, with the most intense interest, "Proceed
farther on our journey, did you say? That we need not do; for, as I
live, here comes the very man!"
Mrs. Logan ran to the window, and behold, there was indeed Robert
Wringhim Colwan (now the Laird of Dalcastle) coming forward almost
below their window, walking arm in arm with another young man; and as
the two passed, the latter looked up and made a sly signal to the two
dames, biting his lip, winking with his left eye, and nodding his
head. Mrs. Calvert was astonished at this recognizance, the young man's
former companion having made exactly such another signal on the night
of the duel, by the light of the moon; and it struck her, moreover,
that she had somewhere seen this young man's face before. She looked
after him, and he winked over his shoulder to her; but she was
prevented from returning his salute by her companion, who uttered a
loud cry, between a groan and shriek, and fell down on the floor with a
rumble like a wall that had suddenly been undermined. She had fainted
quite away, and required all her companion's attention during the
remainder of the evening, for she had scarcely ever well recovered out
of one fit before she fell into another, and in the short intervals she
raved like one distracted, or in a dream. After falling into a sound
sleep by night, she recovered her equanimity, and the two began to
converse seriously on what they had seen. Mrs. Calvert averred that the
young man who passed next to the window, was the very man who stabbed
George Colwan in the back, and she said she was willing to take her
oath on it at any time when required, and was certain if the wretch
Ridsley saw him, that he would make oath to the same purport, for that
his walk was so peculiar, no one of common discernment could mistake it.
Mrs. Logan was in great agitation, and said, "It is what I have
suspected all along, and what I am sure my late master and benefactor
was persuaded of, and the horror of such an idea cut short his days.
That wretch, Mrs. Calvert, is the born brother of him he murdered, sons
of the same mother they were, whether or not of the same father, the
Lord only knows. But, O Mrs. Calvert, that is not the main thing that
has discomposed me, and shaken my nerves to pieces at this time. Who do
you think the young man was who walked in his company to night?"
"I cannot for my life recollect, but am convinced I have seen the
same fine form and face before."
"And did not he seem to know us, Mrs. Calvert? You who are able to
recollect things as they happened, did he not seem to recollect us, and
make signs to that effect?"
"He did, indeed, and apparently with great good humour."
"O, Mrs. Calvert, hold me, else I shall fall into hysterics again!
Who is he? Who is he? Tell me who you suppose he is, for I cannot say
my own thought."
"On my life, I cannot remember."
"Did you note the appearance of the young gentleman you saw slain
that night? Do you recollect aught of the appearance of my young
master, George Colwan?"
Mrs. Calvert sat silent, and stared the other mildly in the face.
Their looks encountered, and there was an unearthly amazement that
gleamed from each, which, meeting together, caught real fire, and
returned the flame to their heated imaginations, till the two
associates became like two statues, with their hands spread, their eyes
fixed, and their chops fallen down upon their bosoms. An old woman who
kept the lodging-house, having been called in before when Mrs. Logan
was faintish, chanced to enter at this crisis with some cordial; and,
seeing the state of her lodgers, she caught the infection, and fell
into the same rigid and statue-like appearance. No scene more striking
was ever exhibited; and if Mrs. Calvert had not resumed strength of
mind to speak, and break the spell, it is impossible to say how long
it might have continued. "It is he, I believe," said she, uttering the
words as it were inwardly. "It can be none other but he. But, no, it is
impossible! I saw him stabbed through and through the heart; I saw him
roll backward on the green in his own blood, utter his last words, and
groan away his soul. Yet, if it is not he, who can it be?"
"It is he!" cried Mrs. Logan, hysterically.
"Yes, yes, it is he!" cried the landlady, in unison.
"It is who?" said Mrs. Calvert; "whom do you mean, mistress?"
"Oh, I don't know! I don't know! I was affrighted."
"Hold your peace then till you recover your senses, and tell me, if
you can, who that young gentleman is, who keeps company with the new
Laird of Dalcastle?"
"Oh, it is he! it is he!" screamed Mrs. Logan, wringing her hands.
"Oh, it is he! it is he!" cried the landlady, wringing hers.
Mrs. Calvert turned the latter gently and civilly out of the
apartment, observing that there seemed to be some infection in the air
of the room, and she would be wise for herself to keep out of it.
The two dames had a restless and hideous night. Sleep came not to
their relief; for their conversation was wholly about the dead, who
seemed to be alive, and their minds were wandering and groping in a
chaos of mystery. "Did you attend to his corpse, and know that he
positively died and was buried?" said Mrs. Calvert.
"O, yes, from the moment that his fair but mangled corpse was
brought home, I attended it till that when it was screwed in the
coffin. I washed the long stripes of blood from his lifeless form, on
both sides of the body—I bathed the livid wound that passed through
his generous and gentle heart. There was one through the flesh of his
left side too, which had bled most outwardly of them all. I bathed
them, and bandaged them up with wax and perfumed ointment, but still
the blood oozed through all, so that when he was laid in the coffin he
was like one newly murdered. My brave, my generous young master! he was
always as a son to me, and no son was ever more kind or more respectful
to a mother. But he was butchered—he was cut off from the earth ere
he had well reached to manhood—most barbarously and unfairly slain.
And how is it, how can it be, that we again see him here, walking arm
in arm with his murderer?"
"The thing cannot be, Mrs. Logan. It is a phantasy of our disturbed
imaginations, therefore let us compose ourselves till we investigate
this matter farther."
"It cannot be in nature, that is quite clear," said Mrs. Logan;
"yet how it should be that I should think so—I who knew and nursed
him from his infancy—there lies the paradox. As you said once before,
we have nothing but our senses to depend on, and if you and I believe
that we see a person, why, we do see him. Whose word, or whose
reasoning can convince us against our own senses? We will disguise
ourselves, as poor women selling a few country wares, and we will go up
to the Hall, and see what is to see, and hear what we can hear, for
this is a weighty business in which we are engaged, namely, to turn the
vengeance of the law upon an unnatural monster; and we will farther
learn, if we can, who this is that accompanies him."
Mrs. Calvert acquiesced, and the two dames took their way to
Dalcastle, with baskets well furnished with trifles. They did not take
the common path from the village, but went about, and approached the
mansion by a different way. But it seemed as if some overruling power
ordered it, that they should miss no chance of attaining the
information they wanted. For ere ever they came within half a mile of
Dalcastle, they perceived the two youths coming, as to meet them, on
the same path. The road leading from Dalcastle toward the north-east,
as all the country knows, goes along a dark bank of brushwood called
the Bogle-heuch. It was by this track that the two women were going;
and when they perceived the two gentlemen meeting them, they turned
back, and the moment they were out of their sight, they concealed
themselves in a thicket close by the road. They did this because Mrs.
Logan was terrified for being discovered, and because they wished to
reconnoitre without being seen. Mrs. Calvert now charged her, whatever
she saw, or whatever she heard, to put on a resolution, and support it,
for if she fainted there and was discovered, what was to become of her!
The two young men came on, in earnest and vehement conversation; but
the subject they were on was a terrible one, and hardly fit to be
repeated in the face of a Christian community. Wringhim was disputing
the boundlessness of the true Christian's freedom, and expressing
doubts, that, chosen as he knew he was from all eternity, still it
might be possible for him to commit acts that would exclude him from
the limits of the covenant. The other argued, with mighty fluency, that
the thing was utterly impossible, and altogether inconsistent with
eternal predestination. The arguments of the latter prevailed, and the
laird was driven to sullen silence. But, to the women's utter surprise,
as the conquering disputant passed, he made a signal of recognizance
through the brambles to them, as formerly, and that he might expose his
associate fully, and in his true colours, he led him backward and
forward by the women more than twenty times, making him to confess both
the crimes that he had done, and those he had in contemplation. At
length he said to him, "Assuredly I saw some strolling vagrant women on
this walk, my dear friend: I wish we could find them, for there is
little doubt that they are concealed here in your woods."
"I wish we could find them," answered Wringhim; "we would have fine
sport maltreating and abusing them."
"That we should, that we should! Now tell me, Robert, if you found a
malevolent woman, the latent enemy of your prosperity, lurking in these
woods to betray you, what would you inflict on her?"
"I would tear her to pieces with my dogs, and feed them with her
flesh. O, my dear friend, there is an old strumpet who lived with my
unnatural father, whom I hold in such utter detestation, that I stand
constantly in dread of her, and would sacrifice the half of my estate
to shed her blood!"
"What will you give me if I will put her in your power, and give you
a fair and genuine excuse for making away with her; one for which you
shall answer at any bar, here or hereafter?"
"I should like to see the vile hag put down. She is in possession of
the family plate, that is mine by right, as well as a thousand valuable
relics, and great riches besides, all of which the old profligate
gifted shamefully away. And it is said, besides all these, that she
has sworn my destruction."
"She has, she has. But I see not how she can accomplish that, seeing
the deed was done so suddenly, and in the silence of the night?"
"It was said there were some on-lookers.—But where shall we find
that disgraceful Miss Logan?"
"I will show you her by and by. But will you then consent to the
other meritorious deed? Come, be a man, and throw away scruples."
"If you can convince me that the promise is binding, I will."
"Then step this way, till I give you a piece of information."
They walked a little way out of hearing, but went not out of sight;
therefore, though the women were in a terrible quandary, they durst not
stir, for they had some hopes that this extraordinary person was on a
mission of the same sort with themselves, knew of them, and was going
to make use of their testimony. Mrs. Logan was several times on the
point of falling into a swoon, so much did the appearance of the young
man impress her, until her associate covered her face that she might
listen without embarrassment. But this latter dialogue aroused
different feelings within them; namely, those arising from imminent
personal danger. They saw his waggish associate point out the place of
their concealment to Wringhim, who came toward them, out of curiosity
to see what his friend meant by what he believed to be a joke,
manifestly without crediting it in the least degree. When he came
running away, the other called after him, "If she is too hard for you,
call to me." As he said this, he hasted out of sight, in the contrary
direction, apparently much delighted with the joke.
Wringhim came rushing through the thicket impetuously, to the very
spot where Mrs. Logan lay squatted. She held the wrapping close about
her head, but he tore it off and discovered her. "The curse of God be
on thee!" said he: "What fiend has brought thee here, and for what
purpose art thou come? But, whatever has brought thee, I have thee!"
and with that he seized her by the throat. The two women, when they
heard what jeopardy they were in from such a wretch, had squatted among
the underwood at a small distance from each other, so that he had never
observed Mrs. Calvert; but no sooner had he seized her benefactor,
than, like a wild cat, she sprung out of the thicket, and had both her
hands fixed at his throat, one of them twisted in his stock, in a
twinkling. She brought him back-over among the brushwood, and the two,
fixing on him like two harpies, mastered him with ease. Then indeed was
he wofully beset. He deemed for a while that his friend was at his
back, and turning his bloodshot eyes toward the path, he attempted to
call; but there was no friend there, and the women cut short his cries
by another twist of his stock. "Now, gallant and rightful Laird of
Dalcastle," said Mrs. Logan, "what hast thou to say for thyself? Lay
thy account to dree the weird thou hast so well earned. Now shalt thou
suffer due penance for murdering thy brave and only brother."
"Thou liest, thou hag of the pit! I touched not my brother's life."
"I saw thee do it with these eyes that now look thee in the face;
ay, when his back was to thee too, and while he was hotly engaged with
thy friend," said Mrs. Calvert.
"I heard thee confess it again and again this same hour," said Mrs.
"Ay, and so did I," said her companion.— "Murder will out, though
the Almighty should lend hearing to the ears of the willow, and speech
to the seven tongues of the woodriff."
"You are liars, and witches!" said he, foaming with rage, "and
creatures fitted from the beginning for eternal destruction. I'll have
your bones and your blood sacrificed on your cursed altars! O,
Gil-Martin! Gil-Martin! where art thou now? Here, here is the proper
food for blessed vengeance!—Hilloa!"
There was no friend, no Gil-Martin there to hear or assist him: he
was in the two women's mercy, but they used it with moderation. They
mocked, they tormented, and they threatened him; but, finally, after
putting him in great terror, they bound his hands behind his back, and
his feet fast with long straps of garters which they chanced to have in
their baskets, to prevent him from pursuing them till they were out of
his reach. As they left him, which they did in the middle of the path,
Mrs. Calvert said, "We could easily put an end to thy sinful life, but
our hands shall be free of thy blood. Nevertheless thou art still in
our power, and the vengeance of thy country shall overtake thee, thou
mean and cowardly murderer, ay, and that more suddenly than thou art
The women posted to Edinburgh; and as they put themselves under the
protection of an English merchant, who was journeying thither with
twenty horses loaden, and armed servants, so they had scarcely any
conversation on the road. When they arrived at Mrs. Logan's house, then
they spoke of what they had seen and heard, and agreed that they had
sufficient proof to condemn young Wringhim, who they thought richly
deserved the severest doom of the law.
"I never in my life saw any human being," said Mrs. Calvert, "whom I
thought so like a fiend. If a demon could inherit flesh and blood, that
youth is precisely such a being as I could conceive that demon to be.
The depth and the malignity of his eye is hideous. His breath is like
the airs from a charnel house, and his flesh seems fading from his
bones, as if the worm that never dies were gnawing it away already."
"He was always repulsive, and every way repulsive," said the other;
"but he is now indeed altered greatly to the worse. While we were
hand-fasting him, I felt his body to be feeble and emaciated; but yet
I know him to be so puffed up with spiritual pride, that I believe he
weens every one of his actions justified before God, and instead of
having stings of conscience for these, he takes great merit to himself
in having effected them. Still my thoughts are less about him than the
extraordinary being who accompanies him. He does every thing with so
much ease and indifference, so much velocity and effect, that all
bespeak him an adept in wickedness. The likeness to my late hapless
young master is so striking, that I can hardly believe it to be a
chance model; and I think he imitates him in every thing, for some
purpose, or some effect on his sinful associate. Do you know that he is
so like in every lineament, look, and gesture, that, against the
clearest light of reason, I cannot in my mind separate the one from the
other, and have a certain indefinable impression on my mind, that they
are one and the same being, or that the one was a prototype of the
"If there is an earthly crime," said Mrs. Calvert, "for the due
punishment of which the Almighty may be supposed to subvert the order
of nature, it is fratricide. But tell me, dear friend, did you remark
to what the subtile and hellish villain was endeavouring to prompt the
"No, I could not comprehend it. My senses were altogether so
bewildered, that I thought they had combined to deceive me, and I gave
them no credit."
"Then hear me: I am almost certain he was using every persuasion to
induce him to make away with his mother; and I likewise conceive that I
heard the incendiary give his consent!"
"This is dreadful. Let us speak and think no more about it, till we
see the issue. In the meantime, let us do that which is our bounden
duty,—go and divulge all that we know relating to this foul murder."
Accordingly the two women went to Sir Thomas Wallace of Craigie, the
Lord Justice Clerk, (who was, I think, either uncle or grandfather to
young Drummond, who was outlawed, and obliged to fly his country on
account of Colwan's death,) and to that gentleman they related every
circumstance of what they had seen and heard. He examined Calvert very
minutely, and seemed deeply interested in her evidence—said he knew
she was relating the truth, and in testimony of it, brought a letter of
young Drummond's from his desk, wherein that young gentleman, after
protesting his innocence in the most forcible terms, confessed having
been with such a woman in such a house, after leaving the company of
his friends; and that on going home, Sir Thomas's servant had let him
in, in the dark, and from these circumstances he found it impossible to
prove an alibi. He begged of his relative, if ever an opportunity
offered, to do his endeavour to clear up that mystery, and remove the
horrid stigma from his name in his country, and among his kin, of
having stabbed a friend behind his back.
Lord Craigie, therefore, directed the two women to the proper
authorities, and after hearing their evidence there, it was judged
proper to apprehend the present Laird of Dalcastle, and bring him to
his trial. But before that, they sent the prisoner in the tolbooth, he
who had seen the whole transaction along with Mrs. Calvert, to take a
view of Wringhim privately; and his discrimination being so well known
as to be proverbial all over the land, they determined secretly to be
ruled by his report. They accordingly sent him on a pretended mission
of legality to Dalcastle, with orders to see and speak with the
proprietor, without giving him a hint what was wanted. On his return,
they examined him, and he told them that he found all things at the
place in utter confusion and dismay; that the lady of the place was
missing, and could not be found, dead or alive. On being asked if he
had ever seen the proprietor before, he looked astounded, and unwilling
to answer. But it came out that he had; and that he had once seen him
kill a man on such a spot at such an hour.
Officers were then despatched, without delay, to apprehend the
monster, and bring him to justice. On these going to the mansion, and
inquiring for him, they were told he was at home; on which they
stationed guards, and searched all the premises, but he was not to be
found. It was in vain that they overturned beds, raised floors, and
broke open closets: Robert Wringhim Colwan was lost once and for ever.
His mother also was lost; and strong suspicions attached to some of the
farmers and house servants, to whom she was obnoxious, relating to her
disappearance. The Honourable Thomas Drummond became a distinguished
officer in the Austrian service, and died in the memorable year for
Scotland, 1715; and this is all with which history, justiciary records,
and tradition, furnish me relating to these matters.
I have now the pleasure of presenting my readers with an original
document of a most singular nature, and preserved for their perusal in
a still more singular manner. I offer no remarks on it, and make as few
additions to it, leaving every one to judge for himself. We have heard
much of the rage of fanaticism in former days, but nothing to this.
My life has been a life of trouble and turmoil; of change and
vicissitude; of anger and exultation; of sorrow and of vengeance. My
sorrows have all been for a slighted gospel, and my vengeance has been
wreaked on its adversaries. Therefore, in the might of heaven I will
sit down and write: I will let the wicked of this world know what I
have done in the faith of the promises, and justification by grace,
that they may read and tremble, and bless their gods of silver and of
gold, that the minister of heaven was removed from their sphere before
their blood was mingled with their sacrifices.
I was born an outcast in the world, in which I was destined to act
so conspicuous a part. My mother was a burning and a shining light, in
the community of Scottish worthies, and in the days of her virginity
had suffered much in the persecution of the saints. But it so pleased
Heaven, that, as a trial of her faith, she was married to one of the
wicked; a man all over spotted with the leprosy of sin. As well might
they have conjoined fire and water together, in hopes that they would
consort and amalgamate, as purity and corruption: She fled from his
embraces the first night after their marriage, and from that time
forth, his iniquities so galled her upright heart, that she quitted his
society altogether, keeping her own apartments in the same house with
I was the second son of this unhappy marriage, and, long ere ever I
was born, my father according to the flesh disclaimed all relation or
connection with me, and all interest in me, save what the law compelled
him to take, which was to grant me a scanty maintenance; and had it not
been for a faithful minister of the gospel, my mother's early
instructor, I should have remained an outcast from the church visible.
He took pity on me, admitting me not only into that, but into the
bosom of his own household and ministry also, and to him am I indebted,
under Heaven, for the high conceptions and glorious discernment between
good and evil, right and wrong, which I attained even at an early age.
It was he who directed my studies aright, both in the learning of the
ancient fathers, and the doctrines of the reformed church, and designed
me for his assistant and successor in the holy office. I missed no
opportunity of perfecting myself particularly in all the minute points
of theology in which my reverend father and mother took great delight;
but at length I acquired so much skill, that I astonished my teachers,
and made them gaze at one another. I remember that it was the custom,
in my patron's house, to ask the questions of the Single Catechism
round every Sabbath night. He asked the first, my mother the second,
and so on, every one saying the question asked, and then asking the
next. It fell to my mother to ask Effectual Calling at me. I said the
answer with propriety and emphasis. "Now, madam," added I, "my question
to you is, What is Ineffectual Calling?"
"Ineffectual Calling? There is no such thing, Robert," said she.
"But there is, madam," said I; "and that answer proves how much you
say these fundamental precepts by rote, and without any consideration.
Ineffectual Calling is, the outward call of the gospel without any
effect on the hearts of unregenerated and impenitent sinners. Have not
all these the same calls, warnings, doctrines, and reproofs, that we
have? and is not this Ineffectual Calling? Has not Ardinferry the same?
Has not Patrick M'Lure the same? Has not the Laird of Dalcastle and his
reprobate heir the same? And will any tell me, that this is not
"What a wonderful boy he is!" said my mother.
"I'm feared he turn out to be a conceited gowk," said old Barnet,
the minister's man.
"No," said my pastor, and father, (as I shall henceforth denominate
him,) "No, Barnet, he is a wonderful boy; and no marvel, for I have
prayed for these talents to be bestowed on him from his infancy: and do
you think that Heaven would refuse a prayer so disinterested? No, it is
impossible. But my dread is, madam," continued he, turning to my
mother, "that he is yet in the bond of iniquity."
"God forbid!" said my mother.
"I have struggled with the Almighty long and hard," continued he;
"but have as yet had no certain token of acceptance in his behalf. I
have indeed fought a hard fight, but have been repulsed by him who hath
seldom refused my request; although I cited his own words against him,
and endeavoured to hold him at his promise, he hath so many turnings in
the supremacy of his power, that I have been rejected. How dreadful is
it to think of our darling being still without the pale of the
covenant! But I have vowed a vow, and in that there is hope."
My heart quaked with terror, when I thought of being still living in
a state of reprobation, subjected to the awful issues of death,
judgment, and eternal misery, by the slightest accident or casualty,
and I set about the duty of prayer myself with the utmost earnestness.
I prayed three times every day, and seven times on the Sabbath; but the
more frequently and fervently that I prayed, I sinned still the more.
About this time, and for a long period afterwards, amounting to several
years, I lived in a hopeless and deplorable state of mind; for I said
to myself, "If my name is not written in the book of life from all
eternity, it is in vain for me to presume that either vows or prayers
of mine, or those of all mankind combined, can ever procure its
insertion now." I had come under many vows, most solemnly taken, every
one of which I had broken; and I saw with the intensity of juvenile
grief, that there was no hope for me. I went on sinning every hour, and
all the while most strenuously warring against sin, and repenting of
every one transgression, as soon after the commission of it as I got
leisure to think. But O what a wretched state this unregenerated state
is, in which every effort after righteousness only aggravates our
offences! I found it vanity to contend; for after communing with my
heart, the conclusion was as follows: "If I could repent me of all my
sins, and shed tears of blood for them, still have I not a load of
original transgression pressing on me, that is enough to crush me to
the lowest hell. I may be angry with my first parents for having
sinned, but how I shall repent me of their sin, is beyond what I am
able to comprehend."
Still, in those days of depravity and corruption, I had some of
those principles implanted in my mind, which were afterward to spring
up with such amazing fertility among the heroes of the faith and the
promises. In particular, I felt great indignation against all the
wicked of this world, and often wished for the means of ridding it of
such a noxious burden. I liked John Barnet, my reverend father's
serving-man, extremely ill; but, from a supposition that he might be
one of the justified, I refrained from doing him any injury. He gave
always his word against me, and when we were by ourselves, in the barn
or the fields, he rated me with such severity for my faults, that my
heart could brook it no longer. He discovered some notorious lies that
I had framed, and taxed me with them in such a manner that I could in
nowise get off. My cheek burnt with offence, rather than shame; and he,
thinking he had got the mastery of me, exulted over me most
unmercifully, telling me I was a selfish and conceited blackguard, who
made great pretences towards religious devotion to cloak a disposition
tainted with deceit, and that it would not much astonish him if I
brought myself to the gallows.
I gathered some courage from his over severity, and answered him as
follows: "Who made thee a judge of the actions or dispositions of the
Almighty's creatures—thou who art a worm, and no man in his sight?
How it befits thee to deal out judgments and anathemas! Hath he not
made one vessel to honour, and another to dishonour, as in the case
with myself and thee? Hath he not builded his stories in the heavens,
and laid the foundations thereof in the earth, and how can a being like
thee judge between good and evil, that are both subjected to the
workings of his hand; or of the opposing principles in the soul of man,
correcting, modifying, and refining one another?"
I said this with that strong display of fervor for which I was
remarkable at my years, and expected old Barnet to be utterly
confounded; but he only shook his head, and, with the most provoking
grin, said, "There he goes! sickan sublime and ridiculous sophistry I
never heard come out of another mouth but ane. There needs nae aiths to
be sworn afore the session wha is your father, young goodman. I ne'er,
for my part, saw a son sae like a dad, sin' my een first opened." With
that he went away, saying, with an ill-natured wince, "You made to
honour and me to dishonour! Dirty bowkail thing that thou be'st!"
"I will have the old rascal on the hip for this, if I live," thought
I. So I went and asked my mother if John was a righteous man? She could
not tell, but supposed he was, and therefore I got no encouragement
from her. I went next to my reverend father, and inquired his opinion,
expecting as little from that quarter. He knew the elect as it were by
instinct, and could have told you of all those in his own, and some
neighbouring parishes, who were born within the boundaries of the
covenant of promise, and who were not.
"I keep a good deal in company with your servant, old Barnet,
father," said I.
"You do, boy; you do, I see," said he.
"I wish I may not keep too much in his company," said I, "not
knowing what kind of society I am in;—is John a good man, father?"
"Why, boy, he is but so, so. A morally good man John is, but very
little of the leaven of true righteousness, which is faith, within. I
am afraid old Barnet, with all his stock of morality, will be a
My heart was greatly cheered by this remark; and I sighed very
deeply, and hung my head to one side. The worthy father observed me,
and inquired the cause? when I answered as follows: "How dreadful the
thought, that I have been going daily in company and fellowship with
one, whose name is written on the red-letter side of the book of life;
whose body and soul have been, from all eternity, consigned over to
everlasting destruction, and to whom the blood of the atonement can
never, never reach! Father, this is an awful thing, and beyond my
"While we are in the world, we must mix with the inhabitants
thereof," said he; "and the stains which adhere to us by reason of this
admixture, which is unavoidable, shall all be washed away. It is our
duty, however, to shun the society of wicked men as much as possible,
lest we partake of their sins, and become sharers with them in
punishment. John, however, is a morally good man, and may yet get a
cast of grace."
"I always thought him a good man till to day," said I, "when he
threw out some reflections on your character, so horrible that I quake
to think of the wickedness and malevolence of his heart. He was rating
me very impertinently for some supposed fault, which had no being save
in his own jealous brain, when I attempted to reason him out of his
belief in the spirit of calm Christian argument. But how do you think
he answered me? He did so, sir, by twisting his mouth at me, and
remarking that such sublime and ridiculous sophistry never came out of
another mouth but one, (meaning yours,) and that no oath before a kirk
session was necessary to prove who was my dad, for that he had never
seen a son so like a father as I was like mine."
"He durst not for his soul's salvation, and for his daily bread,
which he values much more, say such a word, boy; therefore take care
what you assert," said my reverend father.
"He said these very words, and will not deny them, sir," said I.
My reverend father turned about in great wrath and indignation, and
went away in search of John; but I kept out of the way, and listened at
a back window; for John was dressing the plot of ground behind the
house; and I hope it was no sin in me that I did rejoice in the
dialogue which took place, it being the victory of righteousness over
"Well, John, this is a fine day for your delving work."
"Ey, it's a tolerable day, sir."
"Are you thankful in your heart, John, for such temporal mercies as
"Aw doubt we're a' ower little thankfu', sir, baith for temporal an'
speeritual mercies; but it isna aye the maist thankfu' heart that maks
the greatest fraze wi' the tongue."
"I hope there is nothing personal under that remark, John?"
"Gin the bannet fits ony body's head, they're unco welcome to it,
sir, for me."
"John, I do not approve of these innuendoes. You have an arch
malicious manner of vending your aphorisms, which the men of the world
are too apt to read the wrong way, for your dark hints are sure to have
one very bad meaning."
"Hout na, sir, it's only bad folks that think sae. They find ma bits
o' gibes come hame to their hearts wi' a kind o' yerk, an' that gars
"That saying is ten times worse than the other, John; it is a
manifest insult: it is just telling me to my face, that you think me a
"A body canna help his thoughts, sir."
"No, but a man's thoughts are generally formed from observation. Now
I should like to know, even from the mouth of a misbeliever, what part
of my conduct warrants such a conclusion?"
"Nae particular pairt, sir; I draw a' my conclusions frae the haill
o' a man's character, an' I'm no that aften far wrang."
"Well, John, and what sort of general character do you suppose mine
"Yours is a Scripture character, sir, an' I'll prove it."
"I hope so, John. Well, which of the Scripture characters do you
think approximates nearest to my own?"
"Guess, sir, guess; I wish to lead a proof."
"Why, if it be an Old Testament character, I hope it is Melchizedek,
for at all events you cannot deny there is one point of resemblance: I,
like him, am a preacher of righteousness. If it be a New Testament
character, I suppose you mean the Apostle of the Gentiles, of whom I am
an unworthy representative."
"Na, na, sir, better nor that still, an' fer closer is the
resemblance. When ye bring me to the point, I maun speak. Ye are the
just Pharisee, sir, that gaed up wi' the poor publican to pray in the
Temple; an' ye're acting the very same pairt at this time, an' saying
i' your heart, 'God, I thank thee that I am not as other men are, an'
in nae way like this poor misbelieving unregenerate sinner, John
"I hope I may say so indeed."
"There now! I tauld you how it was! But, d'ye hear, maister: Here
stands the poor sinner, John Barnet, your beadle an' servant-man, wha
wadna change chances wi' you in the neist world, nor consciences in
this, for ten times a' that you possess, —your justification by faith
"You are extremely audacious and impertinent, John; but the language
of reprobation cannot affect me: I came only to ask you one question,
which I desire you to answer candidly. Did you ever say to any one that
I was the boy Robert's natural father?"
"Hout na, sir! Ha—ha—ha! Aih, fie na, sir! I durstna say that
for my life. I doubt the black stool, an' the sack gown, or maybe the
juggs wad hae been my portion had I said sic a thing as that. Hout,
hout! Fie, fie! Unco-like doings thae for a Melchizedek or a Saint
"John, you are a profane old man, and I desire that you will not
presume to break your jests on me. Tell me, dare you say, or dare you
think, that I am the natural father of that boy?"
"Ye canna hinder me to think whatever I like, sir, nor can I hinder
"But did you ever say to any one, that he resembled me, and fathered
himself well enough?"
"I hae said mony a time, that he resembled you, sir. Naebody can
"But, John, there are many natural reasons for such likenesses,
besides that of consanguinity. They depend much on the thoughts and
affections of the mother; and, it is probable, that the mother of this
boy, being deserted by her worthless husband, having turned her
thoughts on me, as likely to be her protector, may have caused this
"Ay, it may be, sir. I coudna say."
"I have known a lady, John, who was delivered of a blackamoor child,
merely from the circumstance of having got a start by the sudden
entrance of her negro servant, and not being able to forget him for
"It may be, sir; but I ken this;—an I had been the laird, I wadna
hae ta'en that story in." "So, then, John, you positively think, from
a casual likeness, that this boy is my son?"
"Man's thoughts are vanity, sir; they come unasked, an' gang away
without a dismissal, an' he canna help them. I'm neither gaun to say
that I think he's your son, nor that I think he's no your son: sae ye
needna pose me nae mair about it."
"Hear then my determination, John: If you do not promise to me, in
faith and honour, that you never will say, or insinuate such a thing
again in your life, as that that boy is my natural son, I will take the
keys of the church from you, and dismiss you my service."
John pulled out the keys, and dashed them on the gravel at the
reverend minister's feet. "There are the keys o' your kirk, sir! I hae
never had muckle mense o' them sin' ye entered the door o't. I hae
carried them this three an thretty year, but they hae aye been like to
burn a hole i' my pouch sin' ever they were turned for your admittance.
Tak them again, an' gie them to wha you will, and muckle gude may he
get o' them. Auld John may dee a beggar in a hay barn, or at the back
of a dike, but he sall aye be master o' his ain thoughts, an' gie them
vent or no, as he likes."
He left the manse that day, and I rejoiced in the riddance; for I
disdained to be kept so much under, by one who was in the bond of
iniquity, and of whom there seemed no hope, as he rejoiced in his
frowardness, and refused to submit to that faithful teacher, his master.
It was about this time that my reverend father preached a sermon,
one sentence of which affected me most disagreeably: It was to the
purport, that every unrepented sin was productive of a new sin with
each breath that a man drew; and every one of these new sins added to
the catalogue in the same manner. I was utterly confounded at the
multitude of my transgressions; for I was sensible that there were
great numbers of sins of which I had never been able thoroughly to
repent, and these momentary ones, by a moderate calculation, had, I
saw, long ago, amounted to a hundred and fifty thousand in the minute,
and I saw no end to the series of repentances to which I had subjected
myself. A life-time was nothing to enable me to accomplish the sum, and
then being, for any thing I was certain of, in my state of nature, and
the grace of repentance withheld from me,—what was I to do, or what
was to become of me? In the meantime, I went on sinning without
measure; but I was still more troubled about the multitude than the
magnitude of my transgressions, and the small minute ones puzzled me
more than those that were more heinous, as the latter had generally
some good effects in the way of punishing wicked men, froward boys, and
deceitful women; and I rejoiced, even then in my early youth, at being
used as a scourge in the hand of the Lord; another Jehu, a Cyrus, or a
On the whole, I remember that I got into great confusion relating to
my sins and repentances, and knew neither where to begin nor how to
proceed, and often had great fears that I was wholly without Christ,
and that I would find God a consuming fire to me. I could not help
running into new sins continually; but then I was mercifully dealt
with, for I was often made to repent of them most heartily, by reason
of bodily chastisements received on these delinquencies being
discovered. I was particularly prone to lying, and I cannot but admire
the mercy that has freely forgiven me all these juvenile sins. Now that
I know them all to be blotted out, and that I am an accepted person, I
may the more freely confess them: the truth is, that one lie always
paved the way for another, from hour to hour, from day to day, and from
year to year; so that I found myself constantly involved in a
labyrinth of deceit, from which it was impossible to extricate myself.
If I knew a person to be a godly one, I could almost have kissed his
feet; but against the carnal portion of mankind, I set my face
continually. I esteemed the true ministers of the gospel; but the
prelatic party, and the preachers up of good works I abhorred, and to
this hour I account them the worst and most heinous of all
There was only one boy at Mr. Wilson's class who kept always the
upper hand of me in every part of education. I strove against him from
year to year, but it was all in vain; for he was a very wicked boy, and
I was convinced he had dealings with the devil. Indeed it was believed
all over the country that his mother was a witch; and I was at length
convinced that it was no human ingenuity that beat me with so much ease
in the Latin, after I had often sat up a whole night with my reverend
father, studying my lesson in all its bearings. I often read as well
and sometimes better than he; but the moment Mr. Wilson began to
examine us, my opponent popped up above me. I determined, (as I knew
him for a wicked person, and one of the devil's hand-fasted children,)
to be revenged on him, and to humble him by some means or other.
Accordingly I lost no opportunity of setting the Master against him,
and succeeded several times in getting him severely beaten for faults
of which he was innocent. I can hardly describe the joy that it gave to
my heart to see a wicked creature suffering, for though he deserved it
not for one thing, he richly deserved it for others. This may be by
some people accounted a great sin in me; but I deny it, for I did it as
a duty, and what a man or boy does for the right, will never be put
into the sum of his transgressions.
This boy, whose name was M'Gill, was, at all his leisure hours,
engaged in drawing profane pictures of beasts, men, women, houses, and
trees, and, in short, of all things that his eye encountered. These
profane things the Master often smiled at, and admired; therefore I
began privately to try my hand likewise. I had scarcely tried above
once to draw the figure of a man, ere I conceived that I had hit the
very features of Mr. Wilson. They were so particular, that they could
not be easily mistaken, and I was so tickled and pleased with the
droll likeness that I had drawn, that I laughed immoderately at it. I
tried no other figure but this; and I tried it in every situation in
which a man and a schoolmaster could be placed. I often wrought for
hours together at this likeness, nor was it long before I made myself
so much master of the outline, that I could have drawn it in any
situation whatever, almost off hand. I then took M'Gill's account book
of algebra home with me, and at my leisure put down a number of gross
caricatures of Mr. Wilson here and there, several of them in situations
notoriously ludicrous. I waited the discovery of this treasure with
great impatience; but the book, chancing to be one that M'Gill was not
using, I saw it might be long enough before I enjoyed the consummation
of my grand scheme: therefore, with all the ingenuity I was master of,
I brought it before our dominie's eye. But never shall I forget the
rage that gleamed in the tyrant's phiz! I was actually terrified to
look at him, and trembled at his voice. M'Gill was called upon, and
examined relating to the obnoxious figures. He denied flatly that any
of them were of his doing. But the Master inquiring at him whose they
were, he could not tell, but affirmed it to be some trick. Mr. Wilson
at one time, began, as I thought, to hesitate; but the evidence was so
strong against M'Gill, that at length his solemn asseverations of
innocence only proved an aggravation of his crime. There was not one in
the school who had ever been known to draw a figure but himself, and on
him fell the whole weight of the tyrant's vengeance. It was dreadful;
and I was once in hopes that he would not leave life in the culprit.
He, however, left the school for several months, refusing to return to
be subjected to punishment for the faults of others, and I stood king
of the class.
Matters were at last made up between M'Gill's parents and the
schoolmaster, but by that time I had got the start of him, and never in
my life did I exert myself so much as to keep the mastery. It was in
vain; the powers of enchantment prevailed, and I was again turned down
with the tear in my eye. I could think of no amends but one, and being
driven to desperation, I put it in practice. I told a lie of him. I
came boldly up to the master, and told him that M'Gill had in my
hearing cursed him in a most shocking manner, and called him vile
names. He called M'Gill, and charged him with the crime, and the proud
young coxcomb was so stunned at the atrocity of the charge, that his
face grew as red as crimson, and the words stuck in his throat as he
feebly denied it. His guilt was manifest, and he was again flogged most
nobly, and dismissed the school for ever in disgrace, as a most
This was a great victory gained, and I rejoiced and exulted
exceedingly in it. It had, however, very nigh cost me my life; for not
long thereafter, I encountered M'Gill in the fields, on which he came
up and challenged me for a liar, daring me to fight him. I refused, and
said that I looked on him as quite below my notice; but he would not
quit me, and finally told me that he should either lick me, or I should
lick him, as he had no other means of being revenged on such a
scoundrel. I tried to intimidate him, but it would not do; and I
believe I would have given all that I had in the world to be quit of
him. He at length went so far as first to kick me, and then strike me
on the face; and, being both older and stronger than he, I thought it
scarcely became me to take such insults patiently. I was, nevertheless,
well aware that the devilish powers of his mother would finally
prevail; and either the dread of this, or the inward consciousness of
having wronged him, certainly unnerved my arm, for I fought wretchedly,
and was soon wholly overcome. I was so sore defeated, that I kneeled,
and was going to beg his pardon; but another thought struck me
momentarily, and I threw myself on my face, and inwardly begged aid
from heaven; at the same time I felt as if assured that my prayer was
heard, and would be answered. While I was in this humble attitude, the
villain kicked me with his foot and cursed me; and I being newly
encouraged, arose and encountered him once more. We had not fought long
at this second turn, before I saw a man hastening toward us; on which I
uttered a shout of joy, and laid on valiantly; but my very next look
assured me, that the man was old John Barnet, whom I had likewise
wronged all that was in my power, and between these two wicked persons
I expected any thing but justice. My arm was again enfeebled, and that
of my adversary prevailed. I was knocked down and mauled most
grievously, and while the ruffian was kicking and cuffing me at his
will and pleasure, up came old John Barnet, breathless with running,
and at one blow with his open hand, levelled my opponent with the
earth. "Tak ye that, maister!" says John, "to learn ye better breeding.
Hout awa, man! an ye will fight, fight fair. Gude sauf us, ir ye a
gentleman's brood, that ye will kick an' cuff a lad when he's down?"
When I heard this kind and unexpected interference, I began once
more to value myself on my courage, and springing up, I made at my
adversary; but John, without saying a word, bit his lip, and seizing
me by the neck, threw me down. M'Gill begged of him to stand and see
fair play, and suffer us to finish the battle; for, added he, "he is a
liar, and a scoundrel, and deserves ten times more than I can give him."
"I ken he's a' that ye say, an' mair, my man," quoth John: "But am
I sure that ye're no as bad, an' waur? It says nae muckle for ony o' ye
to be tearing like tikes at ane anither here."
John cocked his cudgel and stood between us, threatening to knock
the one dead, who first offered to lift his hand against the other;
but, perceiving no disposition in any of us to separate, he drove me
home before him like a bullock, keeping close guard behind me, lest
M'Gill had followed. I felt greatly indebted to John, yet I complained
of his interference to my mother, and the old officious sinner got no
thanks for his pains.
As I am writing only from recollection, so I remember of nothing
farther in these early days, in the lest worthy of being recorded. That
I was a great, a transcendent sinner, I confess. But still I had hopes
of forgiveness, because I never sinned from principle, but accident;
and then I always tried to repent of these sins by the slump, for
individually it was impossible; and though not always successful in my
endeavours, I could not help that; the grace of repentance being
withheld from me, I regarded myself as in no degree accountable for the
failure. Moreover, there were many of the most deadly sins into which I
never fell, for I dreaded those mentioned in the Revelations as
excluding sins, so that I guarded against them continually. In
particular, I brought myself to despise, if not to abhor, the beauty of
women, looking on it as the greatest snare to which mankind are
subjected, and though young men and maidens, and even old women, (my
mother among the rest,) taxed me with being an unnatural wretch, I
gloried in my acquisition; and to this day, am thankful for having
escaped the most dangerous of all snares.
I kept myself also free of the sins of idolatry, and misbelief, both
of a deadly nature; and, upon the whole, I think I had not then broken,
that is, absolutely broken, above four out of the ten commandments;
but for all that, I had more sense than to regard either my good
works, or my evil deeds, as in the smallest degree influencing the
eternal decrees of God concerning me, either with regard to my
acceptance or reprobation. I depended entirely on the bounty of free
grace, holding all the righteousness of man as filthy rags, and
believing in the momentous and magnificent truth, that the more heavily
loaden with transgressions, the more welcome was the believer at the
throne of grace. And I have reason to believe that it was this
dependence and this belief that at last ensured my acceptance there.
I come now to the most important period of my existence,—the
period that has modelled my character, and influenced every action of
my life, —without which, this detail of my actions would have been as
a tale that hath been told—a monotonous farrago—an uninteresting
harangue— in short, a thing of nothing. Whereas, lo! it must now be
a relation of great and terrible actions, done in the might, and by
the commission of heaven. Amen.
Like the sinful king of Israel, I had been walking softly before the
Lord for a season. I had been humbled for my transgressions, and, as
far as I recollect, sorry on account of their numbers and heinousness.
My reverend father had been, moreover, examining me every day regarding
the state of my soul, and my answers sometimes appeared to give him
satisfaction, and sometimes not. As for my mother, she would harp on
the subject of my faith for ever; yet, though I knew her to be a
Christian, I confess that I always despised her motley instructions,
nor had I any great regard for her person. If this was a crime in me, I
never could help it. I confess it freely, and believe it was a judgment
from heaven inflicted on her for some sin of former days, and that I
had no power to have acted otherwise toward her than I did.
In this frame of mind was I, when my reverend father one morning
arose from his seat, and, meeting me as I entered the room, he embraced
me, and welcomed me into the community of the just upon earth. I was
struck speechless, and could make no answer save by looks of surprise.
My mother also came to me, kissed, and wept over me; and after
showering unnumbered blessings on my head, she also welcomed me into
the society of the just made perfect. Then each of them took me by a
hand, and my reverend father explained to me how he had wrestled with
God, as the patriarch of old had done, not for a night, but for days
and years, and that in bitterness and anguish of spirit, on my account;
but that he had at last prevailed, and had now gained the long and
earnestly desired assurance of my acceptance with the Almighty, in and
through the merits and sufferings of his Son: That I was now a
justified person, adopted among the number of God's children—my name
written in the Lamb's book of life, and that no bypast transgression,
nor any future act of my own, or of other men, could be instrumental in
altering the decree. "All the powers of darkness," added he, "shall
never be able to pluck you again out of your Redeemer's hand. And now,
my son, be strong and stedfast in the truth. Set your face against sin,
and sinful men, and resist even to blood, as many of the faithful of
this land have done, and your reward shall be double. I am assured of
your acceptance by the word and spirit of him who cannot err, and your
sanctification and repentance unto life will follow in due course.
Rejoice and be thankful, for you are plucked as a brand out of the
burning, and now your redemption is sealed and sure."
I wept for joy to be thus assured of my freedom from all sin, and of
the impossibility of my ever again falling away from my new state. I
bounded away into the fields and the woods, to pour out my spirit in
prayer before the Almighty for his kindness to me: my whole frame
seemed to be renewed; every nerve was buoyant with new life; I felt as
if I could have flown in the air, or leaped over the tops of the trees.
An exaltation of spirit lifted me, as it were, far above the earth, and
the sinful creatures crawling on its surface; and I deemed myself as an
eagle among the children of men, soaring on high, and looking down with
pity and contempt on the grovelling creatures below.
As I thus wended my way, I beheld a young man of a mysterious
appearance coming towards me. I tried to shun him, being bent on my own
contemplations; but he cast himself in my way, so that I could not well
avoid him; and more than that, I felt a sort of invisible power that
drew me towards him, something like the force of enchantment, which I
could not resist. As we approached each other, our eyes met, and I can
never describe the strange sensations that thrilled through my whole
frame at that impressive moment; a moment to me fraught with the most
tremendous consequences; the beginning of a series of adventures which
has puzzled myself, and will puzzle the world when I am no more in it.
That time will now soon arrive, sooner than any one can devise who
knows not the tumult of my thoughts, and the labour of my spirit; and
when it hath come and passed over, —when my flesh and my bones are
decayed, and my soul has passed to its everlasting home, then shall the
sons of men ponder on the events of my life; wonder and tremble, and
tremble and wonder how such things should be.
That stranger youth and I approached each other in silence, and
slowly, with our eyes fixed on each other's eyes. We approached till
not more than a yard intervened between us, and then stood still and
gazed, measuring each other from head to foot. What was my
astonishment, on perceiving that he was the same being as myself! The
clothes were the same to the smallest item. The form was the same; the
apparent age; the colour of the hair; the eyes; and, as far as
recollection could serve me from viewing my own features in a glass,
the features too were the very same. I conceived at first, that I saw a
vision, and that my guardian angel had appeared to me at this important
era of my life; but this singular being read my thoughts in my looks,
anticipating the very words that I was going to utter.
"You think I am your brother," said he; "or that I am your second
self. I am indeed your brother, not according to the flesh, but in my
belief of the same truths, and my assurance in the same mode of
redemption, than which, I hold nothing so great or so glorious on
"Then you are an associate well adapted to my present state," said
I. "For this time is a time of great rejoicing in spirit to me. I am on
my way to return thanks to the Most High for my redemption from the
bonds of sin and misery. If you will join with me heart and hand in
youthful thanks-giving, then shall we two go and worship together; but
if not, go your way, and I shall go mine."
"Ah, you little know with how much pleasure I will accompany you,
and join with you in your elevated devotions," said he fervently. "Your
state is a state to be envied indeed; but I have been advised of it,
and am come to be a humble disciple of yours; to be initiated into the
true way of salvation by conversing with you, and perhaps by being
assisted by your prayers."
My spiritual pride being greatly elevated by this address, I began
to assume the preceptor, and questioned this extraordinary youth with
regard to his religious principles, telling him plainly, if he was one
who expected acceptance with God at all, on account of good works, that
I would hold no communion with him. He renounced these at once, with
the greatest vehemence, and declared his acquiescence in my faith. I
asked if he believed in the eternal and irrevocable decrees of God,
regarding the salvation and condemnation of all mankind? He answered
that he did so: aye, what would signify all things else that he
believed, if he did not believe in that? We then went on to commune
about all our points of belief; and in every thing that I suggested, he
acquiesced, and, as I thought that day, often carried them to extremes,
so that I had a secret dread he was advancing blasphemies. Yet he had
such a way with him, and paid such a deference to all my opinions,
that I was quite captivated, and, at the same time, I stood in a sort
of awe of him, which I could not account for, and several times was
seized with an involuntary inclination to escape from his presence, by
making a sudden retreat. But he seemed constantly to anticipate my
thoughts, and was sure to divert my purpose by some turn in the
conversation that particularly interested me. He took care to dwell
much on the theme of the impossibility of those ever falling away, who
were once accepted and received into covenant with God, for he seemed
to know, that in that confidence, and that trust, my whole hopes were
We moved about from one place to another, until the day was wholly
spent. My mind had all the while been kept in a state of agitation
resembling the motion of a whirlpool, and when we came to separate, I
then discovered that the purpose for which I had sought the fields had
been neglected, and that I had been diverted from the worship of God,
by attending to the quibbles and dogmas of this singular and
unaccountable being, who seemed to have more knowledge and information
than all the persons I had ever known put together.
We parted with expressions of mutual regret, and when I left him I
felt a deliverance, but at the same time a certain consciousness that I
was not thus to get free of him, but that he was like to be an
acquaintance that was to stick to me for good or for evil. I was
astonished at his acuteness and knowledge about every thing; but as for
his likeness to me, that was quite unaccountable. He was the same
person in every respect, but yet he was not always so; for I observed
several times, when we were speaking of certain divines and their
tenets, that his face assumed something of the appearance of theirs;
and it struck me, that by setting his features to the mould of other
people's, he entered at once into their conceptions and feelings. I had
been greatly flattered, and greatly interested by his conversation;
whether I had been the better for it or the worse, I could not tell. I
had been diverted from returning thanks to my gracious Maker for his
great kindness to me, and came home as I went away, but not with the
same buoyancy and lightness of heart. Well may I remember that day in
which I was first received into the number, and made an heir to all the
privileges of the children of God, and on which I first met this
mysterious associate, who from that day forth contrived to wind
himself into all my affairs, both spiritual and temporal, to this day
on which I am writing the account of it. It was on the 25th day of
March 1704, when I had just entered the eighteenth year of my age.
Whether it behoves me to bless God for the events of that day, or to
deplore them, has been hid from my discernment, though I have inquired
into it with fear and trembling; and I have now lost all hopes of ever
discovering the true import of these events until that day when my
accounts are to make up and reckon for in another world.
When I came home, I went straight into the parlour, where my mother
was sitting by herself. She started to her feet, and uttered a
smothered scream. "What ails you, Robert?" cried she. "My dear son,
what is the matter with you?"
"Do you see any thing the matter with me?" said I. "It appears that
the ailment is with yourself, and either in your crazed head or your
dim eyes, for there is nothing the matter with me."
"Ah, Robert, you are ill!" cried she; "you are very ill, my dear
boy; you are quite changed; your very voice and manner are changed.
Ah, Jane, haste you up to the study, and tell Mr. Wringhim to come
here on the instant and speak to Robert."
"I beseech you, woman, to restrain yourself," said I. "If you suffer
your frenzy to run away with your judgment in this manner, I will leave
the house. What do you mean? I tell you, there is nothing ails me: I
never was better."
She screamed, and ran between me and the door, to bar my retreat: in
the meantime my reverend father entered, and I have not forgot how he
gazed, through his glasses, first at my mother, and then at me. I
imagined that his eyes burnt like candles, and was afraid of him, which
I suppose made my looks more unstable than they would otherwise have
"What is all this for?" said he. "Mistress! Robert! What is the
"Oh, sir, our boy!" cried my mother; "our dear boy, Mr. Wringhim!
Look at him, and speak to him: he is either dying or translated, sir!"
He looked at me with a countenance of great alarm; mumbling some
sentences to himself, and then taking me by the arm, as if to feel my
pulse, he said, with a faltering voice, "Something has indeed befallen
you, either in body or mind, boy, for you are transformed, since the
morning, that I could not have known you for the same person. Have you
met with any accident?"
"Have you seen any thing out of the ordinary course of nature?"
"Then, Satan, I fear, has been busy with you, tempting you in no
ordinary degree at this momentous crisis of your life?"
My mind turned on my associate for the day, and the idea that he
might be an agent of the devil, had such an effect on me, that I could
make no answer.
"I see how it is," said he; "you are troubled in spirit, and I have
no doubt that the enemy of our salvation has been busy with you. Tell
me this, has he overcome you, or has he not?"
"He has not, my dear father," said I. "In the strength of the Lord,
I hope I have withstood him. But indeed, if he has been busy with me, I
knew it not. I have been conversant this day with one stranger only,
whom I took rather for an angel of light."
"It is one of the devil's most profound wiles to appear like one,"
said my mother.
"Woman, hold thy peace!" said my reverend father: "thou pretendest
to teach what thou knowest not. Tell me this, boy: Did this stranger,
with whom you met, adhere to the religious principles in which I have
"Yes, to every one of them, in their fullest latitude," said I.
"Then he was no agent of the wicked one with whom you held
converse," said he; "for that is the doctrine that was made to overturn
the principalities and powers, the might and dominion of the kingdom of
darkness.—Let us pray."
After spending about a quarter of an hour in solemn and sublime
thanksgiving, this saintly man and minister of Christ Jesus, gave out
that the day following should be kept by the family as a day of solemn
thanksgiving, and spent in prayer and praise, on account of the calling
and election of one of its members; or rather for the election of that
individual being revealed on earth, as well as confirmed in heaven.
The next day was with me a day of holy exultation. It was begun by
my reverend father laying his hands upon my head and blessing me, and
then dedicating me to the Lord in the most awful and impressive manner.
It was in no common way that he exercised this profound rite, for it
was done with all the zeal and enthusiasm of a devotee to the true
cause, and a champion on the side he had espoused. He used these
remarkable words, which I have still treasured up in my heart:—"I
give him unto Thee only, to Thee wholly, and to Thee for ever. I
dedicate him unto Thee, soul, body, and spirit. Not as the wicked of
this world, or the hirelings of a church profanely called by Thy name,
do I dedicate this Thy servant to Thee: Not in words and form, learned
by rote, and dictated by the limbs of Antichrist, but, Lord, I give him
into Thy hand, as a captain putteth a sword into the hand of his
sovereign, wherewith to lay waste his enemies. May he be a two-edged
weapon in Thy hand, and a spear coming out of Thy mouth, to destroy,
and overcome, and pass over; and may the enemies of Thy church fall
down before him, and be as dung to fat the land!"
From that moment, I conceived it decreed, not that I should be a
minister of the gospel, but a champion of it, to cut off the enemies of
the Lord from the face of the earth; and I rejoiced in the commission,
finding it more congenial to my nature to be cutting sinners off with
the sword, than to be haranguing them from the pulpit, striving to
produce an effect, which God, by his act of absolute predestination,
had for ever rendered impracticable. The more I pondered on these
things, the more I saw of the folly and inconsistency of ministers, in
spending their lives, striving and remonstrating with sinners, in order
to induce them to do that which they had it not in their power to do.
Seeing that God had from all eternity decided the fate of every
individual that was to be born of woman, how vain was it in man to
endeavour to save those whom their Maker had, by an unchangeable
decree, doomed to destruction. I could not disbelieve the doctrine
which the best of men had taught me, and toward which he made the whole
of the Scriptures to bear, and yet it made the economy of the Christian
world appear to me as an absolute contradiction. How much more wise
would it be, thought I, to begin and cut sinners off with the sword!
for till that is effected, the saints can never inherit the earth in
peace. Should I be honoured as an instrument to begin this great work
of purification, I should rejoice in it. But then, where had I the
means, or under what direction was I to begin? There was one thing
clear, I was now the Lord's, and it behoved me to bestir myself in his
service. O that I had an host at my command, then would I be as a
devouring fire among the workers of iniquity!
Full of these great ideas, I hurried through the city, and sought
again the private path through the field and wood of Finnieston, in
which my reverend preceptor had the privilege of walking for study, and
to which he had a key that was always at my command. Near one of the
stiles, I perceived a young man sitting in a devout posture, reading on
a Bible. He rose, lifted his hat, and made an obeisance to me, which I
returned and walked on. I had not well crossed the stile, till it
struck me I knew the face of the youth, and that he was some intimate
acquaintance, to whom I ought to have spoken. I walked on, and
returned, and walked on again, trying to recollect who he was; but for
my life I could not. There was, however, a fascination in his look and
manner, that drew me back toward him in spite of myself, and I resolved
to go to him, if it were merely to speak and see who he was.
I came up to him and addressed him, but he was so intent on his
book, that, though I spoke, he lifted not his eyes. I looked on the
book also, and still it seemed a Bible, having columns, chapters, and
verses; but it was in a language of which I was wholly ignorant, and
all interesected with red lines, and verses. A sensation resembling a
stroke of electricity came over me, on first casting my eyes on that
mysterious book, and I stood motionless. He looked up, smiled, closed
his book, and put it in his bosom. "You seem strangely affected, dear
sir, by looking on my book," said he mildly.
"In the name of God, what book is that?" said I: "Is it a Bible?"
"It is my Bible, sir," said he; "but I will cease reading it, for I
am glad to see you. Pray, is not this a day of holy festivity with you?"
I stared in his face, but made no answer, for my senses were
"Do you not know me?" said he. "You appear to be somehow at a loss.
Had not you and I some sweet communion and fellowship yesterday?"
"I beg your pardon, sir," said I. "But surely if you are the young
gentleman with whom I spent the hours yesterday, you have the cameleon
art of changing your appearance; I never could have recognized you."
"My countenance changes with my studies and sensations," said he.
"It is a natural peculiarity in me, over which I have not full control.
If I contemplate a man's features seriously, mine own gradually assume
the very same appearance and character. And what is more, by
contemplating a face minutely, I not only attain the same likeness,
but, with the likeness, I attain the very same ideas as well as the
same mode of arranging them, so that, you see, by looking at a person
attentively, I by degrees assume his likeness, and by assuming his
likeness I attain to the possession of his most secret thoughts. This,
I say, is a peculiarity in my nature, a gift of the God that made me;
but whether or not given me for a blessing, he knows himself, and so do
I. At all events, I have this privilege,—I can never be mistaken of a
character in whom I am interested."
"It is a rare qualification," replied I, "and I would give worlds to
possess it. Then, it appears, that it is needless to dissemble with
you, since you can at any time extract our most secret thoughts from
our bosoms. You already know my natural character?"
"Yes," said he, "and it is that which attaches me to you. By
assuming your likeness yesterday, I became acquainted with your
character, and was no less astonished at the profundity and range of
your thoughts, than at the heroic magnanimity with which these were
combined. And now, in addition to these, you are dedicated to the great
work of the Lord; for which reasons I have resolved to attach myself as
closely to you as possible, and to render you all the service of which
my poor abilities are capable."
I confess that I was greatly flattered by these compliments paid to
my abilities by a youth of such superior qualifications; by one who,
with a modesty and affability rare at his age, combined a height of
genius and knowledge almost above human comprehension. Nevertheless, I
began to assume a certain superiority of demeanour toward him, as
judging it incumbent on me to do so, in order to keep up his idea of my
exalted character. We conversed again till the day was near a close;
and the things that he strove most to inculcate on my mind, were the
infallibility of the elect, and the pre-ordination of all things that
come to pass. I pretended to controvert the first of these, for the
purpose of showing him the extent of my argumentative powers, and said,
that "indubitably there were degrees of sinning which would induce the
Almighty to throw off the very elect." But behold my hitherto humble
and modest companion took up the argument with such warmth, that he put
me not only to silence, but to absolute shame.
"Why, sir," said he, "by vending such an insinuation, you put
discredit on the great atonement, in which you trust. Is there not
enough of merit in the blood of Jesus to save thousands of worlds, if
it was for these worlds that he died? Now, when you know, as you do,
(and as every one of the elect may know of himself,) that this Saviour
died for you, namely and particularly, dare you say that there is not
enough of merit in his great atonement to annihilate all your sins, let
them be as heinous and atrocious as they may? And, moreover, do you not
acknowledge that God hath pre-ordained and decreed whatsoever comes to
pass? Then, how is it that you should deem it in your power to eschew
one action of your life, whether good or evil? Depend on it, the advice
of the great preacher is genuine: 'What thine hand findeth to do, do it
with all thy might, for none of us knows what a day may bring forth?'
That is, none of us knows what is pre-ordained, but whatever is
pre-ordained we must do, and none of these things will be laid to our
I could hardly believe that these sayings were genuine or orthodox;
but I soon felt, that, instead of being a humble disciple of mine, this
new acquaintance was to be my guide and director, and all under the
humble guise of one stooping at my feet to learn the right. He said
that he saw I was ordained to perform some great action for the cause
of Jesus and his church, and he earnestly coveted being a partaker with
me; but he besought of me never to think it possible for me to fall
from the truth, or the favour of him who had chosen me, else that
misbelief would baulk every good work to which I set my face.
There was something so flattering in all this, that I could not
resist it. Still, when he took leave of me, I felt it as a great
relief; and yet, before the morrow, I wearied and was impatient to see
him again. We carried on our fellowship from day to day, and all the
while I knew not who he was, and still my mother and reverend father
kept insisting that I was an altered youth, changed in my appearance,
my manners, and my whole conduct; yet something always prevented me
from telling them more about my new acquaintance than I had done on the
first day we met. I rejoiced in him, was proud of him, and soon could
not live without him; yet, though resolved every day to disclose the
whole history of my connection with him, I had it not in my power:
Something always prevented me, till at length I thought no more of it,
but resolved to enjoy his fascinating company in private, and by all
means to keep my own with him. The resolution was vain: I set a bold
face to it, but my powers were inadequate to the task; my adherent,
with all the suavity imaginable, was sure to carry his point. I
sometimes fumed, and sometimes shed tears at being obliged to yield to
proposals against which I had at first felt every reasoning power of my
soul rise in opposition; but, for all that, he never failed in carrying
conviction along with him in effect, for he either forced me to
acquiesce in his measures, and assent to the truth of his positions, or
he put me so completely down, that I had not a word left to advance
After weeks, and I may say months of intimacy, I observed, somewhat
to my amazement, that we had never once prayed together; and more than
that, that he had constantly led my attentions away from that duty,
causing me to neglect it wholly. I thought this a bad mark of a man
seemingly so much set on inculcating certain important points of
religion, and resolved next day to put him to the test, and request of
him to perform that sacred duty in name of us both. He objected boldly;
saying there were very few people indeed, with whom he could join in
prayer, and he made a point of never doing it, as he was sure they were
to ask many things of which he disapproved, and that if he were to
officiate himself, he was as certain to allude to many things that came
not within the range of their faith. He disapproved of prayer
altogether, in the manner it was generally gone about, he said. Man
made it merely a selfish concern, and was constantly employed asking,
asking, for every thing. Whereas it became all God's creatures to be
content with their lot, and only to kneel before him in order to thank
him for such benefits as he saw meet to bestow. In short, he argued
with such energy, that before we parted I acquiesced, as usual, in his
position, and never mentioned prayer to him any more.
Having been so frequently seen in his company, several people
happened to mention the circumstance to my mother and reverend father;
but at the same time had all described him differently. At length, they
began to examine me with respect to the company I kept, as I absented
myself from home day after day. I told them I kept company only with
one young gentleman, whose whole manner of thinking on religious
subjects, I found so congenial with my own, that I could not live out
of his society. My mother began to lay down some of her old hackneyed
rules of faith, but I turned from hearing her with disgust; for, after
the energy of my new friend's reasoning, hers appeared so tame I could
not endure it. And I confess with shame, that my reverend preceptor's
religious dissertations began, about this time, to lose their relish
very much, and by degrees became exceedingly tiresome to my ear. They
were so inferior, in strength and sublimity, to the most common
observations of my young friend, that in drawing a comparison the
former appeared as nothing. He, however, examined me about many things
relating to my companion, in all of which I satisfied him, save in one:
I could neither tell him who my friend was, what was his name, nor of
whom he was descended; and I wondered at myself how I had never once
adverted to such a thing, for all the time we had been intimate.
I inquired the next day what his name was; as I said I was often at
a loss for it, when talking with him. He replied, that there was no
occasion for any one friend ever naming another, when their society was
held in private, as ours was; for his part he had never once named me
since we first met, and never intended to do so, unless by my own
request. "But if you cannot converse without naming me, you may call me
Gil for the present," added he; "and if I think proper to take another
name at any future period, it shall be with your approbation."
"Gil!" said I; "Have you no name but Gil? Or which of your names is
it? Your Christian or surname?"
"O, you must have a surname too, must you!" replied he, "Very well,
you may call me Gil-Martin. It is not my Christian name; but it is a
name which may serve your turn."
"This is very strange!" said I. "Are you ashamed of your parents,
that you refuse to give your real name?"
"I have no parents save one, whom I do not acknowledge," said he
proudly; "therefore, pray drop that subject, for it is a disagreeable
one. I am a being of a very peculiar temper, for though I have servants
and subjects more than I can number, yet, to gratify a certain whim, I
have left them, and retired to this city, and for all the society it
contains, you see I have attached myself only to you. This is a secret,
and I tell it you only in friendship, therefore pray let it remain one,
and say not another word about the matter."
I assented, and said no more concerning it; for it instantly struck
me that this was no other than the Czar Peter of Russia, having heard
that he had been travelling through Europe in disguise, and I cannot
say that I had not thenceforward great and mighty hopes of high
preferment, as a defender and avenger of the oppressed Christian
Church, under the influence of this great potentate. He had hinted as
much already, as that it was more honourable, and of more avail to put
down the wicked with the sword, than try to reform them, and I thought
myself quite justified in supposing that he intended me for some great
employment, that he had thus selected me for his companion out of all
the rest in Scotland, and even pretended to learn the great truths of
religion from my mouth. From that time I felt disposed to yield to such
a great prince's suggestions without hesitation.
Nothing ever astonished me so much, as the uncommon powers with
which he seemed invested. In our walk one day, we met with a Mr.
Blanchard, who was reckoned a worthy, pious divine, but quite of the
moral cast, who joined us; and we three walked on, and rested together
in the fields. My companion did not seem to like him, but,
nevertheless, regarded him frequently with deep attention, and there
were several times, while he seemed contemplating him, and trying to
find out his thoughts, that his face became so like Mr. Blanchard's,
that it was impossible to have distinguished the one from the other.
The antipathy between the two was mutual, and discovered itself quite
palpably in a short time. When my companion the prince was gone, Mr.
Blanchard asked me anent him, and I told him that he was a stranger in
the city, but a very uncommon and great personage. Mr. Blanchard's
answer to me was as follows: "I never saw any body I disliked so much
in my life, Mr. Robert; and if it be true that he is a stranger here,
which I doubt, believe me he is come for no good."
"Do you not perceive what mighty powers of mind he is possessed of?"
said I, "and also how clear and unhesitating he is on some of the most
interesting points of divinity?"
"It is for his great mental faculties that I dread him," said he.
"It is incalculable what evil such a person as he may do, if so
disposed. There is a sublimity in his ideas, with which there is to me
a mixture of terror; and when he talks of religion, he does it as one
that rather dreads its truths than reverences them. He, indeed,
pretends great strictness of orthodoxy regarding some of the points of
doctrine embraced by the reformed church; but you do not seem to
perceive, that both you and he are carrying these points to a dangerous
extremity. Religion is a sublime and glorious thing, the bond of
society on earth, and the connector of humanity with the Divine nature;
but there is nothing so dangerous to man as the wresting of any of its
principles, or forcing them beyond their due bounds: this is of all
others the readiest way to destruction. Neither is there any thing so
easily done. There is not an error into which a man can fall, which he
may not press Scripture into his service as proof of the probity of,
and though your boasted theologian shunned the full discussion of the
subject before me, while you pressed it, I can easily see that both you
and he are carrying your ideas of absolute predestination, and its
concomitant appendages, to an extent that overthrows all religion and
revelation together; or, at least, jumbles them into a chaos, out of
which human capacity can never select what is good. Believe me, Mr.
Robert, the less you associate with that illustrious stranger the
better, for it appears to me that your creed and his carries damnation
on the very front of it."
I was rather stunned at this; but I pretended to smile with disdain,
and said, it did not become youth to control age; and, as I knew our
principles differed fundamentally, it behoved us to drop the subject.
He, however, would not drop it, but took both my principles and me
fearfully to task, for Blanchard was an eloquent and powerful-minded
old man; and, before we parted, I believe I promised to drop my new
acquaintance, and was all but resolved to do it.
As well might I have laid my account with shunning the light of day.
He was constant to me as my shadow, and by degrees he acquired such an
ascendency over me, that I never was happy out of his company, nor
greatly so in it. When I repeated to him all that Mr. Blanchard had
said, his countenance kindled with indignation and rage; and then by
degrees his eyes sunk inward, his brow lowered, so that I was awed, and
withdrew my eyes from looking at him. A while afterward, as I was
addressing him, I chanced to look him again in the face, and the sight
of him made me start violently. He had made himself so like Mr.
Blanchard, that I actually believed I had been addressing that
gentleman, and that I had done so in some absence of mind that I could
not account for. Instead of being amused at the quandary I was in, he
seemed offended: indeed, he never was truly amused with any thing. And
he then asked me sullenly, if I conceived such personages as he to have
no other endowments than common mortals?
I said I never conceived that princes or potentates had any greater
share of endowments than other men, and frequently not so much. He
shook his head, and bade me think over the subject again; and there
was an end of it. I certainly felt every day the more disposed to
acknowledge such a superiority in him, and from all that I could
gather, I had now no doubt that he was Peter of Russia. Every thing
combined to warrant the supposition, and, of course, I resolved to act
in conformity with the discovery I had made.
For several days the subject of Mr. Blanchard's doubts and doctrines
formed the theme of our discourse. My friend deprecated them most
devoutly; and then again he would deplore them, and lament the great
evil that such a man might do among the human race. I joined with him
in allowing the evil in its fullest latitude; and, at length, after he
thought he had fully prepared my nature for such a trial of its powers
and abilities, he proposed calmly that we two should make away with Mr.
Blanchard. I was so shocked, that my bosom became as it were a void,
and the beatings of my heart sounded loud and hollow in it; my breath
cut, and my tongue and palate became dry and speechless. He mocked at
my cowardice, and began a-reasoning on the matter with such powerful
eloquence, that before we parted, I felt fully convinced that it was
my bounden duty to slay Mr. Blanchard; but my will was far, very far
from consenting to the deed.
I spent the following night without sleep, or nearly so; and the
next morning, by the time the sun arose, I was again abroad, and in the
company of my illustrious friend. The same subject was resumed, and
again he reasoned to the following purport: That supposing me placed at
the head of an army of Christian soldiers, all bent on putting down the
enemies of the church, would I have any hesitation in destroying and
rooting out these enemies?—None surely.—Well then, when I saw and
was convinced, that here was an individual who was doing more detriment
to the church of Christ on earth, than tens of thousands of such
warriors were capable of doing, was it not my duty to cut him off, and
save the elect? "He, who would be a champion in the cause of Christ and
his Church, my brave young friend," added he, "must begin early, and no
man can calculate to what an illustrious eminence small beginings may
lead. If the man Blanchard is worthy, he is only changing his situation
for a better one; and if unworthy, it is better that one fall, than
that a thousand souls perish. Let us be up and doing in our vocations.
For me, my resolution is taken; I have but one great aim in this world,
and I never for a moment lose sight of it."
I was obliged to admit the force of his reasoning; for though I
cannot from memory repeat his words, his eloquence was of that
overpowering nature, that the subtility of other men sunk before it;
and there is also little doubt that the assurance I had that these
words were spoken by a great potentate, who could raise me to the
highest eminence, (provided that I entered into his extensive and
decisive measures,) assisted mightily in dispelling my youthful
scruples and qualms of conscience; and I thought moreover, that having
such a powerful back friend to support me, I hardly needed to be afraid
of the consequences. I consented! But begged a little time to think of
it. He said the less one thought of a duty the better; and we parted.
But the most singular instance of this wonderful man's power over my
mind was, that he had as complete influence over me by night as by day.
All my dreams corresponded exactly with his suggestions; and when he
was absent from me, still his arguments sunk deeper in my heart than
even when he was present. I dreamed that night of a great triumph
obtained, and though the whole scene was but dimly and confusedly
defined in my vision, yet the overthrow and death of Mr. Blanchard was
the first step by which I attained the eminent station I occupied.
Thus, by dreaming of the event by night, and discoursing of it by day,
it soon became so familiar to my mind, that I almost conceived it as
done. It was resolved on: which was the first and greatest victory
gained; for there was no difficulty in finding opportunities enow of
cutting off a man, who, every good day, was to be found walking by
himself in private grounds. I went and heard him preach for two days,
and in fact I held his tenets scarcely short of blasphemy; they were
such as I had never heard before, and his congregation, which was
numerous, were turning up their ears and drinking in his doctrines with
the utmost delight; for O, they suited their carnal natures and
self-sufficiency to a hair! He was actually holding it forth, as a
fact, that "it was every man's own blame if he was not saved!" What
horrible misconstruction! And then he was alleging, and trying to
prove from nature and reason, that no man ever was guilty of a sinful
action, who might not have declined it had he so chosen! "Wretched
controvertist!" thought I to myself an hundred times, "shall not the
sword of the Lord be moved from its place of peace for such presumtuous
and absurd testimonies as these!"
When I began to tell the prince about these false doctrines, to my
astonishment I found that he had been in the church himself, and had
every argument that the old divine had used verbatim; and he remarked
on them with great concern, that these were not the tenets that
corresponded with his views in society, and that he had agents in every
city, and every land, exerting their powers to put them down. I asked,
with great simplicity, "Are all your subjects Christians, prince?"
"All my European subjects are, or deem themselves so," returned he;
"and they are the most faithful and true subjects I have."
Who could doubt, after this, that he was the Czar of Russia? I have
nevertheless had reasons to doubt of his identity since that period,
and which of my conjectures is right, I believe the God of heaven only
knows, for I do not. I shall go on to write such things as I remember,
and if any one shall ever take the trouble to read over these
confessions, such a one will judge for himself. It will be observed,
that since ever I fell in with this extraordinary person, I have
written about him only, and I must continue to do so to the end of this
memoir, as I have performed no great or interesting action in which he
had not a principal share.
He came to me one day and said, "We must not linger thus in
executing what we have resolved on. We have much before our hands to
perform for the benefit of mankind, both civil as well as religious.
Let us do what we have to do here, and then we must wend our way to
other cities, and perhaps to other countries. Mr. Blanchard is to hold
forth in the high church of Paisley on Sunday next, on some
particularly great occasion: this must be defeated; he must not go
there. As he will be busy arranging his discourses, we may expect him
to be walking by himself in Finnieston Dell the greater part of Friday
and Saturday. Let us go and cut him off. What is the life of a man more
than the life of a lamb, or any guiltless animal? It is not half so
much, especially when we consider the immensity of the mischief this
old fellow is working among our fellow-creatures. Can there be any
doubt that it is the duty of one consecrated to God, to cut off such a
"I fear me, great sovereign," said I, "that your ideas of
retribution are too sanguine, and too arbitrary for the laws of this
country. I dispute not that your motives are great and high; but have
you debated the consequences, and settled the result?"
"I have," returned he, "and hold myself amenable for the action, to
the laws of God and of equity; as to the enactments of men I despise
them. Fain would I see the weapon of the Lord of Hosts, begin the work
of vengeance that awaits it to do!"
I could not help thinking, that I perceived a little derision of
countenance on his face as he said this, nevertheless I sunk dumb
before such a man, and aroused myself to the task, seeing he would not
have it deferred. I approved of it in theory, but my spirit stood aloof
from the practice. I saw and was convinced that the elect of God would
be happier, and purer, were the wicked and unbelievers all cut off from
troubling and misleading them, but if it had not been the instigations
of this illustrious stranger, I should never have presumed to begin so
great a work myself. Yet, though he often aroused my zeal to the
highest pitch, still my heart at times shrunk from the shedding of
lifeblood, and it was only at the earnest and unceasing instigations of
my enlightened and voluntary patron, that I at length put my hand to
the conclusive work. After I said all that I could say, and all had
been overborne, (I remember my actions and words as well as it had been
yesterday,) I turned round hesitatingly, and looked up to Heaven for
direction; but there was a dimness came over my eyes that I could not
see. The appearance was as if their had been a veil drawn over me, so
nigh that I put up my hand to feel it; and then Gil-Martin (as this
great sovereign was pleased to have himself called,) frowned, and asked
me what I was grasping at? I knew not what to say, but answered, with
fear and shame, "I have no weapons, not one; nor know I where any are
to be found."
"The God whom thou servest will provide these," said he; "if thou
provest worthy of the trust committed to thee."
I looked again up into the cloudy veil that covered us, and thought
I beheld golden weapons of every description let down in it, but all
with their points towards me. I kneeled, and was going to stretch out
my hand to take one, when my patron seized me, as I thought, by the
clothes, and dragged me away with as much ease as I had been a lamb,
saying, with a joyful and elevated voice,— "Come, my friend, let us
depart: thou art dreaming—thou art dreaming. Rouse up all the
energies of thy exalted mind, for thou art an highly-favoured one; and
doubt thou not, that he whom thou servest, will be ever at thy right
and left hand, to direct and assist thee."
These words, but particularly the vision I had seen, of the golden
weapons descending out of Heaven, inflamed my zeal to that height that
I was as one beside himself; which my parents perceived that night, and
made some motions toward confining me to my room. I joined in the
family prayers, and then I afterwards sung a psalm and prayed by
myself; and I had good reasons for believing that that small oblation
of praise and prayer was not turned to sin. But there are strange
things, and unaccountable agencies in nature: He only who dwells
between the Cherubim can unriddle them, and to him the honour must
redound for ever. Amen.
I felt greatly strengthened and encouraged that night, and the next
morning I ran to meet my companion, out of whose eye I had now no life.
He rejoiced at seeing me so forward in the great work of reformation by
blood, and said many things to raise my hopes of future fame and glory;
and then, producing two pistols of pure beaten gold, he held them out
and proffered me the choice of one, saying, "See what thy master hath
provided thee!" I took one of them eagerly, for I perceived at once
that they were two of the very weapons that were let down from Heaven
in the cloudy veil, the dim tapestry of the firmament; and I said to
myself, "Surely this is the will of the Lord."
The little splendid and enchanting piece was so perfect, so
complete, and so ready for executing the will of the donor, that I now
longed to use it in his service. I loaded it with my own hand, as
Gil-Martin did the other, and we took our stations behind a bush of
hawthorn and bramble on the verge of the wood, and almost close to the
walk. My patron was so acute in all his calculations that he never
mistook an event. We had not taken our stand above a minute and a half,
till old Mr. Blanchard appeared, coming slowly on the path. When we
saw this, we cowered down, and leaned each of us a knee upon the
ground, pointing the pistols through the bush, with an aim so steady,
that it was impossible to miss our victim.
He came deliberately on, pausing at times so long, that we dreaded
he was going to turn. Gil-Martin dreaded it, and I said I did, but
wished in my heart that he might. He, however, came onward, and I will
never forget the manner in which he came! No—I don't believe I ever
can forget it, either in the narrow bounds of time or the ages of
eternity! He was a boardly ill-shaped man, of a rude exterior, and a
little bent with age; his hands were clasped behind his back, and below
his coat, and he walked with a slow swinging air that was very
peculiar. When he paused and looked abroad on nature, the act was
highly impressive: he seemed conscious of being all alone, and
conversant only with God and the elements of his creation. Never was
there such a picture of human inadvertency! a man approaching step by
step to the one that was to hurl him out of one existence into another,
with as much ease and indifference as the ox goeth to the stall.
Hideous vision, wilt thou not be gone from my mental sight! If not,
let me bear with thee as I can!
When he came straight opposite to the muzzles of our pieces,
Gil-Martin called out "Eh!" with a short quick sound. The old man,
without starting, turned his face and breast toward us, and looked into
the wood, but looked over our heads. "Now!" whispered my companion, and
fired. But my hand refused the office, for I was not at that moment
sure about becoming an assassin in the cause of Christ and his Church.
I thought I heard a sweet voice behind me, whispering me to beware, and
I was going to look round, when my companion exclaimed, "Coward, we are
I had no time for an alternative: Gil-Martin's ball had not taken
effect, which was altogether wonderful, as the old man's breast was
within a few yards of him. "Hilloa!" cried Blanchard; "what is that
for, you dog!" and with that he came forward to look over the bush. I
hesitated, as I said, and attempted to look behind me; but there was no
time: the next step discovered two assassins lying in covert, waiting
for blood. "Coward, we are ruined!" cried my indignant friend; and that
moment my piece was discharged. The effect was as might have been
expected: the old man first stumbled to one side, and then fell on his
back. We kept our places, and I perceived my companion's eyes gleaming
with an unnatural joy. The wounded man raised himself from the bank to
a sitting posture, and I beheld his eyes swimming; he, however,
appeared sensible, for we heard him saying in a low and rattling voice,
"Alas, alas! whom have I offended, that they should have been driven to
an act like this! Come forth and shew yourselves, that I may either
forgive you before I die, or curse you in the name of the Lord." He
then fell agroping with both hands on the ground, as if feeling for
something he had lost, manifestly in the agonies of death; and, with a
solemn and interrupted prayer for forgiveness, he breathed his last.
I had become rigid as a statue, whereas my associate appeared to be
elevated above measure. "Arise, thou faint-hearted one, and let us be
going," said he. "Thou hast done well for once; but wherefore hesitate
in such a cause? This is but a small beginning of so great a work as
that of purging the Christian world. But the first victim is a worthy
one, and more of such lights must be extinguished immediately."
We touched not our victim, nor any thing pertaining to him, for fear
of staining our hands with his blood; and the firing having brought
three men within view, who were hasting towards the spot, my undaunted
companion took both the pistols, and went forward as with intent to
meet them, bidding me shift for myself. I ran off in a contrary
direction, till I came to the foot of the Pearman Sike, and then,
running up the hollow of that, I appeared on the top of the bank as if
I had been another man brought in view by hearing the shots in such a
place. I had a full view of a part of what passed, though not of all. I
saw my companion going straight to meet the men, apparently with a
pistol in every hand, waving in a careless manner. They seemed not
quite clear of meeting with him, and so he went straight on, and passed
between them. They looked after him, and came onward; but when they
came to the old man lying stretched in his blood, then they turned and
pursued my companion, though not so quickly as they might have done;
and I understood that from the first they saw no more of him.
Great was the confusion that day in Glasgow. The most popular of all
their preachers of morality was (what they called) murdered in cold
blood, and a strict and extensive search was made for the assassin.
Neither of the accomplices was found, however, that is certain, nor was
either of them so much as suspected; but another man was apprehended
under circumstances that warranted suspicion.— This was one of the
things that I witnessed in my life, which I never understood, and it
surely was one of my patron's most dexterous tricks, for I must still
say, what I have thought from the beginning, that like him there never
was a man created. The young man who was taken up was a preacher; and
it was proved that he had purchased fire arms in town, and gone out
with them that morning. But the far greatest mystery of the whole was,
that two of the men, out of the three who met my companion, swore, that
that unfortunate preacher was the man whom they met with a pistol in
each hand, fresh from the death of the old divine. The poor fellow made
a confused speech himself, which there is not the least doubt was quite
true; but it was laughed to scorn, and an expression of horror ran
through both the hearers and jury. I heard the whole trial, and so did
Gil-Martin; but we left the journeyman preacher to his fate, and from
that time forth I have had no faith in the justice of criminal trials.
If once a man is prejudiced on one side, he will swear any thing in
support of such prejudice. I tried to expostulate with my mysterious
friend on the horrid injustice of suffering this young man to die for
our act, but the prince exulted in it more than the other, and said the
latter was the most dangerous man of the two.
The alarm in and about Glasgow was prodigious. The country being
divided into two political parties, the court and the country party,
the former held meetings, issued proclamations, and offered rewards,
ascribing all to the violence of party spirit, and deprecating the
infernal measures of their opponents. I did not understand their
political differences; but it was easy to see that the true Gospel
preachers joined all on one side, and the upholders of pure morality
and a blameless life on the other, so that this division proved a test
to us, and it was forthwith resolved, that we two should pick out some
of the leading men of this unsaintly and heterodox cabal, and cut them
off one by one, as occasion should suit.
Now, the ice being broke, I felt considerable zeal in our great
work, but pretended much more; and we might soon have kidnapped them
all through the ingenuity of my patron, had not our next attempt
miscarried, by some awkwardness or mistake of mine. The consequence
was, that he was discovered fairly, and very nigh seized. I also was
seen, and suspected so far, that my reverend father, my mother, and
myself were examined privately. I denied all knowledge of the matter;
and they held it in such a ridiculous light, and their conviction of
the complete groundlessness of the suspicion was so perfect, that their
testimony prevailed, and the affair was hushed. I was obliged, however,
to walk circumspectly, and saw my companion the prince very seldom, who
was prowling about every day, quite unconcerned about his safety. He
was every day a new man, however, and needed not to be alarmed at any
danger; for such a facility had he in disguising himself, that if it
had not been for a pass-word which we had between us, for the purposes
of recognition, I never could have known him myself.
It so happened that my reverend father was called to Edinburgh about
this time, to assist with his council in settling the national
affairs. At my earnest request I was permitted to accompany him, at
which both my associate and I rejoiced, as we were now about to move in
a new and extensive field. All this time I never knew where my
illustrious friend resided. He never once invited me to call on him at
his lodgings, nor did he ever come to our house, which made me
sometimes to suspect, that if any of our great efforts in the cause of
true religion were discovered, he intended leaving me in the lurch.
Consequently, when we met in Edinburgh (for we travelled not in
company) I proposed to go with him to look for lodgings, telling him at
the same time what a blessed religious family my reverend instructor
and I were settled in. He said he rejoiced at it, but he made a rule of
never lodging in any particular house, but took these daily, or hourly,
as he found it convenient, and that he never was at a loss in any
"What a mighty trouble you put yourself to, great sovereign!" said
I, "and all, it would appear, for the purpose of seeing and knowing
more and more of the human race."
"I never go but where I have some great purpose to serve," returned
he, "either in the advancement of my own power and dominion, or in
thwarting my enemies."
"With all due deference to your great comprehension, my illustrious
friend," said I, "it strikes me that you can accomplish very little
either the one way or the other here, in the humble and private
capacity you are pleased to occupy."
"It is your own innate modesty that prompts such a remark," said he.
"Do you think the gaining of you to my service, is not an attainment
worthy of being envied by the greatest potentate in Christendom? Before
I had missed such a prize as the attainment of your services, I would
have travelled over one half of the habitable globe."— I bowed with
great humility, but at the same time how could I but feel proud and
highly flattered? He continued. "Believe me, my dear friend, for such a
prize I account no effort too high. For a man who is not only dedicated
to the King of Heaven, in the most solemn manner, soul, body, and
spirit, but also chosen of him from the beginning, justified,
sanctified, and received into a communion that never shall be broken,
and from which no act of his shall ever remove him,—the possession of
such a man, I tell you, is worth kingdoms; because every deed that he
performs, he does it with perfect safety to himself and honour to
me."—I bowed again, lifting my hat, and he went on.—"I am now going
to put his courage in the cause he has espoused, to a severe test—to
a trial at which common nature would revolt, but he who is dedicated to
be the sword of the Lord, must raise himself above common humanity. You
have a father and a brother according to the flesh, what do you know of
"I am sorry to say I know nothing good," said I. "They are
reprobates, cast-aways, beings devoted to the wicked one, and, like
him, workers of every species of iniquity with greediness."
"They must both fall!" said he, with a sigh and melancholy look: "It
is decreed in the councils above, that they must both fall by your
"The God of heaven forbid it!" said I. "They are enemies to Christ
and his church, that I know and believe; but they shall live and die in
their iniquity for me, and reap their guerdon when their time cometh.
There my hand shall not strike."
"The feeling is natural, and amiable," said he; "but you must think
again. Whether are the bonds of carnal nature, or the bonds and vows
of the Lord, strongest?"
"I will not reason with you on this head, mighty potentate," said I,
"for whenever I do so it is but to be put down. I shall only express my
determination, not to take vengeance out of the Lord's hand in this
instance. It availeth not. These are men that have the mark of the
beast in their foreheads and right hands; they are lost beings
themselves, but have no influence over others. Let them perish in their
sins; for they shall not be meddled with by me."
"How preposterously you talk, my dear friend!" said he. "These
people are your greatest enemies; they would rejoice to see you
annihilated. And now that you have taken up the Lord's cause of being
avenged on his enemies, wherefore spare those that are your own as well
as his? Besides, you ought to consider what great advantages would be
derived to the cause of righteousness and truth, were the estate and
riches of that opulent house in your possession, rather than in that of
such as oppose the truth and all manner of holiness."
This was a portion of the consequence of following my illustrious
adviser's summary mode of procedure, that had never entered into my
calculation —I disclaimed all idea of being influenced by it;
however, I cannot but say that the desire of being enabled to do so
much good, by the possession of these bad men's riches, made some
impression on my heart, and I said I would consider of the matter. I
did consider it, and that right seriously as well as frequently; and
there was scarcely an hour in the day on which my resolves were not
animated by my great friend, till at length I began to have a longing
desire to kill my brother, in particular. Should any man ever read this
scroll, he will wonder at this confession, and deem it savage and
unnatural. So it appeared to me at first, but a constant thinking of an
event changes every one of its features. I have done all for the best,
and as I was prompted, by one who knew right and wrong much better than
I did. I had a desire to slay him, it is true, and such a desire too as
a thirsty man has to drink; but at the same time, this longing desire
was mingled with a certain terror, as if I had dreaded that the drink
for which I longed was mixed with deadly poison. My mind was so much
weakened, or rather softened about this time, that my faith began a
little to give way, and I doubted most presumptuously of the least
tangible of all Christian tenets, namely, of the infallibility of the
elect. I hardly comprehended the great work I had begun, and doubted of
my own infallibility, or that of any created being. But I was brought
over again by the unwearied diligence of my friend to repent of my
backsliding, and view once more the superiority of the Almighty's
counsels in its fullest latitude. Amen.
I prayed very much in secret about this time, and that with great
fervor of spirit, as well as humility; and my satisfaction at finding
all my requests granted is not to be expressed.
My illustrious friend still continuing to sound in my ears the
imperious duty to which I was called, of making away with my sinful
relations, and quoting many parallel actions out of the Scriptures, and
the writings of the holy Fathers, of the pleasure the Lord took in such
as executed his vengeance on the wicked, I was obliged to acquiesce in
his measures, though with certain limitations. It was not easy to
answer his arguments, and yet I was afraid that he soon perceived a
leaning to his will on my part. "If the acts of Jehu, in rooting out
the whole house of his master, were ordered and approved of by the
Lord," said he, "would it not have been more praiseworthy if one of
Ahab's own sons had stood up for the cause of the God of Israel, and
rooted out the sinners and their idols out of the land?"
"It would certainly," said I. "To our duty to God all other duties
"Go thou then and do likewise," said he. "Thou art called to a high
vocation; to cleanse the sanctuary of thy God in this thy native land
by the shedding of blood; go thou forth then like a ruling energy, a
master spirit of desolation in the dwellings of the wicked, and high
shall be your reward both here and hereafter."
My heart now panted with eagerness to look my brother in the face:
On which my companion, who was never out of the way, conducted me to a
small square in the suburbs of the city, where there were a number of
young noblemen and gentlemen playing at a vain, idle, and sinful game,
at which there was much of the language of the accursed going on; and
among these blasphemers he instantly pointed out my brother to me. I
was fired with indignation at seeing him in such company, and so
employed; and I placed myself close beside him to watch all his
motions, listen to his words, and draw inferences from what I saw and
heard. In what a sink of sin was he wallowing! I resolved to take him
to task, and if he refused to be admonished, to inflict on him some
condign punishment; and knowing that my illustrious friend and director
was looking on, I resolved to show some spirit. Accordingly, I waited
until I heard him profane his Maker's name three times, and then, my
spiritual indignation being roused above all restraint, I went up and
kicked him. Yes, I went boldly up and struck him with my foot, and
meant to have given him a more severe blow than it was my fortune to
inflict. It had, however, the effect of rousing up his corrupt nature
to quarrelling and strife, instead of taking the chastisement of the
Lord in humility and meekness. He ran furiously against me in the
choler that is always inspired by the wicked one; but I overthrew him,
by reason of impeding the natural and rapid progress of his unholy
feet, running to destruction. I also fell slightly; but his fall
proving a severe one, he arose in wrath, and struck me with the mall
which he held in his hand, until my blood flowed copiously; and from
that moment I vowed his destruction in my heart. But I chanced to have
no weapon at that time, nor any means of inflicting due punishment on
the caitiff, which would not have been returned double on my head, by
him and his graceless associates. I mixed among them at the suggestion
of my friend, and following them to their den of voluptuousness and
sin, I strove to be admitted among them, in hopes of finding some means
of accomplishing my great purpose, while I found myself moved by the
spirit within me so to do. But I was not only debarred, but, by the
machinations of my wicked brother and his associates, cast into prison.
I was not sorry at being thus honoured to suffer in the cause of
righteousness, and at the hands of sinful men; and as soon as I was
alone, I betook myself to prayer, deprecating the long-suffering of God
toward such horrid sinners. My jailer came to me, and insulted me. He
was a rude unprincipled fellow, partaking much of the loose and carnal
manners of the age; but I remembered of having read, in the Cloud of
Witnesses, of such men formerly, having been converted by the
imprisoned saints; so I set myself, with all my heart, to bring about
this man's repentance and reformation.
"Fat the deil are ye yoolling an' praying that gate for, man?" said
he, coming angrily in. "I thought the days o' praying prisoners had
been a' ower. We had rowth o' them aince; an' they were the poorest an'
the blackest bargains that ever poor jailers saw. Gie up your crooning,
or I'll pit you to an in-by place, where ye sall get plenty o't."
"Friend," said I, "I am making my appeal at that bar where all human
actions are seen and judged, and where you shall not be forgot, sinful
as you are. Go in peace, and let me be."
"Hae ye naebody nearer-hand hame to mak your appeal to, man?" said
he; "because an ye haena, I dread you an' me may be unco weel
acquaintit by an' by?"
I then opened up the mysteries of religion to him in a clear and
perspicuous manner, but particularly the great doctrine of the election
of grace; and then I added, "Now, friend, you must tell me if you
pertain to this chosen number. It is in every man's power to ascertain
this, and it is every man's duty to do it."
"An' fat the better wad you be for the kenning o' this, man?" said
"Because, if you are one of my brethren, I will take you into sweet
communion and fellowship," returned I; "but if you belong to the
unregenerate, I have a commission to slay you."
"The deil you hae, callant!" said he, gaping and laughing. "An' pray
now, fa was it that gae you siccan a braw commission?"
"My commission is sealed by the signet above," said I, "and that I
will let you and all sinners know. I am dedicated to it by the most
solemn vows and engagements. I am the sword of the Lord, and Famine and
Pestilence are my sisters. Wo then to the wicked of this land, for they
must fall down dead together, that the church may be purified!"
"Oo, foo, foo! I see how it is," said he; "yours is a very braw
commission, but you will have the small opportunity of carrying it
through here. Take my advising, and write a bit of a letter to your
friends, and I will send it, for this is no place for such a great man.
If you cannot steady your hand to write, as I see you have been at your
great work, a word of a mouth may do; for I do assure you this is not
the place at all, of any in the world, for your operations."
The man apparently thought I was deranged in my intellect. He could
not swallow such great truths at the first morsel. So I took his
advice, and sent a line to my reverend father, who was not long in
coming, and great was the jailer's wonderment when he saw all the great
Christian noblemen of the land sign my bond of freedom.
My reverend father took this matter greatly to heart, and bestirred
himself in the good cause till the transgressors were ashamed to shew
their faces. My illustrious companion was not idle: I wondered that he
came not to me in prison, nor at my release; but he was better
employed, in stirring up the just to the execution of God's decrees;
and he succeeded so well, that my brother and all his associates had
nearly fallen victims to their wrath: But many were wounded, bruised,
and imprisoned, and much commotion prevailed in the city. For my part,
I was greatly strengthened in my resolution by the anathemas of my
reverend father, who, privately, (that is in a family capacity,) in his
prayers, gave up my father and brother, according to the flesh, to
Satan, making it plain to all my senses of perception, that they were
beings given up of God, to be devoured by fiends or men, at their will
and pleasure, and that whosoever should slay them, would do God good
The next morning my illustrious friend met me at an early hour, and
he was greatly overjoyed at hearing my sentiments now chime so much in
unison with his own. I said, "I longed for the day and the hour that I
might look my brother in the face at Gilgal, and visit on him the
iniquity of his father and himself, for that I was now strengthened and
prepared for the deed."
"I have been watching the steps and movements of the profligate
one," said he; "and lo, I will take you straight to his presence. Let
your heart be as the heart of the lion, and your arms strong as the
shekels of brass, and swift to avenge as the bolt that descendeth from
Heaven, for the blood of the just and the good hath long flowed in
Scotland. But already is the day of their avengement begun; the hero is
at length arisen, who shall send all such as bear enmity to the true
church, or trust in works of their own, to Tophet!"
Thus encouraged, I followed my friend, who led me directly to the
same court in which I had chastised the miscreant on the foregoing day;
and behold, there was the same group again assembled. They eyed me
with terror in their looks, as I walked among them and eyed them with
looks of disapprobation and rebuke; and I saw that the very eye of a
chosen one lifted on these children of Belial, was sufficient to dismay
and put them to flight. I walked aside to my friend, who stood at a
distance looking on, and he said to me, "What thinkest thou now?" and I
answered in the words of the venal prophet, "Lo now, if I had a sword
into mine hand, I would even kill him."
"Wherefore lackest thou it?" said he. "Dost thou not see that they
tremble at thy presence, knowing that the avenger of blood is among
My heart was lifted up on hearing this, and again I strode into the
midst of them, and eyeing them with threatening looks, they were so
much confounded, that they abandoned their sinful pastime, and fled
every one to his house!
This was a palpable victory gained over the wicked, and I thereby
knew that the hand of the Lord was with me. My companion also exulted,
and said, "Did not I tell thee? Behold thou dost not not know one half
of thy might, or of the great things thou art destined to do. Come with
me and I will show thee more than this, for these young men cannot
subsist without the exercises of sin. I listened to their councils, and
I know where they will meet again."
Accordingly he led me a little farther to the south, and we walked
aside till by degrees we saw some people begin to assemble; and in a
short time we perceived the same group stripping off their clothes to
make them more expert in the practice of madness and folly. Their game
was begun before we approached, and so also were the oaths and cursing.
I put my hands in my pockets, and walked with dignity and energy into
the midst of them. It was enough: Terror and astonishment seized them.
A few of them cried out against me, but their voices were soon hushed
amid the murmurs of fear. One of them, in the name of the rest, then
came and besought of me to grant them liberty to amuse themselves; but
I refused peremptorily, dared the whole multitude so much as to touch
me with one of their fingers, and dismissed them in the name of the
Again they all fled and dispersed at my eye, and I went home in
triumph, escorted by my friend, and some well-meaning young Christians,
who, however, had not learned to deport themselves with soberness and
humility. But my ascendency over my enemies was great indeed; for
wherever I appeared I was hailed with approbation, and whereever my
guilty brother made his appearance, he was hooted and held in derision,
till he was forced to hide his disgraceful head, and appear no more in
Immediately after this I was seized with a strange distemper, which
neither my friends nor physicians could comprehend, and it confined me
to my chamber for many days; but I knew, myself, that I was bewitched,
and suspected my father's reputed concubine of the deed. I told my
fears to my reverend protector, who hesitated concerning them, but I
knew by his words and looks that he was conscious I was right. I
generally conceived myself to be two people. When I lay in bed, I
deemed there were two of us in it; when I sat up, I always beheld
another person, and always in the same position from the place where I
sat or stood, which was about three paces off me towards my left side.
It mattered not how many or how few were present: this my second self
was sure to be present in his place; and this occasioned a confusion in
all my words and ideas that utterly astounded my friends, who all
declared, that instead of being deranged in my intellect, they had
never heard my conversation manifest so much energy or sublimity of
conception; but for all that, over the singular delusion that I was two
persons, my reasoning faculties had no power. The most perverse part of
it was, that I rarely conceived myself to be any of the two persons. I
thought for the most part that my companion was one of them, and my
brother the other; and I found, that to be obliged to speak and answer
in the character of another man, was a most awkward business at the
Who can doubt, from this statement, that I was bewitched, and that
my relatives were at the ground of it? The constant and unnatural
persuasion that I was my brother, proved it to my own satisfaction, and
must, I think, do so to every unprejudiced person. This victory of the
wicked one over me kept me confined in my chamber, at Mr. Millar's
house, for nearly a month, until the prayers of the faithful prevailed,
and I was restored. I knew it was a chastisement for my pride, because
my heart was lifted up at my superiority over the enemies of the
church; nevertheless, I determined to make short work with the
aggressor, that the righteous might not be subjected to the effect of
his diabolical arts again.
I say I was confined a month. I beg he that readeth to take note of
this, that he may estimate how much the word, or even the oath, of a
wicked man, is to depend on. For a month I saw no one but such as came
into my room, and for all that, it will be seen, that there were plenty
of the same set to attest upon oath that I saw my brother every day
during that period; that I persecuted him with my presence day and
night, while all the time I never saw his face, save in a delusive
dream. I cannot comprehend what manoeuvres my illustrious friend was
playing off with them about this time; for he, having the art of
personating whom he chose, had peradventure deceived them, else so many
of them had never all attested the same thing. I never saw any man so
steady in his friendships and attentions as he; but as he made a rule
of never calling at private houses, for fear of some discovery being
made of his person, so I never saw him while my malady lasted; but as
soon as I grew better, I knew I had nothing ado but to attend at some
of our places of meeting, to see him again. He was punctual, as usual,
and I had not to wait.
My reception was precisely as I apprehended. There was no flaring,
no flummery, nor bombastical pretensions, but a dignified return to my
obeisance, and an immediate recurrence, in converse, to the important
duties incumbent on us, in our stations, as reformers and purifiers of
"I have marked out a number of most dangerous characters in this
city," said he, "all of whom must be cut off from cumbering the true
vineyard before we leave this land. And if you bestir not yourself in
the work to which you are called, I must raise up others who shall have
the honour of it."
"I am, most illustrious prince, wholly at your service," said I.
"Show but what ought to be done, and here is the heart to dare, and the
hand to execute. You pointed out my relations, according to the flesh,
as brands fitted to be thrown into the burning. I approve peremptorily
of the award; nay, I thirst to accomplish it; for I myself have
suffered severely from their diabolical arts. When once that trial of
my devotion to the faith is accomplished, then be your future
"You are free of your words and promises," said he.
"So will I be of my deeds in the service of my master, and that
shalt thou see," said I. "I lack not the spirit, nor the will, but I
lack experience wofully; and because of that shortcoming, must bow to
"Meet me here to-morrow betimes," said he, "and perhaps you may hear
of some opportunity of displaying your zeal in the cause of
I met him as he desired me; and he addressed me with a hurried and
joyful expression, telling me that my brother was astir, and that a few
minutes ago he had seen him pass on his way to the mountain. "The hill
is wrapped in a cloud," added he, "and never was there such an
opportunity of executing divine justice on a guilty sinner. You may
trace him in the dew, and shall infallibly find him on the top of some
precipice; for it is only in secret that he dares show his debased head
to the sun."
"I have no arms, else assuredly I would pursue him and discomfit
him," said I.
"Here is a small dagger," said he; "I have nothing of weapon-kind
about me save that, but it is a potent one; and should you require it,
there is nothing more ready or sure."
"Will not you accompany me?" said I: "Sure you will?"
"I will be with you, or near you," said he. "Go you on before."
I hurried away as he directed me, and imprudently asked some of
Queensberry's guards if such and such a young man passed by them going
out from the city. I was answered in the affirmative, and till then had
doubted of my friend's intelligence, it was so inconsistent with a
profligate's life to be so early astir. When I got the certain
intelligence that my brother was before me, I fell a-running, scarcely
knowing what I did; and looking several times behind me, I perceived
nothing of my zealous and arbitrary friend. The consequence of this
was, that by the time I reached St. Anthony's well, my resolution began
to give way. It was not my courage, for now that I had once shed blood
in the cause of the true faith, I was exceedingly bold and ardent; but
whenever I was left to myself, I was subject to sinful doubtings. These
always hankered on one point: I doubted if the elect were infallible,
and if the Scripture promises to them were binding in all situations
and relations. I confess this, and that it was a sinful and shameful
weakness in me, but my nature was subject to it, and I could not eschew
it. I never doubted that I was one of the elect myself; for, besides
the strong inward and spiritual conviction that I possessed, I had my
kind father's assurance; and these had been revealed to him in that
way and measure that they could not be doubted.
In this desponding state, I sat myself down on a stone, and
bethought me of the rashness of my understanding. I tried to ascertain,
to my own satisfaction, whether or not I really had been commissioned
of God to perpetrate these crimes in his behalf, for in the eyes, and
by the laws of men, they were great and crying transgressions. While I
sat pondering on these things, I was involved in a veil of white misty
vapour, and looking up to heaven, I was just about to ask direction
from above, when I heard as it were a still small voice close by me,
which uttered some words of derision and chiding. I looked intensely in
the direction whence it seemed to come, and perceived a lady, robed in
white, who hasted toward me. She regarded me with a severity of look
and gesture that appalled me so much, I could not address her; but she
waited not for that, but coming close to my side, said, without
stopping, "Preposterous wretch! how dare you lift your eyes to heaven
with such purposes in your heart? Escape homeward, and save your soul,
or farewell for ever!"
These were all the words that she uttered, as far as I could ever
recollect, but my spirits were kept in such a tumult that morning, that
something might have escaped me. I followed her eagerly with my eyes,
but in a moment she glided over the rocks above the holy well, and
vanished. I persuaded myself that I had seen a vision, and that the
radiant being that had addressed me was one of the good angels, or
guardian spirits, commissioned by the Almighty to watch over the steps
of the just. My first impulse was to follow her advice, and make my
escape home; for I thought to myself, "How is this interested and
mysterious foreigner, a proper judge of the actions of a free
The thought was hardly framed, nor had I moved in a retrograde
direction six steps, when I saw my illustrious friend and great adviser
descending the ridge towards me with hasty and impassioned strides. My
heart fainted within me; and when he came up and addressed me, I looked
as one caught in a trespass. "What hath detained thee, thou desponding
trifler?" said he. "Verily now shall the golden opportunity be lost
which may never be recalled. I have traced the reprobate to his
sanctuary in the cloud, and lo he is perched on the pinnacle of a
precipice an hundred fathoms high. One ketch with thy foot, or toss
with thy finger, shall throw him from thy sight into the foldings of
the cloud, and he shall be no more seen, till found at the bottom of
the cliff dashed to pieces. Make haste therefore, thou loiterer, if
thou wouldst ever prosper and rise to eminence in the work of thy Lord
"I go no farther on this work," said I, "for I have seen a vision
that has reprimanded the deed."
"A vision?" said he: "Was it that wench who descended from the hill?"
"The being that spake to me, and warned me of my danger, was indeed
in the form of a lady," said I.
"She also approached me and said a few words," returned he; "and I
thought there was something mysterious in her manner. Pray, what did
she say? for the words of such a singular message, and from such a
messenger, ought to be attended to. If I understood her aright, she was
chiding us for our misbelief and preposterous delay."
I recited her words, but he answered that I had been in a state of
sinful doubting at the time, and it was to these doubtings she had
adverted. In short, this wonderful and clear-sighted stranger soon
banished all my doubts and despondency, making me utterly ashamed of
them, and again I set out with him in the pursuit of my brother. He
showed me the traces of his footsteps in the dew, and pointed out the
spot where I should find him. "You have nothing more to do than go
softly down behind him," said he; "which you can do to within an ell of
him, without being seen; then rush upon him, and throw him from his
seat, where there is neither footing nor hold. I will go, meanwhile,
and amuse his sight by some exhibition in the contrary direction, and
he shall neither know nor perceive who has done him this kind office:
for, exclusive of more weighty concerns, be assured of this, that the
sooner he falls, the fewer crimes will he have to answer for, and his
estate in the other world will be proportionally more tolerable, than
if he spent a long unregenerate life steeped in iniquity to the
loathing of the soul."
"Nothing can be more plain or more pertinent," said I: "therefore I
fly to perform that which is both a duty toward God and toward man!"
"You shall yet rise to great honour and preferment," said he.
"I value it not, provided I do honour and justice to the cause of my
master here," said I.
"You shall be lord of your father's riches and demesnes," added he.
"I disclaim and deride every selfish motive thereto relating," said
I, "farther than as it enables me to do good."
"Ay, but that is a great and a heavenly consideration, that longing
for ability to do good," said he;—and as he said so, I could not help
remarking a certain derisive exultation of expression which I could not
comprehend; and indeed I have noted this very often in my illustrious
friend, and sometimes mentioned it civilly to him, but he has never
failed to disclaim it. On this occasion I said nothing, but concealing
his poniard in my clothes, I hasted up the mountain, determined to
execute my purpose before any misgivings should again visit me; and I
never had more ado, than in keeping firm my resolution. I could not
help my thoughts, and there are certain trains and classes of thoughts
that have great power in enervating the mind. I thought of the awful
thing of plunging a fellow creature from the top of a cliff into the
dark and misty void below—of his being dashed to pieces on the
protruding rocks, and of hearing his shrieks as he descended the cloud,
and beheld the shagged points on which he was to alight. Then I thought
of plunging a soul so abruptly into hell, or, at the best, sending it
to hover on the confines of that burning abyss—of its appearance at
the bar of the Almighty to receive its sentence. And then I thought,
"Will there not be a sentence pronounced against me there, by a jury of
the just made perfect, and written down in the registers of heaven?"
These thoughts, I say, came upon me unasked, and instead of being
able to dispel them, they mustered, upon the summit of my imagination,
in thicker and stronger array: and there was another that impressed me
in a very particular manner, though, I have reason to believe, not so
strongly as those above written. It was this: "What if I should fail
in my first effort? Will the consequence not be that I am tumbled from
the top of the rock myself?" and then all the feelings anticipated,
with regard to both body and soul, must happen to me! This was a
spine-breaking reflection; and yet, though the probability was rather
on that side, my zeal in the cause of godliness was such that it
carried me on, maugre all danger and dismay.
I soon came close upon my brother, sitting on the dizzy pinnacle,
with his eyes fixed stedfastly in the direction opposite to me. I
descended the little green ravine behind him with my feet foremost, and
every now and then raised my head, and watched his motions. His posture
continued the same, until at last I came so near him I could have heard
him breathe, if his face had been towards me. I laid my cap aside, and
made me ready to spring upon him, and push him over. I could not for my
life accomplish it! I do not think it was that I durst not, for I have
always felt my courage equal to any thing in a good cause. But I had
not the heart, or something that I ought to have had. In short, it was
not done in time, as it easily might have been. These THOUGHTS are hard
enemies wherewith to combat! And I was so grieved that I could not
effect my righteous purpose, that I laid me down on my face and shed
tears. Then, again, I thought of what my great enlightened friend and
patron would say to me, and again my resolution rose indignant, and
indissoluble save by blood. I arose on my right knee and left foot, and
had just begun to advance the latter forward: the next step my great
purpose had been accomplished, and the culprit had suffered the
punishment due to his crimes. But what moved him I knew not: in the
critical moment he sprung to his feet, and dashing himself furiously
against me, he overthrew me, at the imminent peril of my life. I
disencumbered myself by main force, and fled, but he overhied me,
knocked me down, and threatened, with dreadful oaths, to throw me from
the cliff. After I was a little recovered from the stunning blow, I
aroused myself to the combat; and though I do not recollect the
circumstances of that deadly scuffle very minutely, I know that I
vanquished him so far as to force him to ask my pardon, and crave a
reconciliation. I spurned at both, and left him to the chastisements of
his own wicked and corrupt heart.
My friend met me again on the hill, and derided me, in a haughty and
stern manner, for my imbecility and want of decision. I told him how
nearly I had effected my purpose, and excused myself as well as I was
able. On this, seeing me bleeding, he advised me to swear the peace
against my brother, and have him punished in the mean time, he being
the first aggressor. I promised compliance, and we parted, for I was
somewhat ashamed of my failure, and was glad to be quit for the present
of one of whom I stood so much in awe.
When my reverend father beheld me bleeding a second time by the hand
of a brother, he was moved to the highest point of displeasure; and,
relying on his high interest and the justice of his cause, he brought
the matter at once before the courts. My brother and I were first
examined face to face. His declaration was a mere romance: mine was not
the truth; but as it was by the advice of my reverend father, and that
of my illustrious friend, both of whom I knew to be sincere Christians
and true believers, that I gave it, I conceived myself completly
justified on that score. I said, I had gone up into the mountain early
on the morning to pray, and had withdrawn myself, for entire privacy,
into a little sequestered dell—had laid aside my cap, and was in the
act of kneeling, when I was rudely attacked by my brother, knocked
over, and nearly slain. They asked my brother if this was true. He
acknowledged that it was; that I was bare-headed, and in the act of
kneeling when he ran foul of me without any intent of doing so. But the
judge took him to task on the improbability of this, and put the
profligate sore out of countenance. The rest of his tale told still
worse, insomuch that he was laughed at by all present, for the judge
remarked to him, that granting it was true that he had at first run
against me on an open mountain, and overthrown me by accident, how was
it, that after I had extricated myself and fled, that he had pursued,
overtaken, and knocked me down a second time? Would he pretend that all
that was likewise by chance? The culprit had nothing to say for himself
on this head, and I shall not forget my exultation and that of my
reverend father, when the sentence of the judge was delivered. It was,
that my wicked brother should be thrown into prison, and tried on a
criminal charge of assault and battery, with the intent of committing
murder. This was a just and righteous judge, and saw things in their
proper bearings, that is, he could discern between a righteous and a
wicked man, and then there could be no doubt as to which of the two
were acting right, and which wrong.
Had I not been sensible that a justified person could do nothing
wrong, I should not have been at my ease concerning the statement I had
been induced to give on this occasion. I could easily perceive, that by
rooting out the weeds from the garden of the Church, I heightened the
growth of righteousness; but as to the tardy way of giving false
evidence on matters of such doubtful issue, I confess I saw no great
propriety in it from the beginning. But I now only moved by the will
and mandate of my illustrious friend: I had no peace or comfort when
out of his sight, nor have I ever been able to boast of much in his
presence; so true is it that a Christian's life is one of suffering.
My time was now much occupied, along with my reverend preceptor, in
making ready for the approaching trial, as the prosecutors. Our counsel
assured us of a complete victory, and that banishment would be the
mildest award of the law on the offender. Mark how different was the
result! From the shifts and ambiguities of a wicked Bench, who had a
fellow-feeling of iniquity with the defenders, —my suit was cast, the
graceless libertine was absolved, and I was incarcerated, and bound
over to keep the peace, with heavy penalties, before I was set at
I was exceedingly disgusted at this issue, and blamed the counsel of
my friend to his face. He expressed great grief, and expatiated on the
wickedness of our judicatories, adding, "I see I cannot depend on you
for quick and summary measures, but for your sake I shall be revenged
on that wicked judge, and that you shall see in a few days." The Lord
Justice Clerk died that same week! But he died in his own house and his
own bed, and by what means my friend effected it, I do not know. He
would not tell me a single word of the matter, but the judge's sudden
death made a great noise, and I made so many curious inquiries
regarding the particulars of it, that some suspicions were like to
attach to our family, of some unfair means used. For my part I know
nothing, and rather think he died by the visitation of Heaven, and that
my friend had foreseen it, by symptoms, and soothed me by promises of
It was some days before he mentioned my brother's meditated death to
me again, and certainly he then found me exasperated against him
personally to the highest degree. But I told him that I could not now
think any more of it, owing to the late judgment of the court, by
which, if my brother were missing or found dead, I would not only
forfeit my life, but my friends would be ruined by the penalties.
"I suppose you know and believe in the perfect safety of your soul,"
said he, "and that that is a matter settled from the beginning of time,
and now sealed and ratified both in heaven and earth?"
"I believe in it thoroughly and perfectly," said I; "and whenever I
entertain doubts of it, I am sensible of sin and weakness."
"Very well, so then am I," said he. "I think I can now divine, with
all manner of certainty, what will be the high and merited guerdon of
your immortal part. Hear me then farther: I give you my solemn
assurance, and bond of blood, that no human hand shall ever henceforth
be able to injure your life, or shed one drop of your precious blood,
but it is on the condition that you walk always by my directions."
"I will do so with cheerfulness," said I; "for without your
enlightened counsel, I feel that I can do nothing. But as to your power
of protecting my life, you must excuse me for doubting of it. Nay, were
we in your own proper dominions, you could not ensure that."
"In whatever dominion or land I am, my power accompanies me," said
he; "and it is only against human might and human weapon that I ensure
your life; on that will I keep an eye, and on that you may depend. I
have never broken word or promise with you. Do you credit me?"
"Yes, I do," said I; "for I see you are in earnest. I believe,
though I do not comprehend you."
"Then why do you not at once challenge your brother to the field of
honour? Seeing you now act without danger, cannot you also act without
"It is not fear," returned I; "believe me, I hardly know what fear
is. It is a doubt, that on all these emergencies constantly haunts my
mind, that in performing such and such actions I may fall from my
upright state. This makes fratricide a fearful task."
"This is imbecility itself," said he. "We have settled, and agreed
on that point an hundred times. I would therefore advise that you
challenge your brother to single combat. I shall ensure your safety,
and he cannot refuse giving you satisfaction."
"But then the penalties?" said I.
"We will try to evade these," said he; "and supposing you should be
caught, if once you are Laird of Dalcastle and Balgrennan, what are the
penalties to you?"
"Might we not rather pop him off in private and quietness, as we did
the deistical divine?" said I.
"The deed would be alike meritorious, either way," said he. "But may
we not wait for years before we find an opportunity? My advice is to
challenge him, as privately as you will, and there cut him off."
"So be it then," said I. "When the moon is at the full, I will send
for him forth to speak with one, and there will I smite him and slay
him, and he shall trouble the righteous no more."
"Then this is the very night," said he. "The moon is nigh to the
full, and this night your brother and his sinful mates hold carousal;
for there is an intended journey to-morrow. The exulting profligate
leaves town, where we must remain till the time of my departure hence;
and then is he safe, and must live to dishonour God, and not only
destroy his own soul, but those of many others. Alack, and wo is me!
The sins that he and his friends will commit this very night, will cry
to heaven against us for our shameful delay! When shall our great work
of cleansing the sanctuary be finished, if we proceed at this puny
"I see the deed must be done, then," said I; "and since it is so,
it shall be done. I will arm myself forthwith, and from the midst of
his wine and debauchery you shall call him forth to me, and there will
I smite him with the edge of the sword, that our great work be not
"If thy execution were equal to thy intent, how great a man you soon
might be!" said he. "We shall make the attempt once more; and if it
fail again, why, I must use other means to bring about my high purposes
relating to mankind.—Home and make ready. I will go and procure what
information I can regarding their motions, and will meet you in
disguise twenty minutes hence, at the first turn of Hewie's lane beyond
"I have nothing to make ready," said I; "for I do not choose to go
home. Bring me a sword, that we may consecrate it with prayer and vows,
and if I use it not to the bringing down of the wicked and profane,
then may the Lord do so to me, and more also!"
We parted, and there was I left again to the multiplicity of my own
thoughts for the space of twenty minutes, a thing my friend never
failed in subjecting me to, and these were worse to contend with than
hosts of sinful men. I prayed inwardly, that these deeds of mine might
never be brought to the knowledge of men who were incapable of
appreciating the high motives that led to them; and then I sung part of
the 10th Psalm, likewise in spirit; but for all these efforts, my
sinful doubts returned, so that when my illustrious friend joined me,
and proffered me the choice of two gilded rapiers, I declined accepting
any of them, and began, in a very bold and energetic manner, to express
my doubts regarding the justification of all the deeds of perfect men.
He chided me severely, and branded me with cowardice, a thing that my
nature never was subject to; and then he branded me with falsehood,
and breach of the most solemn engagements both to God and man.
I was compelled to take the rapier, much against my inclination; but
for all the arguments, threats, and promises that he could use, I would
not consent to send a challenge to my brother by his mouth. There was
one argument only that he made use of which had some weight with me,
but yet it would not preponderate. He told me my brother was gone to a
notorious and scandalous habitation of women, and that if I left him to
himself for ever so short a space longer, it might embitter his state
through ages to come. This was a trying concern to me; but I resisted
it, and reverted to my doubts. On this he said that he had meant to do
me honour, but since I put it out of his power, he would do the deed,
and take the responsibility on himself. "I have with sore travail
procured a guardship of your life," added he. "For my own, I have not;
but, be that as it will, I shall not be baffled in my attempts to
benefit my friends without a trial. You will at all events accompany
me, and see that I get justice?"
"Certes, I will do thus much," said I; "and wo be to him if his arm
prevail against my friend and patron!"
His lip curled with a smile of contempt, which I could hardly brook;
and I began to be afraid that the eminence to which I had been destined
by him was already fading from my view. And I thought what I should
then do to ingratiate myself again with him, for without his
countenance I had no life. "I will be a man in act," thought I, "but in
sentiment I will not yield, and for this he must surely admire me the
As we emerged from the shadowy lane into the fair moonshine, I
started so that my whole frame underwent the most chilling vibrations
of surprise. I again thought I had been taken at unawares, and was
conversing with another person. My friend was equipped in the Highland
garb, and so completely translated into another being, that, save by
his speech, all the senses of mankind could not have recognized him. I
blessed myself, and asked whom it was his pleasure to personify
to-night? He answered me carelessly, that it was a spark whom he meant
should bear the blame of whatever might fall out to-night; and that was
all that passed on the subject.
We proceeded by some stone steps at the foot of the North Loch, in
hot argument all the way. I was afraid that our conversation might be
overheard, for the night was calm and almost as light as day, and we
saw sundry people crossing us as we advanced. But the zeal of my friend
was so high, that he disregarded all danger, and continued to argue
fiercely and loudly on my delinquency, as he was pleased to call it. I
stood on one argument alone, which was, "that I did not think the
Scripture promises to the elect, taken in their utmost latitude,
warranted the assurance that they could do no wrong; and that,
therefore, it behoved every man to look well to his steps."
There was no religious scruple that irritated my enlightened friend
and master so much as this. He could not endure it. And the sentiments
of our great covenanted reformers being on his side, there is not a
doubt that I was wrong. He lost all patience on hearing what I advanced
on this matter, and taking hold of me, he led me into a darksome booth
in a confined entry; and, after a friendly but cutting reproach, he
bade me remain there in secret and watch the event; "and if I fall,"
said he, "you will not fail to avenge my death?"
I was so entirely overcome with vexation that I could make no
answer, on which he left me abruptly, a prey to despair; and I saw or
heard no more, till he came down to the moonlight green followed by my
brother. They had quarrelled before they came within my hearing, for
the first words I heard were those of my brother, who was in a state of
intoxication, and he was urging a reconciliation, as was his wont on
such occasions. My friend spurned at the suggestion, and dared him to
the combat; and after a good deal of boastful altercation, which the
turmoil of my spirits prevented me from remembering, my brother was
compelled to draw his sword and stand on the defensive. It was a
desperate and terrible engagement. I at first thought that the royal
stranger and great champion of the faith would overcome his opponent
with ease, for I considered heaven as on his side; and nothing but the
arm of sinful flesh against him. But I was deceived: The sinner stood
firm as a rock, while the assailant flitted about like a shadow, or
rather like a spirit. I smiled inwardly, conceiving that these
lightsome manoeuvres were all a sham to show off his art and mastership
in the exercise, and that whenever they came to close fairly, that
instant my brother would be overcome. Still I was deceived: My
brother's arm seemed invincible, so that the closer they fought the
more palpably did it prevail. They fought round the green to the very
edge of the water, and so round, till they came close up to the covert
where I stood. There being no more room to shift ground, my brother
then forced him to come to close quarters, on which, the former still
having the decided advantage, my friend quitted his sword, and called
out. I could resist no longer; so, springing from my concealment, I
rushed between them with my sword drawn, and parted them as if they had
been two schoolboys: then turning to my brother, I addressed him as
follows:—"Wretch! miscreant! knowest thou what thou art attempting?
Wouldst thou lay thine hand on the Lord's anointed, or shed his
precious blood? Turn thee to me, that I may chastise thee for all thy
wickedness, and not for the many injuries thou hast done to me!" To it
we went, with full thirst of vengeance on every side. The duel was
fierce; but the might of heaven prevailed, and not my might. The
ungodly and reprobate young man fell, covered with wounds, and with
curses and blasphemy in his mouth, while I escaped uninjured. Thereto
his power extended not.
I will not deny, that my own immediate impressions of this affair in
some degree differed from this statement. But this is precisely as my
illustrious friend described it to me afterwards, and I can rely
implicitly on his information, as he was at that time a looker-on, and
my senses all in a state of agitation, and he could have no motive for
saying what was not the positive truth.
Never till my brother was down did we perceive that there had been
witnesses to the whole business. Our ears were then astounded by rude
challenges of unfair play, which were quite appalling to me; but my
friend laughed at them, and conducted me off in perfect safety. As to
the unfairness of the transaction, I can say thus much, that my royal
friend's sword was down ere ever mine was presented. But if it still be
accounted unfair to take up a conqueror, and punish him in his own way,
I answer: That if a man is sent on a positive mission by his master,
and hath laid himself under vows to do his work, he ought not to be too
nice in the means of accomplishing it; and farther, I appeal to holy
writ, wherein many instances are recorded of the pleasure the Lord
takes in the final extinction of the wicked and profane; and this
position I take to be unanswerable.
I was greatly disturbed in my mind for many days, knowing that the
transaction had been witnessed, and sensible also of the perilous
situation I occupied, owing to the late judgment of the court against
me. But, on the contrary, I never saw my enlightened friend in such
high spirits. He assured me there was no danger; and again repeated,
that he warranted my life against the power of man. I thought proper,
however, to remain in hiding for a week; but, as he said, to my utter
amazement, the blame fell on another, who was not only accused, but
pronounced guilty by the general voice, and outlawed for
non-appearance! how could I doubt, after this, that the hand of heaven
was aiding and abetting me? The matter was beyond my comprehension; and
as for my friend, he never explained any thing that was past, but his
activity and art were without a parallel.
He enjoyed our success mightily; and for his sake I enjoyed it
somewhat, but it was on account of his comfort only, for I could not
for my life perceive in what degree the church was better or purer
than before these deeds were done. He continued to flatter me with
great things, as to honours, fame, and emolument; and, above all, with
the blessing and protection of him to whom my body and soul were
dedicated. But after these high promises, I got no longer peace; for he
began to urge the death of my father with such an unremitting
earnestness, that I found I had nothing for it but to comply. I did so;
and cannot express his enthusiasm of approbation. So much did he hurry
and press me in this, that I was forced to devise some of the most
openly violent measures, having no alternative. Heaven spared me the
deed, taking, in that instance, the vengeance in its own hand; for
before my arm could effect the sanguine but meritorious act, the old
man followed his son to the grave. My illustrious and zealous friend
seemed to regret this somewhat; but he comforted himself with the
reflection, that still I had the merit of it, having not only consented
to it, but in fact effected it, for by doing the one action I had
brought about both.
No sooner were the obsequies of the funeral over, than my friend and
I went to Dalcastle, and took undisputed possession of the houses,
lands, and effects that had been my father's; but his plate, and vast
treasures of ready money, he had bestowed on a voluptuous and unworthy
creature, who had lived long with him as a mistress. Fain would I have
sent her after her lover, and gave my friend some hints on the
occasion; but he only shook his head, and said that we must lay all
selfish and interested motives out of the question.
For a long time, when I awaked in the morning, I could not believe
my senses, that I was indeed the undisputed and sole proprietor of so
much wealth and grandeur; and I felt so much gratified, that I
immediately set about doing all the good I was able, hoping to meet
with all approbation and encouragement from my friend. I was mistaken:
He checked the very first impulses towards such a procedure, questioned
my motives, and uniformly made them out to be wrong. There was one
morning that a servant said to me, there was a lady in the back chamber
who wanted to speak with me, but he could not tell me who it was, for
all the old servants had left the mansion, every one on hearing of the
death of the late laird, and those who had come knew none of the people
in the neighbourhood. From several circumstances, I had suspicions of
private confabulations with women, and refused to go to her, but bid
the servant inquire what she wanted. She would not tell; she could only
state the circumstances to me; so I, being sensible that a little
dignity of manner became me in my elevated situation, returned for
answer, that if it was business that could not be transacted by my
steward, it must remain untransacted. The answer which the servant
brought back was of a threatening nature. She stated that she must see
me, and if I refused her satisfaction there, she would compel it where
I should not evite her.
My friend and director appeared pleased with my dilemma, and rather
advised that I should hear what the woman had to say; on which I
consented, provided she would deliver her mission in his presence. She
came in with manifest signs of anger and indignation, and began with a
bold and direct charge against me of a shameful assault on one of her
daughters; of having used the basest of means in order to lead her
aside from the paths of rectitude; and on the failure of these, of
having resorted to the most unqualified measures.
I denied the charge in all its bearings, assuring the dame that I
had never so much as seen either of her daughters to my knowledge, far
less wronged them; on which she got into great wrath, and abused me to
my face as an accomplished vagabond, hypocrite, and sensualist; and she
went so far as to tell me roundly, that if I did not marry her
daughter, she would bring me to the gallows, and that in a very short
"Marry your daughter, honest woman!" said I, "on the faith of a
Christian, I never saw your daughter; and you may rest assured in this,
that I will neither marry you nor her. Do you consider how short a time
I have been in this place? How much that time has been occupied? And
how there was even a possibility that I could have accomplished such
"And how long does your Christian reverence suppose you have
remained in this place since the late laird's death?" said she.
"That is too well known to need recapitulation," said I: "only a
very few days, though I cannot at present specify the exact number;
perhaps from thirty to forty, or so. But in all that time, certes, I
have never seen either you or any of your two daughters that you talk
of. You must be quite sensible of that."
My friend shook his head three times during this short sentence,
while the woman held up her hands in amazement and disgust, exclaiming,
"There goes the self-righteous one! There goes the consecrated youth,
who cannot err! You, sir, know, and the world shall know of the faith
that is in this most just, devout, and religious miscreant! Can you
deny that you have already been in this place four months and seven
days? Or that in that time you have been forbid my house twenty times?
Or that you have persevered in your endeavours to effect the basest and
most ungenerous of purposes? Or that you have attained them? hypocrite
and deceiver as you are! Yes, sir; I say, dare you deny that you have
attained your vile, selfish, and degrading purposes towards a young,
innocent, and unsuspecting creature, and thereby ruined a poor widow's
only hope in this world? No, you cannot look in my face, and deny aught
"The woman is raving mad!" said I. "You, illustrious sir, know, that
in the first instance, I have not yet been in this place one month." My
friend shook his head again, and answered me, "You are wrong, my dear
friend; you are wrong. It is indeed the space of time that the lady
hath stated, to a day, since you came here, and I came with you; and I
am sorry that I know for certain that you have been frequently haunting
her house, and have often had private correspondence with one of the
young ladies too. Of the nature of it I presume not to know."
"You are mocking me," said I. "But as well may you try to reason me
out of my existence, as to convince me that I have been here even one
month, or that any of those things you allege against me has the shadow
of truth or evidence to support it. I will swear to you, by the great
God that made me; and by—"
"Hold, thou most abandoned profligate!" cried she violently, "and
do not add perjury to your other detestable crimes. Do not, for mercy's
sake, any more profane that name whose attributes you have wrested and
disgraced. But tell me what reparation you propose offering to my
"I again declare, before heaven, woman, that to the best of my
knowledge and recollection, I never saw your daughter. I now think I
have some faint recollection of having seen your face, but where, or in
what place, puzzles me quite."
"And, why?" said she. "Because for months and days you have been in
such a state of extreme inebriety, that your time has gone over like a
dream that has been forgotten. I believe, that from the day you came
first to my house, you have been in a state of utter delirium, and that
principally from the fumes of wine and ardent spirits."
"It is a manifest falsehood!" said I; "I have never, since I entered
on the possession of Dalcastle, tasted wine or spirits, saving once, a
few evenings ago; and, I confess to my shame, that I was led too far;
but I have craved forgiveness and obtained it. I take my noble and
distinguished friend there for a witness to the truth of what I assert;
a man who has done more, and sacrificed more for the sake of genuine
Christianity, than any this world contains. Him you will believe."
"I hope you have attained forgiveness," said he, seriously. "Indeed
it would be next to blasphemy to doubt it. But, of late, you have been
very much addicted to intemperance. I doubt if, from the first night
you tasted the delights of drunkenness, that you have ever again been
in your right mind until Monday last. Doubtless you have been for a
good while most diligent in your addresses to this lady's daughter."
"This is unaccountable," said I. "It is impossible that I can have
been doing a thing, and not doing it at the same time. But indeed,
honest woman, there have several incidents occurred to me in the course
of my life which persuade me I have a second self; or that there is
some other being who appears in my likeness."
Here my friend interrupted me with a sneer, and a hint that I was
talking insanely; and then he added, turning to the lady, "I know my
friend Mr. Colwan will do what is just and right. Go and bring the
young lady to him, that he may see her, and he will then recollect all
his former amours with her."
"I humbly beg your pardon, sir," said I. "But the mention of such a
thing as amours with any woman existing, to me, is really so absurd, so
far from my principles, so far from the purity of nature and frame to
which I was born and consecrated, that I hold it as an insult, and
regard it with contempt."
I would have said more in reprobation of such an idea, had not my
servant entered, and said, that a gentleman wanted to see me on
business. Being glad of an opportunity of getting quit of my lady
visitor, I ordered the servant to show him in; and forthwith a little
lean gentleman, with a long acquiline nose, and a bald head, daubed all
over with powder and pomatum, entered. I thought I recollected having
seen him too, but could not remember his name, though he spoke to me
with the greatest familiarity; at least, that sort of familiarity that
an official person generally assumes. He bustled about and about,
speaking to every one, but declined listening for a single moment to
any. The lady offered to withdraw, but he stopped her.
"No, no, Mrs. Keeler, you need not go; you need not go; you must not
go, madam. The business I came about, concerns you—yes, that it
does—Bad business yon of Walker's? Eh? Could not help it—did all I
could, Mr. Wringhim. Done your business. Have it all cut and dry here,
sir—No, this is not it—Have it among them, though—I'm at a little
loss for your name, sir, (addressing my friend,)—seen you very often,
though—exceedingly often—quite well acquainted with you."
"No, sir, you are not," said my friend, sternly. —The intruder
never regarded him; never so much as lifted his eyes from his bundle
of law papers, among which he was bustling with great hurry and
importance, but went on—
"Impossible! Have seen a face very like it, then—what did you
say your name was, sir?— very like it indeed. Is it not the young
laird who was murdered whom you resemble so much?"
Here Mrs. Keeler uttered a scream, which so much startled me, that
it seems I grew pale. And on looking at my friend's face, there was
something struck me so forcibly in the likeness between him and my late
brother, that I had very nearly fainted. The woman exclaimed, that it
was my brother's spirit that stood beside me.
"Impossible!" exclaimed the attorney; "at least I hope not, else his
signature is not worth a pin. There is some balance due on yon
business, madam. Do you wish your account? because I have it here,
ready discharged, and it does not suit letting such things lie over.
This business of Mr. Colwan's will be a severe one on you, madam,
—rather a severe one."
"What business of mine, if it be your will, sir," said I. "For my
part I never engaged you in business of any sort, less or more." He
never regarded me, but went on. "You may appeal, though: Yes, yes,
there are such things as appeals for the refractory. Here it is,
gentlemen,—here they are all together—Here is, in the first place,
sir, your power of attorney, regularly warranted, sealed, and signed
with your own hand."
"I declare solemnly that I never signed that document," said I.
"Ay, ay, the system of denial is not a bad one in general," said my
attorney; "but at present there is no occasion for it. You do not deny
your own hand?"
"I deny every thing connected with the business," cried I; "I
disclaim it in toto, and declare that I know no more about it than the
"That is exceedingly good!" exclaimed he; "I like your pertinacity
vastly! I have three of your letters, and three of your signatures;
that part is all settled, and I hope so is the whole affair; for here
is the original grant to your father, which he has never thought proper
to put in requisition. Simple gentleman! But here have I, Lawyer
Linkum, in one hundredth part of the time that any other notary,
writer, attorney, or writer to the signet in Britain, would have done
it, procured the signature of his Majesty's commissioner, and thereby
confirmed the charter to you and your house, sir, for ever and
ever,—Begging your pardon, madam." The lady, as well as myself,
tried several times to interrupt the loquacity of Linkum, but in vain:
he only raised his hand with a quick flourish, and went on:—
"Here it is:—'James, by the grace of God, King of Great Britain,
France, and Ireland, to his right trust cousin, sendeth greeting:' And
whereas his right leal and trust-worthy cousin, George Colwan, of
Dalcastle and Balgrennan, hath suffered great losses, and undergone
much hardship, on behalf of his Majesty's rights and titles; he
therefore, for himself, and as prince and steward of Scotland, and by
the consent of his right trusty cousins and councillors, hereby grants
to the said George Colwan, his heirs and assignees whatsomever,
heritably and irrevocably, all and haill the lands and others
underwritten: To wit, All and haill, the five merk land of Kipplerig;
the five pound land of Easter Knockward, with all the towers,
fortalices, manor-places, houses, biggings, yards, orchards, tofts,
crofts, mills, woods, fishings, mosses, muirs, meadows, commonties,
pasturages, coals, coal-heughs, tenants, tenantries, services of free
tenants, annexes, connexes, dependencies, parts, pendicles, and
pertinents of the same whatsomever; to be peaceably brooked, joysed,
set, used, and disposed of by him and his aboves, as specified,
heritably and irrevocably, in all time coming: And, in testimony
thereof, His Majesty, for himself, and as prince and steward of
Scotland, with the advice and consent of his foresaids, knowledge,
proper motive, and kingly power, makes, erects, creates, unites,
annexes, and incorporates, the whole lands above mentioned in an haill
and free barony, by all the rights, miethes, and marches thereof, old
and divided, as the same lies, in length and breadth, in houses,
biggings, mills, multures, hawking, hunting, fishing; with court,
plaint, herezeld, fock, fork, sack, sock, thole, thame, vert, wraik,
waith, wair, venison, outfang thief, infang thief, pit and gallows, and
all and sundry other commodities. Given at our Court of Whitehall, &c.
&c. God save the King.
'Compositio 5 lib. 13. 8.'
'Registrate 26th September, 1687.'
"See, madam, here are ten signatures of privy councillors of that
year, and here are other ten of the present year, with his Grace the
Duke of Queensberry at the head. All right—See here it is, sir,
—all right—done your work. So you see, madam, this gentleman is the
true and sole heritor of all the land that your father possesses, with
all the rents thereof for the last twenty years, and upwards —Fine
job for my employers!—sorry on your account, madam—can't help it."
I was again going to disclaim all interest or connection in the
matter, but my friend stopped me; and the plaints and lamentations of
the dame became so overpowering, that they put an end to all farther
colloquy; but Lawyer Linkum followed me, and stated his great outlay,
and the important services he had rendered me, until I was obliged to
subscribe an order to him for £100 on my banker.
I was now glad to retire with my friend, and ask seriously for some
explanation of all this. It was in the highest degree unsatisfactory.
He confirmed all that had been stated to me; assuring me, that I had
not only been assiduous in my endeavours to seduce a young lady of
great beauty, which it seemed I had effected, but that I had taken
counsel, and got this supposed, old, false, and forged grant, raked up
and new signed, to ruin the young lady's family quite, so as to throw
her entirely on myself for protection, and be wholly at my will.
This was to me wholly incomprehensible. I could have freely made
oath to the contrary of every particular. Yet the evidences were
against me, and of a nature not to be denied. Here I must confess,
that, highly as I disapproved of the love of women, and all intimacies
and connections with the sex, I felt a sort of indefinite pleasure, an
ungracious delight in having a beautiful woman solely at my disposal.
But I thought of her spiritual good in the meantime. My friend spoke of
my backslidings with concern; requesting me to make sure of my
forgiveness, and to forsake them; and then he added some words of sweet
comfort. But from this time forth I began to be sick at times of my
existence. I had heart-burnings, longings, and yearnings, that would
not be satisfied; and I seemed hardly to be an accountable creature;
being thus in the habit of executing transactions of the utmost moment,
without being sensible that I did them. I was a being incomprehensible
to myself. Either I had a second self, who transacted business in my
likeness, or else my body was at times possessed by a spirit over which
it had no controul, and of whose actions my own soul was wholly
unconscious. This was an anomaly not to be accounted for by any
philosophy of mine, and I was many times, in contemplating it, excited
to terrors and mental torments hardly describable. To be in a state of
consciousness and unconsciousness, at the same time, in the same body
and same spirit, was impossible. I was under the greatest anxiety,
dreading some change would take place momently in my nature; for of
dates I could make nothing: one-half, or two-thirds of my time, seemed
to me to be totally lost. I often, about this time, prayed with great
fervour, and lamented my hopeless condition, especially in being liable
to the commission of crimes, which I was not sensible of, and could not
eschew. And I confess, notwithstanding the promises on which I had been
taught to rely, I began to have secret terrors, that the great enemy of
man's salvation was exercising powers over me, that might eventually
lead to my ruin. These were but temporary and sinful fears, but they
added greatly to my unhappiness.
The worst thing of all was, what hitherto I had never felt, and, as
yet, durst not confess to myself, that the presence of my illustrious
and devoted friend was becoming irksome to me. When I was by myself, I
breathed freer, and my step was lighter; but, when he approached, a
pang went to my heart, and, in his company, I moved and acted as if
under a load that I could hardly endure. What a state to be in! And yet
to shake him off was impossible—we were incorporated
together—identified with one another, as it were, and the power was
not in me to separate myself from him. I still knew nothing who he was,
farther than that he was a potentate of some foreign land, bent on
establishing some pure and genuine doctrines of Christianity, hitherto
only half understood, and less than half exercised. Of this I could
have no doubts, after all that he had said, done, and suffered in the
cause. But, alongst with this, I was also certain, that he was
possessed of some supernatural power, of the source of which I was
wholly ignorant. That a man could be a Christian, and at the same time
a powerful necromancer, appeared inconsistent, and adverse to every
principle taught in our church; and from this I was led to believe,
that he inherited his powers from on high, for I could not doubt either
of the soundness of his principles, or that he accomplished things
impossible to account for.
Thus was I sojourning in the midst of a chaos of confusion. I looked
back on my bypast life with pain, as one looks back on a perilous
journey, in which he has attained his end, without gaining any
advantage either to himself, or others; and I looked forward, as on a
darksome waste, full of repulsive and terrific shapes, pitfalls, and
precipices, to which there was no definite bourne, and from which I
turned with disgust. With my riches, my unhappiness was increased
tenfold; and here, with another great acquisition of property, for
which I had pleaed, and which I had gained in a dream, my miseries and
difficulties were increasing. My principal feeling, about this time,
was an insatiable longing for something that I cannot describe or
denominate properly, unless I say it was for utter oblivion that I
longed. I desired to sleep; but it was for a deeper and longer sleep,
than that in which the senses were nightly steeped. I longed to be at
rest and quiet, and close my eyes on the past and the future alike, as
far as this frail life was concerned. But what had been formerly and
finally settled in the counsels above, I presumed not to call in
In this state of irritation and misery, was I dragging on an
existence, disgusted with all around me, and in particular with my
mother, who, with all her love and anxiety, had such an insufferable
mode of manifesting them, that she had by this time rendered herself
exceedingly obnoxious to me. The very sound of her voice at a distance,
went to my heart like an arrow, and made all my nerves to shrink; and
as for the beautiful young lady of whom they told me I had been so much
enamoured, I shunned all intercourse with her or hers, as I would have
done with the devil. I read some of their letters and burnt them, but
refused to see either the young lady or her mother, on any account.
About this time it was, that my worthy and reverend parent came with
one of his elders to see my mother and myself. His presence always
brought joy with it into our family, for my mother was uplifted, and I
had so few who cared for me, or for whom I cared, that I felt rather
gratified at seeing him. My illustrious friend was also much more
attached to him, than any other person, (except myself,) for their
religious principles tallied in every point, and their conversation was
interesting, serious, and sublime. Being anxious to entertain well and
highly the man to whom I had been so much indebted, and knowing that
with all his integrity and righteousness, he disdained not the good
things of this life, I brought from the late laird's well-stored
cellars, various fragrant and salubrious wines, and we drank and became
merry, and I found that my miseries and overpowering calamities, passed
away over my head like a shower that is driven by the wind. I became
elevated and happy, and welcomed my guests an hundred times; and then I
joined them in religious conversation, with a zeal and enthusiasm which
I had not often experienced, and which made all their hearts rejoice,
so that I said to myself, "Surely every gift of God is a blessing, and
ought to be used with liberality and thankfulness."
The next day I waked from a profound and feverish sleep, and called
for something to drink. There was a servant answered whom I had never
seen before, and he was clad in my servant's clothes and livery. I
asked for Andrew Handyside, the servant who had waited at table the
night before; but the man answered with a stare and a smile.
"What do you mean, sirrah," said I. "Pray what do you here? or what
are you pleased to laugh at? I desire you to go about your business,
and send me up Handyside. I want him to bring me something to drink."
"Ye sanna want a drink, maister," said the fellow: "Tak a hearty
ane, and see if it will wauken ye up something, sae that ye dinna ca'
for ghaists through your sleep. Surely ye haena forgotten that Andrew
Handyside has been in his grave these six months?"
This was a stunning blow to me. I could not answer farther, but sunk
back on my pillow as if I had been a lump of lead, refusing to take a
drink or any thing else at the fellow's hand, who seemed thus mocking
me with so grave a face. The man seemed sorry, and grieved at my being
offended, but I ordered him away, and continued sullen and thoughtful.
Could I have again been for a season in utter oblivion to myself, and
transacting business which I neither approved of, nor had any
connection with! I tried to recollect something in which I might have
been engaged, but nothing was pourtrayed on my mind subsequent to the
parting with my friends at a late hour the evening before. The evening
before it certainly was: but if so, how came it, that Andrew Handyside,
who served at table that evening, should have been in his grave six
months! This was a circumstance somewhat equivocal; therefore, being
afraid to arise lest accusations of I knew not what might come against
me, I was obliged to call once more in order to come at what
intelligence I could. The same fellow appeared to receive my orders as
before, and I set about examining him with regard to particulars. He
told me his name was Scrape; that I hired him myself; of whom I hired
him; and at whose recommendation. I smiled, and nodded so as to let the
knave see I understood he was telling me a chain of falsehoods, but did
not choose to begin with any violent asseverations to the contrary.
"And where is my noble friend and companion?" said I. "How has he
been engaged in the interim?"
"I dinna ken him, sir," said Scrape; "but have heard it said, that
the strange mysterious person that attended you, him that the maist
part of folks countit uncanny, had gane awa wi' a Mr. Ringan o' Glasko
last year, and had never returned."
I thanked the Lord in my heart for this intelligence, hoping that
the illustrious stranger had returned to his own land and people, and
that I should thenceforth be rid of his controlling and appalling
presence. "And where is my mother?" said I.—The man's breath cut
short, and he looked at me without returning any answer.—"I ask you
where my mother is?" said I.
"God only knows, and not I, where she is," returned he. "He knows
where her soul is, and as for her body, if you dinna ken something o'
it, I suppose nae man alive does."
"What do you mean, you knave?" said I. "What dark hints are these
you are throwing out? Tell me precisely and distinctly what you know of
"It is unco queer o' ye to forget, or pretend to forget every thing
that gate, the day, sir," said he. "I'm sure you heard enough about it
yestreen; an' I can tell you, there are some gayan ill-faurd stories
gaun about that business. But as the thing is to be tried afore the
circuit lords, it wad be far wrang to say either this or that to
influence the public mind; it is best just to let justice tak its
swee. I hae naething to say, sir. Ye hae been a good enough maister to
me, and paid my wages regularly, but ye hae muckle need to be innocent,
for there are some heavy accusations rising against you."
"I fear no accusations of man," said I, "as long as I can justify my
cause in the sight of Heaven; and that I can do this I am well aware.
Go you and bring me some wine and water, and some other clothes than
these gaudy and glaring ones."
I took a cup of wine and water; put on my black clothes, and walked
out. For all the perplexity that surrounded me, I felt my spirits
considerably buoyant. It appeared that I was rid of the two greatest
bars to my happiness, by what agency I knew not. My mother, it seemed,
was gone, who had become a grievous thorn in my side of late, and my
great companion and counsellor, who tyrannized over every spontaneous
movement of my heart, had likewise taken himself off. This last was an
unspeakable relief; for I found that for a long season I had only been
able to act by the motions of his mysterious mind and spirit. I
therefore thanked God for my deliverance, and strode through my woods
with a daring and heroic step; with independence in my eye, and freedom
swinging in my right hand.
At the extremity of the Colwan wood, I perceived a figure
approaching me with slow and dignified motion. The moment that I beheld
it, my whole frame received a shock as if the ground on which I walked
had sunk suddenly below me. Yet, at that moment, I knew not who it was;
it was the air and motion of some one that I dreaded, and from whom I
would gladly have escaped; but this I even had not power to attempt. It
came slowly onward, and I advanced as slowly to meet it; yet when we
came within speech, I still knew not who it was. It bore the figure,
air, and features of my late brother, I thought, exactly; yet in all
these there were traits so forbidding, so mixed with an appearance of
misery, chagrin, and despair, that I still shrunk from the view, not
knowing on whose face I looked. But when the being spoke, both my
mental and bodily frame received another shock more terrible than the
first, for it was the voice of the great personage I had so long
denominated my friend, of whom I had deemed myself for ever freed, and
whose presence and counsels I now dreaded more than hell. It was his
voice, but so altered—I shall never forget it till my dying day. Nay,
I can scarce conceive it possible that any earthly sounds could be so
discordant, so repulsive to every feeling of a human soul, as the tones
of the voice that grated on my ear at that moment. They were the sounds
of the pit, wheezed through a grated cranny, or seemed so to my
"So! Thou shudderest at my approach now, dost thou?" said he. "Is
this all the gratitude that you deign for an attachment of which the
annals of the world furnish no parallel? An attachment which has caused
me to forego power and dominion, might, homage, conquest and adulation,
all that I might gain one highly valued and sanctified spirit, to my
great and true principles of reformation among mankind. Wherein have I
offended? What have I done for evil, or what have I not done for your
good, that you would thus shun my presence?"
"Great and magnificent prince," said I humbly, "let me request of
you to abandon a poor worthless wight to his own wayward fortune, and
return to the dominion of your people. I am unworthy of the sacrifices
you have made for my sake; and after all your efforts, I do not feel
that you have rendered me either more virtuous or more happy. For the
sake of that which is estimable in human nature, depart from me to your
own home, before you render me a being either altogether above, or
below the rest of my fellow creatures. Let me plod on towards heaven
and happiness in my own way, like those that have gone before me, and I
promise to stick fast by the great principles which you have so
strenuously inculcated, on condition that you depart and leave me for
"Sooner shall you make the mother abandon the child of her bosom;
nay, sooner cause the shadow to relinquish the substance, than separate
me from your side. Our beings are amalgamated, as it were, and
consociated in one, and never shall I depart from this country until I
can carry you in triumph with me."
I can in nowise describe the effect this appalling speech had on me.
It was like the announcement of death to one who had of late deemed
himself free, if not of something worse than death, and of longer
continuance. There was I doomed to remain in misery, subjugated, soul
and body, to one whose presence was become more intolerable to me than
ought on earth could compensate: And at that moment, when he beheld
the anguish of my soul, he could not conceal that he enjoyed it. I was
troubled for an answer, for which he was waiting: it became incumbent
on me to say something after such a protestation of attachment; and, in
some degree to shake the validity of it, I asked, with great
simplicity, where he had been all this while?
"Your crimes and your extravagancies forced me from your side for a
season," said he; "but now that I hope the day of grace is returned, I
am again drawn towards you by an affection that has neither bounds nor
interest; an affection for which I receive not even the poor return of
gratitude, and which seems to have its radical sources in fascination.
I have been far, far abroad, and have seen much, and transacted much,
since I last spoke with you. During that space, I grievously suspect
that you have been guilty of great crimes and misdemeanours, crimes
that would have sunk an unregenerated person to predition; but as I
knew it to be only a temporary falling off, a specimen of that liberty
by which the chosen and elected ones are made free, I closed my eyes on
the wilful debasement of our principles, knowing that the
transgressions could never be accounted to your charge, and that in
good time you would come to your senses, and throw the whole weight of
your crimes on the shoulders that had voluntarily stooped to receive
"Certainly I will," said I, "as I and all the justified have a good
right to do. But what crimes? What misdemeanours and transgressions do
you talk about? For my part, I am conscious of none, and am utterly
amazed at insinuations which I do not comprehend."
"You have certainly been left to yourself for a season," returned
he, "having gone on rather like a person in a delirium, than a
Christian in his sober senses. You are accused of having made away with
your mother privately; as also of the death of a beautiful young lady,
whose affections you had seduced."
"It is an intolerable and monstrous falsehood!" cried I,
interrupting him; "I never laid a hand on a woman to take away her
life, and have even shunned their society from my childhood: I know
nothing of my mother's exit, nor of that young lady's whom you
"I hope it is so," said he. "But it seems there are some strong
presumptuous proofs against you, and I came to warn you this day that a
precognition is in progress, and that unless you are perfectly
convinced, not only of your innocence, but of your ability to prove it,
it will be the safest course for you to abscond, and let the trial go
on without you."
"Never shall it be said that I shrunk from such a trial as this,"
said I. "It would give grounds for suspicions of guilt that never had
existence, even in thought. I will go and show myself in every public
place, that no slanderous tongue may wag against me. I have shed the
blood of sinners, but of these deaths I am guiltless; therefore, I will
face every tribunal, and put all my accusers down."
"Asseveration will avail you but little," answered he, composedly:
"It is, however, justifiable in its place, although to me it signifies
nothing, who know too well that you did commit both crimes, in your own
person, and with your own hands. Far be it from me to betray you;
indeed, I would rather endeavour to palliate the offences; for though
adverse to nature, I can prove them not to be so to the cause of pure
Christianity, by the mode of which we have approved of it, and which
we wish to promulgate."
"If this that you tell me be true," said I, "then is it as true that
I have two souls, which take possession of my bodily frame by turns,
the one being all unconscious of what the other performs; for as sure
as I have at this moment a spirit within me, fashioned and destined to
eternal felicity, as sure am I utterly ignorant of the crimes you now
lay to my charge."
"Your supposition may be true in effect," said he. "We are all
subjected to two distinct natures in the same person. I myself have
suffered grievously in that way. The spirit that now directs my
energies is not that with which I was endowed at my creation. It is
changed within me, and so is my whole nature. My former days were those
of grandeur and felicity. But, would you believe it? I was not then a
Christian. Now I am. I have been converted to its truths by passing
through the fire, and since my final conversion, my misery has been
extreme. You complain that I have not been able to render you more
happy than you were. Alas! do you expect it in the difficult and
exterminating career which you have begun. I, however, promise you
this—a portion of the only happiness which I enjoy, sublime in its
motions, and splendid in its attainments—I will place you on the
right hand of my throne, and show you the grandeur of my domains, and
the felicity of my millions of true professors."
I was once more humbled before this mighty potentate, and promised
to be ruled wholly by his directions, although at that moment my nature
shrunk from the concessions, and my soul longed rather to be inclosed
in the deeps of the sea, or involved once more in utter oblivion. I was
like Daniel in the den of lions, without his faith in divine support,
and wholly at their mercy. I felt as one round whose body a deadly
snake is twisted, which continues to hold him in its fangs, without
injuring him, farther than in moving its scaly infernal folds with
exulting delight, to let its victim feel to whose power he has
subjected himself; and thus did I for a space drag an existence from
day to day, in utter weariness and helplessness; at one time
worshipping with great fervour of spirit, and at other times so wholly
left to myself, as to work all manner of vices and follies with
greediness. In these my enlightened friend never accompanied me, but I
always observed that he was the first to lead me to every one of them,
and then leave me in the lurch. The next day, after these my fallings
off, he never failed to reprove me gently, blaming me for my venial
transgressions; but then he had the art of reconciling all, by
reverting to my justified and infallible state, which I found to prove
a delightful healing salve for every sore.
But, of all my troubles, this was the chief: I was every day and
every hour assailed with accusations of deeds of which I was wholly
ignorant; of acts of cruelty, injustice, defamation, and deceit; of
pieces of business which I could not be made to comprehend; with
law-suits, details, arrestments of judgment, and a thousand
interminable quibbles from the mouth of my loquacious and conceited
attorney. So miserable was my life rendered by these continued attacks,
that I was often obliged to lock myself up for days together, never
seeing any person save my man Samuel Scrape, who was a very honest
blunt fellow, a staunch Cameronian, but withal very little conversant
in religious matters. He said he came from a place called Penpunt,
which I thought a name so ludicrous, that I called him by the name of
his native village, an appellation of which he was very proud, and
answered every thing with more civility and perspicuity when I
denominated him Penpunt, than Samuel, his own Christian name. Of this
peasant was I obliged to make a companion on sundry occasions, and
strange indeed were the details which he gave me concerning myself, and
the ideas of the country people concerning me. I took down a few of
these in writing, to put off the time, and here leave them on record to
show how the best and greatest actions are misconstrued among sinful
and ignorant men.
"You say, Samuel, that I hired you myself— that I have been a
good enough master to you, and have paid you your weekly wages
punctually. Now, how is it that you say this, knowing, as you do, that
I never hired you, and never paid you a sixpence of wages in the whole
course of my life, excepting this last month?"
"Ye may as weel say, master, that water's no water, or that stanes
are no stanes. But that's just your gate, an' it is a great pity aye to
do a thing an' profess the clean contair. Weel then, since you havena
paid me ony wages, an' I can prove day and date when I was hired, an'
came hame to your service, will you be sae kind as to pay me now?
That's the best way o' curing a man o' the mortal disease o'
leasing-making that I ken o'."
"I should think that Penpunt and Cameronian principles, would not
admit of a man taking twice payment for the same article."
"In sic a case as this, sir, it disna hinge upon principles, but a
piece o' good manners; an' I can tell you that at sic a crisis, a
Cameronian is a gay an weel-bred man. He's driven to this, that he maun
either make a breach in his friend's good name, or in his purse; an' O,
sir, whilk o' thae, think you, is the most precious? For instance, an a
Galloway drover had comed to the town o' Penpunt, an' said to a
Cameronian, (the folk's a' Cameronians there,) 'Sir, I want to buy your
cow.' 'Vera weel,' says the Cameronian, 'I just want to sell the cow,
sae gie me twanty punds Scots, an' take her w'ye.' It's a bargain. The
drover takes away the cow, an' gies the Cameronian his twanty pund
Scots. But after that, he meets him again on the white sands, amang a'
the drovers an' dealers o' the land, an' the Gallowayman, he says to
the Cameronian, afore a' thae witnesses, 'Come, Master Whiggam, I hae
never paid you for yon bit useless cow, that I bought, I'll pay her
the day, but you maun mind the luck-penny; there's muckle need
for't,—or something to that purpose. The Cameronian then turns out to
be a civil man, an' canna bide to make the man baith a feele an' liar
at the same time, afore a' his associates; an' therefore he pits his
principles aff at the side, to be a kind o' sleepin partner, as it war,
an' brings up his good breeding to stand at the counter: he pockets the
money, gies the Galloway drover time o' day, an' comes his way. An'
wha's to blame? Man mind yoursel is the first commandment. A
Cameronian's principles never came atween him an' his purse, nor sanna
in the present case; for as I canna bide to make you out a leear, I'll
thank you for my wages."
"Well, you shall have them, Samuel, if you declare to me that I
hired you myself in this same person, and bargained with you with this
same tongue, and voice, with which I speak to you just now."
"That I do declare, unless ye hae twa persons o' the same
appearance, and twa tongues to the same voice. But, od saif us, sir, do
you ken what the auld wives o' the clachan say about you?"
"How should I, when no one repeats it to me?"
"Oo, I trow it's a' stuff;—folk shouldna heed what's said by auld
crazy kimmers. But there are some o' them weel kend for witches too;
an' they say,—lord have a care o' us!—they say the deil's often
seen gaun sidie for sidie w'ye, whiles in ae shape, an' whiles in
another. An' they say that he whiles takes your ain shape, or else
enters into you, and then you turn a deil yoursel."
"I was so astounded at this terrible idea that had gone abroad,
regarding my fellowship with the prince of darkness, that I could make
no answer to the fellow's information, but sat like one in a stupor;
and if it had not been for my well-founded faith, and conviction that I
was a chosen and elected one before the world was made, I should at
that moment have given into the popular belief, and fallen into the sin
of despondency; but I was preserved from such a fatal error by an
inward and unseen supporter. Still the insinuation was so like what I
felt myself, that I was greatly awed and confounded.
The poor fellow observed this, and tried to do away the impression
by some farther sage remarks of his own.
"Hout, dear sir, it is balderdash, there's nae doubt o't. It is the
crownhead o' absurdity to tak in the havers o' auld wives for gospel. I
told them that my master was a peeous man, an' a sensible man; an' for
praying, that he could ding auld Macmillan himsel. 'Sae could the
deil,' they said, 'when he liket, either at preaching or praying, if
these war to answer his ain ends.' 'Na, na,' says I, 'but he's a strick
believer in a' the truths o' Christianity, my master.' They said, sae
was Satan, for that he was the firmest believer in a' the truths of
Christianity that was out o' heaven; an' that, sin' the Revolution that
the gospel had turned sae rife, he had been often driven to the shift
o' preaching it himsel, for the purpose o' getting some wrang tenets
introduced into it, and thereby turning it into blasphemy and ridicule."
I confess, to my shame, that I was so overcome by this jumble of
nonsense, that a chillness came over me, and in spite of all my efforts
to shake off the impression it had made, I fell into a faint. Samuel
soon brought me to myself, and after a deep draught of wine and water,
I was greatly revived, and felt my spirit rise above the sphere of
vulgar conceptions, and the restrained views of unregenerate men. The
shrewd but loquacious fellow, perceiving this, tried to make some
amends for the pain he had occasioned to me, by the following story,
which I noted down, and which was brought on by a conversation to the
"Now, Penpunt, you may tell me all that passed between you and the
wives of the clachan. I am better of that stomach qualm, with which I
am sometimes seized, and shall be much amused by hearing the sentiments
of noted witches regarding myself and my connections."
"Weel, you see, sir, I says to them, 'It will be lang afore the deil
intermeddle wi' as serious a professor, and as fervent a prayer as my
master, for gin he gets the upper hand o' sickan men, wha's to be
safe?' An', what think ye they said, sir? There was ane Lucky Shaw set
up her lang lantern chafts, an' answered me, an' a' the rest shanned
and noddit in assent an' approbation: 'Ye silly, sauchless, Cameronian
cuif!' quo she, 'is that a' that ye ken about the wiles and doings o'
the prince o' the air, that rules an' works in the bairns of
disobedience? Gin ever he observes a proud professor, wha has mae than
ordinary pretensions to a divine calling, and that reards and prays
till the very howlets learn his preambles, that's the man Auld Simmie
fixes on to mak a dishclout o'. He canna get rest in hell, if he sees a
man, or a set of men o' this stamp, an' when he sets fairly to wark, it
is seldom that he disna bring them round till his ain measures by hook
or by crook. Then, O it is a grand prize for him, an' a proud deil he
is, when he gangs hame to his ain ha', wi' a batch o' the souls o' sic
strenuous professors on his back. Ay, I trow, auld Ingleby, the
Liverpool packman, never came up Glasco street wi' prouder pomp, when
he had ten horse-laids afore him o' Flanders lace, an' Hollin lawn, an'
silks an' satins frae the eastern Indians, than Satan wad strodge into
hell with a pack-laid o' the souls o' proud professors on his braid
shoulders. Ha, ha, ha! I think I see how the auld thief wad be gaun
through his gizened dominions, crying his wares, in derision, 'Wha will
buy a fresh, cauler divine, a bouzy bishop, a fasting zealot, or a
piping priest? For a' their prayers an' their praises, their aumuses,
an' their penances, their whinings, their howlings, their rantings, an'
their ravings, here they come at last! Behold the end! Here go the rare
and precious wares! A fat professor for a bodle, an' a lean ane for
half a merk!' I declare, I trembled at the auld hag's ravings, but the
lave o' the kimmers applauded the sayings as sacred truths. An' then
Lucky went on: 'There are many wolves in sheep's claithing, among us,
my man; mony deils aneath the masks o' zealous professors, roaming
about in kirks and meeting-houses o' the land. It was but the year
afore the last, that the people o' the town o' Auchtermuchty grew so
rigidly righteous, that the meanest hind among them became a shining
light in ither towns an' parishes. There was nought to be heard,
neither night nor day, but preaching, praying, argumentation, an'
catechising in a' the famous town o' Auchtermuchty. The young men wooed
their sweethearts out o' the Song o' Solomon, an' the girls returned
answers in strings o' verses out o' the Psalms. At the lint-swinglings,
they said questions round; and read chapters, and sang hymns at
bridals; auld and young prayed in their dreams, an' prophesied in their
sleep, till the deils in the farrest nooks o' hell were alarmed, and
moved to commotion. Gin it hadna been an auld carl, Robin Ruthven,
Auchtermuchty wad at that time hae been ruined and lost for ever. But
Robin was a cunning man, an' had rather mae wits than his ain, for he
had been in the hands o' the fairies when he was young, an' a' kinds o'
spirits were visible to his een, an' their language as familiar to him
as his ain mother tongue. Robin was sitting on the side o' the West
Lowmond, ae still gloomy night in September, when he saw a bridal o'
corbie craws coming east the lift, just on the edge o' the gloaming.
The moment that Robin saw them, he kenned, by their movements, that
they were craws o' some ither warld than this; so he signed himself,
and crap into the middle o' his bourock. The corbie craws came a' an'
sat down round about him, an' they poukit their black sooty wings, an'
spread them out to the breeze to cool; and Robin heard ae corbie
speaking, an' another answering him; and the tane said to the tither:
'Where will the ravens find a prey the night?'—'On the lean crazy
souls o' Auchtermuchty,' quo the tither.—'I fear they will be o'er
weel wrappit up in the warm flannens o' faith, an' clouted wi' the
dirty duds o' repentance, for us to mak a meal o',' quo the
first.—'Whaten vile sounds are these that I hear coming bumming up
the hill?' 'O these are the hymns and praises o' the auld wives and
creeshy louns o' Auchtermuchty, wha are gaun crooning their way to
heaven; an' gin it warna for the shame o' being beat, we might let our
great enemy tak them. For sic a prize as he will hae! Heaven, forsooth!
What shall we think o' heaven, if it is to be filled wi' vermin like
thae, amang whom there is mair poverty and pollution, than I can name.'
'No matter for that,' said the first, 'we cannot have our power set at
defiance; though we should put them in the thief's hole, we must catch
them, and catch them with their own bait too. Come all to church
to-morrow, and I'll let you hear how I'll gull the saints of
Auchtermuchty. In the mean time, there is a feast on the Sidlaw hills
tonight, below the hill of Macbeth,—Mount, Diabolus, and fly.' Then,
with loud croaking and crowing, the bridal of corbies again scaled the
dusky air, and left Robin Ruthven in the middle of his cairn.
"The next day the congregation met in the kirk of Auchtermuchty, but
the minister made not his appearance. The elders ran out and in, making
inquiries; but they could learn nothing, save that the minister was
missing. They ordered the clerk to sing a part of the 119th Psalm,
until they saw if the minister would cast up. The clerk did as he was
ordered, and by the time he reached the 77th verse, a strange divine
entered the church, by the western door, and advanced solemnly up to
the pulpit. The eyes of all the congregation were riveted on the
sublime stranger, who was clothed in a robe of black sackcloth, that
flowed all around him, and trailed far behind, and they weened him an
angel, come to exhort them, in disguise. He read out his text from the
Prophecies of Ezekiel, which consisted of these singular words: 'I will
overturn, overturn, overturn it; and it shall be no more, until he
come, whose right it is, and I will give it him.'
"'From these words he preached such a sermon as never was heard by
human ears, at least never by ears of Auchtermuchty. It was a true,
sterling, gospel sermon—it was striking, sublime, and awful in the
extreme. He finally made out the IT, mentioned in the text, to mean,
properly and positively, the notable town of Auchtermuchty. He proved
all the people in it, to their perfect satisfaction, to be in the gall
of bitterness and bond of iniquity, and he assured them, that God would
overturn them, their principles, and professions; and that they should
be no more, until the devil, the town's greatest enemy, came, and then
it should be given unto him for a prey, for it was his right, and to
him it belonged, if there was not forthwith a radical change made in
all their opinions and modes of worship.
"'The inhabitants of Auchtermuchty were electrified—they were
charmed; they were actually raving mad about the grand and sublime
truths delivered to them, by this eloquent and impressive preacher of
Christianity. 'He is a prophet of the Lord,' said one, 'sent to warn
us, as Jonah was sent to the Ninevites.' 'O, he is an angel sent from
heaven, to instruct this great city,' said another, 'for no man ever
uttered truths so sublime before.' The good people of Auchtermuchty
were in perfect raptures with the preacher, who had thus sent them to
hell by the slump, tag, rag, and bobtail! Nothing in the world delights
a truly religious people so much, as consigning them to eternal
damnation. They wondered after the preacher—they crowded together,
and spoke of his sermon with admiration, and still as they conversed,
the wonder and the admiration increased; so that honest Robin Ruthven's
words would not be listened to. It was in vain that he told them he
heard a raven speaking, and another raven answering him: the people
laughed him to scorn, and kicked him out of their assemblies, as a one
who spoke evil of dignities; and they called him a warlock, an' a daft
body, to think to mak language out o' the crouping o' craws.
"The sublime preacher could not be heard of, although all the
country was sought for him, even to the minutest corner of St. Johnston
and Dundee; but as he had announced another sermon on the same text, on
a certain day, all the inhabitants of that populous country, far and
near, flocked to Auchtermuchty. Cupar, Newburgh, and Strathmiglo,
turned out men, women, and children. Perth and Dundee gave their
thousands; and from the East Nook of Fife to the foot of the Grampian
hills, there was nothing but running and riding that morning to
Auchtermuchty. The kirk would not hold the thousandth part of them. A
splendid tent was erected on the brae north of the town, and round that
the countless congregation assembled. When they were all waiting
anxiously for the great preacher, behold, Robin Ruthven set up his head
in the tent, and warned his countrymen to beware of the doctrines they
were about to hear, for he could prove, to their satisfaction, that
they were all false, and tended to their destruction!
"The whole multitude raised a cry of indignation against Robin, and
dragged him from the tent, the elders rebuking him, and the multitude
threatening to resort to stronger measures; and though he told them a
plain and unsophisticated tale of the black corbies, he was only
derided. The great preacher appeared once more, and went through his
two discourses with increased energy and approbation. All who heard him
were amazed, and many of them went into fits, writhing and foaming in a
state of the most horrid agitation. Robin Ruthven sat on the outskirts
of the great assembly, listening with the rest, and perceived what
they, in the height of their enthusiasm, perceived not,—the ruinous
tendency of the tenets so sublimely inculcated. Robin kenned the voice
of his friend the corby-craw again, and was sure he could not be wrang:
sae when public worship was finished, a' the elders an' a' the gentry
flocked about the great preacher, as he stood on the green brae in the
sight of the hale congregation, an' a' war alike anxious to pay him
some mark o' respect. Robin Ruthven came in amang the thrang, to try to
effect what he had promised; and, with the greatest readiness and
simplicity, just took haud o' the side an' wide gown, an' in sight of
a' present, held it aside as high as the preacher's knee, and behold,
there was a pair o' cloven feet! The auld thief was fairly catched in
the very height o' his proud conquest, an' put down by an auld carl. He
could feign nae mair, but gnashing on Robin wi' his teeth, he dartit
into the air like a fiery dragon, an' keust a reid rainbow our the taps
o' the Lowmonds.
"'a' the auld wives an' weavers o' Auchtermuchty fell down flat wi'
affright, an' betook them to their prayers aince again, for they saw
the dreadfu' danger they had escapit, an' frae that day to this it is a
hard matter to gar an Auchtermuchty man listen to a sermon at a', an' a
harder ane still to gar him applaud ane, for he thinks aye that he sees
the cloven foot peeping out frae aneath ilka sentence.
"'Now, this is a true story, my man,' quo the auld wife; 'an'
whenever you are doubtfu' of a man, take auld Robin Ruthven's plan, an'
look for the cloven foot, for it's a thing that winna weel hide; an' it
appears whiles where ane wadna think o't. It will keek out frae aneath
the parson's gown, the lawyer's wig, and the Cameronian's blue bannet;
but still there is a gouden rule whereby to detect it, an' that never,
never fails.'—The auld witch didna gie me the rule, an' though I hae
heard tell o't often an' often, shame fa' me an I ken what it is! But
ye will ken it well, an' it wad be nae the waur of a trial on some o'
your friends, maybe; for they say there's a certain gentleman seen
walking wi' you whiles, that, wherever he sets his foot, the grass
withers as gin it war scoudered wi' a het ern. His presence be about
us! What's the matter wi' you, master? Are ye gaun to take the calm o'
the stamock again?"
The truth is, that the clown's absurd story, with the still more
ridiculous application, made me sick at heart a second time. It was not
because I thought my illustrious friend was the devil, or that I took a
fool's idle tale as a counterbalance to divine revelation, that had
assured me of my justification in the sight of God before the existence
of time. But, in short, it gave me a view of my own state, at which I
shuddered, as indeed I now always did, when the image of my devoted
friend and ruler presented itself to my mind. I often communed with my
heart on this, and wondered how a connection, that had the well-being
of mankind solely in view, could be productive of fruits so bitter. I
then went to try my works by the Saviour's gol- den rule, as my
servant had put it into my head to do; and, behold, not one of them
would stand the test. I had shed blood on a ground on which I could not
admit that any man had a right to shed mine; and I began to doubt the
motives of my adviser once more, not that they were intentionally bad,
but that his was some great mind led astray by enthusiasm, or some
He seemed to comprehend every one of these motions of my heart, for
his manner towards me altered every day. It first became any thing but
agreeable, then supercilious, and finally, intolerable; so that I
resolved to shake him off, cost what it would, even though I should be
reduced to beg my bread in a foreign land. To do it at home was
impossible, as he held my life in his hands, to sell it whenever he had
a mind; and besides, his ascendancy over me was as complete as that of
a huntsman over his dogs. I was even so weak, as, the next time I met
with him, to look stedfastly at his foot, to see if it was not cloven
into two hoofs. It was the foot of a gentleman, in every respect, so
far as appearances went, but the form of his counsels was somewhat
equivocal, and if not double, they were amazingly crooked.
But, if I had taken my measures to abscond and fly from my native
place, in order to free myself of this tormenting, intolerant, and
bloody reformer, he had likewise taken his to expel me, or throw me
into the hands of justice. It seems, that about this time, I was
haunted by some spies connected with my late father and brother, of
whom the mistress of the former was one. My brother's death had been
witnessed by two individuals; indeed, I always had an impression that
it was witnessed by more than one, having some faint recollection of
hearing voices and challenges close beside me; and this woman had
searched about until she found these people; but, as I shrewdly
suspected, not without the assistance of the only person in my secret,
—my own warm and devoted friend. I say this, because I found that he
had them concealed in the neighbourhood, and then took me again and
again where I was fully exposed to their view, without being aware. One
time in particular, on pretence of gratifying my revenge on that base
woman, he knew so well where she lay concealed, that he led me to her,
and left me to the mercy of two viragos, who had very nigh taken my
life. My time of residence at Dalcastle was wearing to a crisis. I
could no longer live with my tyrant, who haunted me like my shadow;
and besides, it seems there were proofs of murder leading against me
from all quarters. Of part of these I deemed myself quite free, but the
world deemed otherwise; and how the matter would have gone, God only
knows, for, the case never having undergone a judicial trial, I do not.
It perhaps, however, behoves me here to relate all that I know of it,
and it is simply this:
On the first of June 1712, (well may I remember the day,) I was
sitting locked in my secret chamber, in a state of the utmost
despondency, revolving in my mind what I ought to do to be free of my
persecutors, and wishing myself a worm, or a moth, that I might be
crushed and at rest, when behold Samuel entered, with eyes like to
start out of his head, exclaiming, "For God's sake, master, fly and
hide yourself, for your mother's found, an' as sure as you're a living
soul, the blame is gaun to fa' on you!"
"My mother found!" said I. "And, pray, where has she been all this
while?" In the mean time, I was terribly discomposed at the thoughts of
"Been, sir! Been? Why, she has been where ye pat her, it
seems,—lying buried in the sands o' the linn. I can tell you, ye will
see her a fright-some figure, sic as I never wish to see again. An' the
young lady is found too, sir: an' it is said the devil—I beg pardon
sir, your friend, I mean,— it is said your friend has made the
discovery, an' the folk are away to raise officers, an' they will be
here in an hour or two at the farthest, sir; an' sae you hae not a
minute to lose, for there's proof, sir, strong proof, an' sworn proof,
that ye were last seen wi' them baith; sae, unless ye can gie a' the
better an account o' baith yoursel an' them, either hide, or flee for
your bare life."
"I will neither hide nor fly," said I; "for I am as guiltless of the
blood of these women as the child unborn."
"The country disna think sae, master; an' I can assure you, that
should evidence fail, you run a risk o' being torn limb frae limb. They
are bringing the corpse here, to gar ye touch them baith afore
witnesses, an' plenty o' witnesses there will be!"
"They shall not bring them here," cried I, shocked beyond measure at
the experiment about to be made: "Go, instantly, and debar them from
entering my gate with their bloated and mangled carcases."
"The body of your own mother, sir!" said the fellow emphatically. I
was in terrible agitation; and, being driven to my wit's end, I got up
and strode furiously round an' round the room. Samuel wist not what to
do, but I saw by his staring he deemed me doubly guilty. A tap came to
the chamber door: we both started like guilty creatures; and as for
Samuel, his hairs stood all on end with alarm, so that when I motioned
to him, he could scarcely advance to open the door. He did so at
length, and who should enter but my illustrious friend, manifestly in
the utmost state of alarm. The moment that Samuel admitted him, the
former made his escape by the prince's side as he entered, seemingly in
a state of distraction. I was little better, when I saw this dreaded
personage enter my chamber, which he had never before attempted; and
being unable to ask his errand, I suppose I stood and gazed on him like
"I come with sad and tormenting tidings to you, my beloved and
ungrateful friend," said he; "but having only a minute left to save
your life, I have come to attempt it. There is a mob coming towards you
with two dead bodies, which will place you in circumstances
disagreeable enough: but that is not the worst, for of that you may be
able to clear yourself. At this moment there is a party of officers,
with a Justiciary warrant from Edinburgh, surrounding the house, and
about to begin the search of it, for you. If you fall into their hands,
you are inevitably lost; for I have been making earnest inquiries, and
find that every thing is in train for your ruin."
"Ay, and who has been the cause of all this?" said I, with great
bitterness. But he stopped me short, adding, "There is no time for such
reflections at present: I gave you my word of honour that your life
should be safe from the hand of man. So it shall, if the power remain
with me to save it. I am come to redeem my pledge, and to save your
life by the sacrifice of my own. Here,—Not one word of expostulation,
change habits with me, and you may then pass by the officers, and
guards, and even through the approaching mob, with the most perfect
temerity. There is a virtue in this garb, and instead of offering to
detain you, they shall pay you obeisance. Make haste, and leave this
place for the present, flying where you best may, and if I escape from
these dangers that surround me, I will endeavour to find you out, and
bring you what intelligence I am able.
I put on his green frock coat, buff belt, and a sort of a turban
that he always wore on his head, somewhat resembling a bishop's mitre:
he drew his hand thrice across my face, and I withdrew as he continued
to urge me. My hall door and postern gate were both strongly guarded,
and there were sundry armed people within, searching the closets; but
all of them made way for me, and lifted their caps as I passed by them.
Only one superior officer accosted me, asking if I had seen the
culprit? I knew not what answer to make, but chanced to say, with great
truth and propriety, "He is safe enough." The man beckoned with a
smile, as much as to say, "Thank you, sir, that is quite sufficient;"
and I walked deliberately away.
I had not well left the gate, till, hearing a great noise coming
from the deep glen toward the east, I turned that way, deeming myself
quite secure in this my new disguise, to see what it was, and if
matters were as had been described to me. There I met a great mob,
sure enough, coming with two dead bodies stretched on boards, and
decently covered with white sheets. I would fain have examined their
appearance, had I not perceived the apparent fury in the looks of the
men, and judged from that how much more safe it was for me not to
intermeddle in the affray. I cannot tell how it was, but I felt a
strange and unwonted delight in viewing this scene, and a certain pride
of heart in being supposed the perpetrator of the unnatural crimes laid
to my charge. This was a feeling quite new to me; and if there were
virtues in the robes of the illustrious foreigner, who had without all
dispute preserved my life at this time; I say, if there was any
inherent virtue in these robes of his, as he had suggested, this was
one of their effects, that they turned my heart towards that which was
evil, horrible, and disgustful.
I mixed with the mob to hear what they were saying. Every tongue was
engaged in loading me with the most opprobrious epithets! One called me
a monster of nature; another an incarnate devil; and another a
creature made to be cursed in time and eternity. I retired from them,
and winded my way southward, comforting myself with the assurance,
that so mankind had used and persecuted the greatest fathers and
apostles of the Christian church, and that their vile opprobrium could
not alter the counsels of heaven concerning me.
On going over that rising ground called Dorington Moor, I could not
help turning round and taking a look of Dalcastle. I had little doubt
that it would be my last look, and nearly as little ambition that it
should not. I thought how high my hopes of happiness and advancement
had been on entering that mansion, and taking possession of its rich
and extensive domains, and how miserably I had been disappointed. On
the contrary, I had experienced nothing but chagrin, disgust, and
terror; and I now consoled myself with the hope that I should
henceforth shake myself free of the chains of my great tormentor, and
for that privilege was I willing to encounter any earthly distress. I
could not help perceiving, that I was now on a path which was likely to
lead me into a species of distress hitherto unknown, and hardly dreamed
of by me, and that was total destitution. For all the riches I had been
possessed of a few hours previous to this, I found that here I was
turned out of my lordly possessions without a single merk, or the power
of lifting and commanding the smallest sum, without being thereby
discovered and seized. Had it been possible for me to have escaped in
my own clothes, I had a considerable sum secreted in these, but, by the
sudden change, I was left without a coin for present necessity. But I
had hope in heaven, knowing that the just man would not be left
destitute; and that though many troubles surrounded him, he would at
last be set free from them all. I was possessed of strong and brilliant
parts, and a liberal education; and though I had somehow unaccountably
suffered my theological qualifications to fall into desuetude, since my
acquaintance with the ablest and most rigid of all theologians, I had
nevertheless hopes that, by preaching up redemption by grace,
pre-ordination, and eternal purpose, I should yet be enabled to benefit
mankind in some country, and rise to high distinction.
These were some of the thoughts by which I consoled myself as I
posted on my way southward, avoiding the towns and villages, and
falling into the cross ways that led from each of the great roads
passing east and west, to another. I lodged the first night in the
house of a country weaver, into which I stepped at a late hour, quite
overcome with hunger and fatigue, having travelled not less than
thirty miles from my late home. The man received me ungraciously,
telling me of a gentleman's house at no great distance, and of an inn a
little farther away; but I said I delighted more in the society of a
man like him, than that of any gentleman of the land, for my concerns
were with the poor of this world, it being easier for a camel to go
through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the
kingdom of heaven. The weaver's wife, who sat with a child on her knee,
and had not hitherto opened her mouth, hearing me speak in that serious
and religious style, stirred up the fire, with her one hand; then
drawing a chair near it, she said, "Come awa, honest lad, in by here;
sin' it be sae that you belang to Him wha gies us a' that we hae, it is
but right that you should share a part. You are a stranger, it is true,
but them that winna entertain a stranger will never entertain an angel
I never was apt to be taken with the simplicity of nature; in
general I despised it; but, owing to my circumstances at the time, I
was deeply affected by the manner of this poor woman's welcome. The
weaver continued in a churlish mood throughout the evening, apparently
dissatisfied with what his wife had done in entertaining me, and spoke
to her in a manner so crusty that I thought proper to rebuke him, for
the woman was comely in her person, and virtuous in her conversation;
but the weaver her husband was large of make, ill-favoured, and
pestilent; therefore did I take him severely to task for the tenor of
his conduct; but the man was froward, and answered me rudely, with
sneering and derision, and, in the height of his caprice, he said to
his wife, "Whan focks are sae keen of a chance o' entertaining angels,
gudewife, it wad maybe be worth their while to tak tent what kind o'
angels they are. It wadna wonder me vera muckle an ye had entertained
your friend the deil the night, for aw thought aw fand a saur o' reek
an' brimstane about him. He's nane o' the best o' angles, an' focks
winna hae muckle credit by entertaining him."
Certainly, in the assured state I was in, I had as little reason to
be alarmed at mention being made of the devil as any person on earth:
of late, however, I felt that the reverse was the case, and that any
allusion to my great enemy, moved me exceedingly. The weaver's speech
had such an effect on me, that both he and his wife were alarmed at my
looks. The latter thought I was angry, and chided her husband gently
for his rudeness; but the weaver himself rather seemed to be confirmed
in his opinion that I was the devil, for he looked round like a
startled roe-buck, and immediately betook him to the family Bible.
I know not whether it was on purpose to prove my identity or not,
but I think he was going to desire me either to read a certain portion
of Scripture that he had sought out, or to make family worship, had not
the conversation at that instant taken another turn; for the weaver,
not knowing how to address me, abruptly asked my name, as he was about
to put the Bible into my hands. Never having considered myself in the
light of a malefactor, but rather as a champion in the cause of truth,
and finding myself perfectly safe under my disguise, I had never once
thought of the utility of changing my name, and when the man asked me,
I hesitated; but being compelled to say something, I said my name was
Cowan. The man stared at me, and then at his wife, with a look that
spoke a knowledge of something alarming or mysterious.
"Ha! Cowan?" said he. "That's most extrordinar! Not Colwan, I hope?"
"No: Cowan is my sirname," said I. "But why not Colwan, there being
so little difference in the sound?"
"I was feared ye might be that waratch that the deil has taen the
possession o', an' eggit him on to kill baith his father an' his
mother, his only brother, an' his sweetheart," said he; "an' to say the
truth, I'm no that sure about you yet, for I see you're gaun wi' arms
"Not I, honest man," said I; "I carry no arms; a man conscious of
his innocence and uprightness of heart, needs not to carry arms in his
"Ay, ay, maister," said he; "an' pray what div ye ca' this bit
windlestrae that's appearing here?" With that he pointed to something
on the inside of the breast of my frock-coat. I looked at it, and there
certainly was the gilded haft of a poniard, the same weapon I had seen
and handled before, and which I knew my illustrious companion always
carried about with him; but till that moment I knew not that I was in
possession of it. I drew it out: a more dangerous or insidious looking
weapon could not be conceived. The weaver and his wife were both
frightened, the latter in particular; and she being my friend, and I
dependant on their hospitality, for that night, I said, "I declare I
knew not that I carried this small rapier, which has been in my coat by
chance, and not by any design of mine. But lest you should think that I
meditate any mischief to any under this roof, I give it into your
hands, requesting of you to lock it by till to-morrow, or when I shall
next want it."
The woman seemed rather glad to get hold of it; and, taking it from
me, she went into a kind of pantry out of my sight, and locked the
weapon up; and then the discourse went on.
"There cannot be such a thing in reality," said I, "as the story you
were mentioning just now, of a man whose name resembles mine."
"It's likely that you ken a wee better about the story than I do,
maister," said he, "suppose you do leave the L out of your name. An'
yet I think sic a waratch, an' a murderer, wad hae taen a name wi' some
gritter difference in the sound. But the story is just that true, that
there were twa o' the Queen's officers here nae mair than an hour ago,
in pursuit o' the vagabond, for they gat some intelligence that he had
fled this gate; yet they said he had been last seen wi' black claes on,
an' they supposed he was clad in black. His ain servant is wi' them,
for the purpose o' kennin the scoundrel, an' they're galloping through
the country like madmen. I hope in God they'll get him, an' rack his
neck for him!"
I could not say Amen to the weaver's prayer, and therefore tried to
compose myself as well as I could, and made some religious comment on
the causes of the nation's depravity. But suspecting that my potent
friend had betrayed my flight and disguise, to save his life, I was
very uneasy, and gave myself up for lost. I said prayers in the family,
with the tenor of which the wife was delighted, but the weaver still
dissatisfied; and, after a supper of the most homely fare, he tried to
start an argument with me, proving, that every thing for which I had
interceded in my prayer, was irrelevant to man's present state. But I,
being weary and distressed in mind, shunned the contest, and requested
a couch whereon to repose.
I was conducted into the other end of the house, among looms,
treadles, pirns, and confusion without end; and there, in a sort of
box, was I shut up for my night's repose, for the weaver, as he left
me, cautiously turned the key of my apartment, and left me to shift for
myself among the looms, determined that I should escape from the house
with nothing. After he and his wife and children were crowded into
their den, I heard the two mates contending furiously about me in
suppressed voices, the one maintaining the probability that I was the
murderer, and the other proving the impossibility of it. The husband,
however, said as much as let me understand, that he had locked me up on
purpose to bring the military, or officers of justice, to seize me. I
was in the utmost perplexity, yet, for all that, and the imminent
danger I was in, I fell asleep, and a more troubled and tormenting
sleep never enchained a mortal frame. I had such dreams that they will
not bear repetition, and early in the morning I awaked, feverish, and
parched with thirst.
I went to call mine host, that he might let me out to the open air,
but before doing so, I thought it necessary to put on some clothes. In
attempting to do this, a circumstance arrested my attention, (for which
I could in nowise account, which to this day I cannot unriddle, nor
shall I ever be able to comprehend it while I live,) the frock and
turban, which had furnished my disguise on the preceding day, were both
removed, and my own black coat and cocked hat laid down in their place.
At first I thought I was in a dream, and felt the weaver's beam, web,
and treadle-strings with my hands, to convince myself that I was awake.
I was certainly awake; and there was the door locked firm and fast as
it was the evening before. I carried my own black coat to the small
window, and examined it. It was my own in verity; and the sums of
money, that I had concealed in case of any emergency, remained
untouched. I trembled with astonishment; and on my return from the
small window, went doiting in amongst the weaver's looms, till I
entangled myself, and could not get out again without working great
deray amongst the coarse linen threads that stood in warp from one end
of the apartment unto the other. I had no knife whereby to cut the
cords of this wicked man, and therefore was obliged to call out lustily
for assistance. The weaver came half naked, unlocked the door, and,
setting in his head and long neck, accosted me thus:
"What now, Mr. Satan? What for are ye roaring that gate? Are you
fawn inna little hell, instead o' the big muckil ane? Deil be in your
reistit trams! What for have ye abscondit yoursel into ma leddy's wab
"Friend, I beg your pardon," said I; "I wanted to be at the light,
and have somehow unfortunately involved myself in the intricacies of
your web, from which I cannot get clear without doing you a great
injury. Pray do, lend your experienced hand to extricate me."
"May aw the pearls o' damnation light on your silly snout, an I
dinna estricat ye weel enough! Ye ditit, donnart, deil's burd that ye
be! what made ye gang howkin in there to be a poor man's ruin? Come
out, ye vile rag-of-a-muffin, or I gar ye come out wi' mair shame and
disgrace, an' fewer haill banes in your body."
My feet had slipped down through the double warpings of a web, and
not being able to reach the ground with them, (there being a small pit
below,) I rode upon a number of yielding threads, and there being
nothing else that I could reach, to extricate myself was impossible. I
was utterly powerless; and besides, the yarn and cords hurt me very
much. For all that, the destructive weaver seized a loomspoke, and
began a-beating me most unmercifully, while, entangled as I was, I
could do nothing but shout aloud for mercy, or assistance, whichever
chanced to be within hearing. The latter, at length, made its
appearance, in the form of the weaver's wife, in the same state of
dishabille with himself, who instantly interfered, and that most
strenuously, on my behalf. Before her arrival, however, I had made a
desperate effort to throw myself out of the entanglement I was in; for
the weaver continued repeating his blows and cursing me so, that I
determined to get out of his meshes at any risk. This effect made my
case worse; for my feet being wrapt among the nether threads, as I
threw myself from my saddle on the upper ones, my feet brought the
others up through these, and I hung with my head down, and my feet as
firm as they had been in a vice. The predicament of the web being
thereby increased, the weaver's wrath was doubled in proportion, and he
laid on without mercy.
At this critical juncture the wife arrived, and without hesitation
rushed before her offended lord, withholding his hand from injuring me
farther, although then it was uplifted along with the loomspoke in
overbearing ire. "Dear Johnny! I think ye be gaen dementit this
morning. Be quiet, my dear, an' dinna begin a Boddel Brigg business in
your ain house. What for ir ye persecutin' a servant o' the Lord's that
gate, an' pitting the life out o' him wi' his head down an' his heels
"Had ye said a servant o' the deil's, Nans, ye wad hae been nearer
the nail, for gin he binna the auld ane himsel, he's gayan sib till
him. There, didna I lock him in on purpose to bring the military on
him; an' in place o' that, hasna he keepit me in a sleep a' this while
as deep as death? An' here do I find him abscondit like a speeder i'
the mids o' my leddy's wab, an' me dreamin' a' the night that I had the
deil i' my house, an' that he was clapper-clawin me ayont the loom.
Have at you, ye brun-stane thief!" and, in spite of the good woman's
struggles, he lent me another severe blow.
"Now, Johnny Dods, my man! O Johnny Dods, think if that be like a
Christian, and ane o' the heroes o' Boddel Brigg, to entertain a
stranger, an' then bind him in a web wi' his head down, an' mell him to
death! O Johnny Dods, think what you are about! Slack a pin, an' let
the good honest religious lad out."
The weaver was rather overcome, but still stood to his point that I
was the deil, though in better temper; and as he slackened the web to
release me, he remarked, half laughing, "Wha wad hae thought that John
Dods should hae escapit a' the snares an' dangers that circumfauldit
him, an' at last should hae weaved a net to catch the deil."
The wife released me soon, and carefully whispered me, at the same
time, that it would be as well for me to dress and be going. I was not
long in obeying, and dressed myself in my black clothes, hardly knowing
what I did, what to think, or whither to betake myself. I was sore hurt
by the blows of the desperate ruffian; and, what was worse, my ankle
was so much strained, that I could hardly set my foot to the ground. I
was obliged to apply to the weaver once more, to see if I could learn
any thing about my clothes, or how the change was effected. "Sir," said
I, "how comes it that you have robbed me of my clothes, and put these
down in their place over night?"
"Ha! thae claes? Me pit down thae claes!" said he, gaping with
astonishment, and touching the clothes with the point of his
fore-finger; "I never saw them afore, as I have death to meet wi': So
help me God!"
He strode into the work-house where I slept, to satisfy himself that
my clothes were not there, and returned perfectly aghast with
consternation. "The doors were baith fast lockit," said he. "I could
hae defied a rat either to hae gotten out or in. My dream has been
true! My dream has been true! The Lord judge between thee and me; but,
in his name, I charge you to depart out o' this house; an', gin it be
your will, dinna tak the braidside o't w'ye, but gang quietly out at
the door wi' your face foremost. Wife, let nought o' this enchanter's
remain i' the house, to be a curse, an' a snare to us; gang an' bring
him his gildit weapon, an' may the Lord protect a' his ain against its
hellish an' deadly point!"
The wife went to seek my poniard, trembling so excessively that she
could hardly walk, and shortly after, we heard a feeble scream from the
pantry. The weapon had disappeared with the clothes, though under
double lock and key; and the terror of the good people having now
reached a disgusting extremity, I thought proper to make a sudden
retreat, followed by the weaver's anathemas.
My state both of body and mind was now truly deplorable. I was
hungry, wounded, and lame; an outcast and a vagabond in society; my
life sought after with avidity, and all for doing that to which I was
predestined by him who fore-ordains whatever comes to pass. I knew not
whither to betake me. I had purposed going into England, and there
making some use of the classical education I had received, but my
lameness rendered this impracticable for the present. I was therefore
obliged to turn my face towards Edinburgh, where I was little
known—where concealment was more practicable than by skulking in the
country, and where I might turn my mind to something that was great and
good. I had a little money, both Scots and English, now in my
possession, but not one friend in the whole world on whom I could rely.
One devoted friend, it is true, I had, but he was become my greatest
terror. To escape from him, I now felt that I would willingly travel to
the farthest corners of the world, and be subjected to every
deprivation; but after the certainty of what had taken place last
night, after I had travelled thirty miles by secret and bye-ways, I saw
not how escape from him was possible.
Miserable, forlorn, and dreading every person that I saw, either
behind or before me, I hasted on towards Edinburgh, taking all the bye
and unfrequented paths; and the third night after I left the weaver's
house, I reached the West Port, without meeting with any thing
remarkable. Being exceedingly fatigued and lame, I took lodgings in the
first house I entered, and for these I was to pay two groats a-week,
and to board and sleep with a young man who wanted a companion to make
his rent easier. I liked this; having found from experience, that the
great personage who had attached himself to me, and was now become my
greatest terror among many surrounding evils, generally haunted me when
I was alone, keeping aloof from all other society.
My fellow lodger came home in the evening, and was glad at my
coming. His name was Linton, and I changed mine to Elliot. He was a
flippant unstable being, one to whom nothing appeared a difficulty, in
his own estimation, but who could effect very little, after all. He was
what is called by some a compositor, in the Queen's printing house,
then conducted by a Mr. James Watson. In the course of our conversation
that night, I told him that I was a first-rate classical scholar, and
would gladly turn my attention to some business wherein my education
might avail me something; and that there was nothing would delight me
so much as an engagement in the Queen's printing office. Linton made no
difficulty in bringing about that arrangement. His answer was. "Oo, gud
sir, you are the very man we want. Gud bless your breast and your
buttons, sir! Ay, that's neither here nor there—That's all very
well—Ha-ha-ha— A byeword in the house, sir. But, as I was saying,
you are the very man we want—You will get any money you like to ask,
sir—Any money you like, sir. God bless your buttons!—That's
settled—All done—Settled, settled—I'll do it, I'll do it—No
more about it; no more about it. Settled, settled."
The next day I went with him to the office, and he presented me to
Mr. Watson as the most wonderful genius and scholar ever known. His
recommendation had little sway with Mr. Watson, who only smiled at
Linton's extravagancies, as one does at the prattle of an infant. I
sauntered about the printing office for the space of two or three
hours, during which time Watson bustled about with green spectacles on
his nose, and took no heed of me. But seeing that I still lingered, he
addressed me at length, in a civil gentlemanly way, and inquired
concerning my views. I satisfied him with all my answers, in
particular those to his questions about the Latin and Greek languages;
but when he came to ask testimonials of my character and acquirements,
and found that I could produce none, he viewed me with a jealous eye,
and said he dreaded I was some ne'er-do-weel, run from my parents or
guardians, and he did not chuse to employ any such. I said my parents
were both dead; and that being thereby deprived of the means of
following out my education, it behoved me to apply to some business in
which my education might be of some use to me. He said he would take me
into the office, and pay me according to the business I performed, and
the manner in which I deported myself; but he could take no man into
her Majesty's printing office upon a regular engagement, who could not
produce the most respectable references with regard to morals.
I could not but despise the man in my heart who laid such a stress
upon morals, leaving grace out of the question; and viewed it as a
deplorable instance of human depravity and self conceit; but for all
that, I was obliged to accept of his terms, for I had an inward thirst
and longing to distinguish myself in the great cause of religion, and
I thought if once I could print my own works, how I would astonish
mankind, and confound their self wisdom and their esteemed
morality—blow up the idea of any dependence on good works, and
morality, forsooth! And I weened that I might thus get me a name even
higher than if I had been made a general of the Czar Peter's troops
against the infidels.
I attended the office some hours every day, but got not much
encouragement, though I was eager to learn every thing, and could soon
have set types considerably well. It was here that I first conceived
the idea of writing this journal, and having it printed, and applied to
Mr. Watson to print it for me, telling him it was a religious parable
such as the Pilgrim's Progress. He advised me to print it close, and
make it a pamphlet, and then if it did not sell, it would not cost me
much; but that religious pamphlets, especially if they had a shade of
allegory in them, were the very rage of the day. I put my work to the
press, and wrote early and late; and encouraging my companion to work
at odd hours, and on Sundays, before the press-work of the second sheet
was begun, we had the work all in types, corrected, and a clean copy
thrown off for farther revisal. The first sheet was wrought off; and I
never shall forget how my heart exulted when at the printing house this
day, I saw what numbers of my works were to go abroad among mankind,
and I determined with myself that I would not put the Border name of
Elliot, which I had assumed, to the work.
Thus far have my History and Confessions been carried.
I must now furnish my Christian readers with a key to the process,
management, and winding up of the whole matter; which I propose, by the
assistance of God, to limit to a very few pages.
Chesters, July 27, 1712.—My hopes and prospects are a wreck. My
precious journal is lost! consigned to the flames! My enemy hath found
me out, and there is no hope of peace or rest for me on this side the
In the beginning of the last week, my fellow lodger came home,
running in a great panic, and told me a story of the devil having
appeared twice in the printing house, assisting the workmen at the
printing of my book, and that some of them had been frightened out of
their wits. That the story was told to Mr. Watson, who till that time
had never paid any attention to the treatise, but who, out of
curiosity, began and read a part of it, and thereupon flew into a great
rage, called my work a medley of lies and blasphemy, and ordered the
whole to be consigned to the flames, blaming his foreman, and all
connected with the press, for letting a work go so far, that was enough
to bring down the vengeance of heaven on the concern.
If ever I shed tears through perfect bitterness of spirit it was at
that time, but I hope it was more for the ignorance and folly of my
countrymen than the overthrow of my own hopes. But my attention was
suddenly aroused to other matters, by Linton mentioning that it was
said by some in the office the devil had inquired for me.
"Surely you are not such a fool," said I, "as to believe that the
devil really was in the printing office?"
"Oo, gud bless you sir! saw him myself, gave him a nod, and
good-day. Rather a gentlemanly personage—Green Circassian hunting
coat and turban —Like a foreigner—Has the power of vanishing in one
moment though—Rather a suspicious circumstance that. Otherwise, his
appearance not much against him."
If the former intelligence thrilled me with grief, this did so with
terror. I perceived who the personage was that had visited the printing
house in order to further the progress of my work; and at the approach
of every person to our lodgings, I from that instant trembled every
bone, lest it should be my elevated and dreaded friend. I could not say
I had ever received an office at his hand that was not friendly, yet
these offices had been of a strange tendency; and the horror with which
I now regarded him was unaccountable to myself. It was beyond
description, conception, or the soul of man to bear. I took my printed
sheets, the only copy of my unfinished work existing; and, on pretence
of going straight to Mr. Watson's office, decamped from my lodgings at
Portsburgh a little before the fall of evening, and took the road
As soon as I got clear of the city, I ran with a velocity I knew not
before I had been capable of. I flew out the way towards Dalkeith so
swiftly, that I often lost sight of the ground, and I said to myself,
"O that I had the wings of a dove, that I might fly to the farthest
corners of the earth, to hide me from those against whom I have no
power to stand!"
I travelled all that night and the next morning, exerting myself
beyond my power; and about noon the following day I went into a
yeoman's house, the name of which was Ellanshaws, and requested of the
people a couch of any sort to lie down on, for I was ill, and could not
proceed on my journey. They showed me to a stable-loft where there were
two beds, on one of which I laid me down; and, falling into a sound
sleep, I did not awake till the evening, that other three men came from
the fields to sleep in the same place, one of whom lay down beside me,
at which I was exceedingly glad. They fell all sound asleep, and I was
terribly alarmed at a conversation I overheard somewhere outside the
stable. I could not make out a sentence, but trembled to think I knew
one of the voices at least, and rather than not be mistaken, I would
that any man had run me through with a sword. I fell into a cold sweat,
and once thought of instantly putting hand to my own life, as my only
means of relief, (May the rash and sinful thought be in mercy
forgiven!) when I heard as it were two persons at the door, contending,
as I thought, about their right and interest in me. That the one was
forcibly preventing the admission of the other, I could hear
distinctly, and their language was mixed with something dreadful and
mysterious. In an agony of terror, I awakened my snoring companion with
great difficulty, and asked him, in a low whisper, who these were at
the door? The man lay silent, and listening, till fairly awake, and
then asked if I had heard any thing? I said I had heard strange voices
contending at the door.
"Then I can tell you, lad, it has been something neither good nor
canny," said he: "It's no for naething that our horses are snorking
For the first time, I remarked that the animals were snorting and
rearing as if they wished to break through the house. The man called to
them by their names, and ordered them to be quiet; but they raged still
the more furiously. He then roused his drowsy companions, who were
alike alarmed at the panic of the horses, all of them declaring that
they had never seen either Mause or Jolly start in their lives before.
My bed-fellow and another then ventured down the ladder, and I heard
one of them then saying, "Lord be wi' us! What can be i' the house? The
sweat's rinning off the poor beasts like water."
They agreed to sally out together, and if possible to reach the
kitchen and bring a light. I was glad at this, but not so much so when
I heard the one man saying to the other, in a whisper, "I wish that
stranger man may be canny enough."
"God kens!" said the other: "It doesnae look unco weel."
The lad in the other bed, hearing this, set up his head in manifest
affright as the other two departed for the kitchen; and, I believe, he
would have been glad to have been in their company. This lad was next
the ladder, at which I was extremely glad, for had he not been there,
the world should not have induced me to wait the return of these two
men. They were not well gone, before I heard another distinctly enter
the stable, and come towards the ladder. The lad who was sitting up in
his bed, intent on the watch, called out, "Wha's that there? Walker, is
that you? Purdie, I say, is it you?"
The darkling intruder paused for a few moments, and then came
towards the foot of the ladder. The horses broke loose, and snorting
and neighing for terror, raged through the house. In all my life I
never heard so frightful a commotion. The being that occasioned it
all, now began to mount the ladder toward our loft, on which the lad in
the bed next the ladder sprung from his couch, crying out, "the L—d
A—y preserve us! what can it be?" With that he sped across the loft,
and by my bed, praying lustily all the way; and, throwing himself from
the other end of the loft into a manger, he darted, naked as he was,
through among the furious horses, and making the door, that stood open,
in a moment he vanished and left me in the lurch. Powerless with
terror, and calling out fearfully, I tried to follow his example; but
not knowing the situation of the places with regard to one another, I
missed the manger, and fell on the pavement in one of the stalls. I was
both stunned and lamed on the knee; but terror prevailing, I got up and
tried to escape. It was out of my power; for there were divisions and
cross divisions in the house, and mad horses smashing every thing
before them, so that I knew not so much as on what side of the house
the door was. Two or three times was I knocked down by the animals, but
all the while I never stinted crying out with all my power. At length,
I was seized by the throat and hair of the head, and dragged away, I
wist not whither. My voice was now laid, and all my powers, both
mental and bodily, totally overcome; and I remember no more till I
found myself lying naked on the kitchen table of the farm house, and
something like a horse's rug thrown over me. The only hint that I got
from the people of the house on coming to myself was, that my absence
would be good company; and that they had got me in a woful state, one
which they did not chuse to describe, or hear described.
As soon as day-light appeared, I was packed about my business, with
the hisses and execrations of the yeoman's family, who viewed me as a
being to be shunned, ascribing to me the visitations of that unholy
night. Again was I on my way southward, as lonely, hopeless, and
degraded a being as was to be found on life's weary round. As I limped
out the way, I wept, thinking of what I might have been, and what I
really had become: of my high and flourishing hopes, when I set out as
the avenger of God on the sinful children of men; of all that I had
dared for the exaltation and progress of the truth; and it was with
great difficulty that my faith remained unshaken, yet was I preserved
from that sin, and comforted myself with the certainty, that the
believer's progress through life is one of warfare and suffering.
My case was indeed a pitiable one. I was lame, hungry; fatigued, and
my resources on the very eve of being exhausted. Yet these were but
secondary miseries, and hardly worthy of a thought, compared with those
I suffered inwardly. I not only looked around me with terror at every
one that approached, but I was become a terror to myself; or rather, my
body and soul were become terrors to each other; and, had it been
possible, I felt as if they would have gone to war. I dared not look at
my face in a glass, for I shuddered at my own image and likeness. I
dreaded the dawning, and trembled at the approach of night, nor was
there one thing in nature that afforded me the least delight.
In this deplorable state of body and mind, was I jogging on towards
the Tweed, by the side of the small river called Ellan, when, just at
the narrowest part of the glen, whom should I meet full in the face,
but the very being in all the universe of God I would the most gladly
have shunned. I had no power to fly from him, neither durst I, for the
spirit within me, accuse him of falsehood, and renounce his
fellowship. I stood before him like a condemned criminal, staring him
in the face, ready to be winded, twisted, and tormented as he pleased.
He regarded me with a sad and solemn look. How changed was now that
majestic countenance, to one of haggard despair—changed in all save
the extraordinary likeness to my late brother, a resemblance which
misfortune and despair tended only to heighten. There were no kind
greetings passed between us at meeting, like those which pass between
the men of the world; he looked on me with eyes that froze the currents
of my blood, but spoke not, till I assumed as much courage as to
articulate —"You here! I hope you have brought me tidings of comfort?"
"Tidings of despair!" said he. "But such tidings as the timid and
the ungrateful deserve, and have reason to expect. You are an outlaw,
and a vagabond in your country, and a high reward is offered for your
apprehension. The enraged populace have burnt your house, and all that
is within it; and the farmers on the land bless themselves at being rid
of you. So fare it with every one who puts his hand to the great work
of man's restoration to freedom; and draweth back, contemning the
light that is within him! Your enormities caused me to leave you to
yourself for a season, and you see what the issue has been. You have
given some evil ones power over you, who long to devour you, both soul
and body, and it has required all my power and influence to save you.
Had it not been for my hand, you had been torn in pieces last night;
but for once I prevailed. We must leave this land fortwith, for here
there is neither peace, safety, nor comfort for us. Do you now, and
here, pledge yourself to one who has so often saved your life, and has
put his own at stake to do so? Do you pledge yourself that you will
henceforth be guided by my counsel, and follow me whithersoever I chuse
"I have always been swayed by your counsel," said I, "and for your
sake, principally, am I sorry, that all our measures have proved
abortive. But I hope still to be useful in my native isle, therefore
let me plead that your highness will abandon a poor despised and
outcast wretch to his fate, and betake you to your realms, where your
presence cannot but be greatly wanted."
"Would that I could do so!" said he wofully. "But to talk of that is
to talk of an impossibility. I am wedded to you so closely, that I
feel as if I were the same person. Our essences are one, our bodies and
spirits being united, so, that I am drawn towards you as by magnetism,
and wherever you are, there must my presence be with you."
Perceiving how this assurance affected me, he began to chide me most
bitterly for my ingratitude; and then he assumed such looks, that it
was impossible for me longer to bear them; therefore I staggered out
the way, begging and beseeching of him to give me up to my fate, and
hardly knowing what I said; for it struck me, that, with all his
assumed appearance of misery and wretchedness, there were traits of
exultation in his hideous countenance, manifesting a secret and inward
joy at my utter despair.
It was long before I durst look over my shoulder, but when I did so,
I perceived this ruined and debased potentate coming slowly on the same
path, and I prayed that the lord would hide me in the bowels of the
earth, or depths of the sea. When I crossed the Tweed, I perceived him
still a little behind me; and my despair being then at its height, I
cursed the time I first met with such a tormentor; though, on a little
recollection it occurred, that it was at that blessed time when I was
solemnly dedicated to the Lord, and assured of my final election, and
confirmation, by an eternal decree never to be annulled. This being my
sole and only comfort, I recalled my curse upon the time, and repented
me of my rashness.
After crossing the Tweed, I saw no more of my persecutor that day,
and had hopes that he had left me for a season; but, alas, what hope
was there of my relief after the declaration I had so lately heard! I
took up my lodgings that night in a small miserable inn in the village
of Ancrum, of which the people seemed alike poor and ignorant. Before
going to bed, I asked if it was customary with them to have family
worship of evenings? The man answered, that they were so hard set with
the world, they often could not get time, but if I would be so kind as
officiate they would be much obliged to me. I accepted the invitation,
being afraid to go to rest lest the commotions of the foregoing night
might be renewed, and continued the worship as long as in decency I
could. The poor people thanked me, hoped my prayers would be heard both
on their account and my own, seemed much taken with my abilities, and
wondered how a man of my powerful eloquence chanced to be wandering
about in a condition so forlorn. I said I was a poor student of
theology, on my way to Oxford. They stared at one another with
expressions of wonder, disappointment, and fear. I afterwards came to
learn, that the term theology was by them quite misunderstood, and that
they had some crude conceptions that nothing was taught at Oxford but
the black arts, which ridiculous idea prevailed over all the south of
Scotland. For the present I could not understand what the people meant,
and less so, when the man asked me, with deep concern, "If I was
serious in my intentions of going to Oxford? He hoped not, and that I
would be better guided."
I said my education wanted finishing;—but he remarked, that the
Oxford arts were a bad finish for a religious man's
education.—Finally, I requested him to sleep with me, or in my room
all the night, as I wanted some serious and religious conversation with
him, and likewise to convince him that the study of the fine arts,
though not absolutely necessary, were not incompatible with the
character of a Christian divine. He shook his head, and wondered how I
could call them fine arts— hoped I did not mean to convince him by
any ocular demonstration, and at length reluctantly condescended to
sleep with me, and let the lass and wife sleep together for one night.
I believe he would have declined it, had it not been some hints from
his wife, stating, that it was a good arrangement, by which I
understood there were only two beds in the house, and that when I was
preferred to the lass's bed, she had one to shift for.
The landlord and I accordingly retired to our homely bed, and
conversed for some time about indifferent matters, till he fell sound
asleep. Not so with me: I had that within which would not suffer me to
close my eyes; and about the dead of night, I again heard the same
noises and contention begin outside the house, as I had heard the night
before; and again I heard it was about a sovereign and peculiar right
in me. At one time the noise was on the top of the house, straight
above our bed, as if the one party were breaking through the roof, and
the other forcibly preventing it; at another time it was at the door,
and at a third time at the window; but still mine host lay sound by my
side, and did not waken. I was seized with terrors indefinable, and
prayed fervently, but did not attempt rousing my sleeping companion
until I saw if no better could be done. The women, however, were
alarmed, and, rushing into our apartment, exclaimed that all the devils
in hell were besieging the house. Then, indeed, the landlord awoke, and
it was time for him, for the tumult had increased to such a degree,
that it shook the house to its foundations, being louder and more
furious than I could have conceived the heat of battle to be when the
volleys of artillery are mixed with groans, shouts, and blasphemous
cursing. It thundered and lightened; and there were screams, groans,
laughter, and execrations, all intermingled.
I lay trembling and bathed in a cold perspiration, but was soon
obliged to bestir myself, the inmates attacking me one after the other.
"O, Tam Douglas! Tam Douglas! haste ye an' rise out fra-yont that
incarnal devil!" cried the wife: "Ye are in ayont the auld ane himsel,
for our lass Tibbie saw his cloven cloots last night."
"Lord forbid!" roared Tam Douglas, and darted over the bed like a
flying fish. Then, hearing the unearthly tumult with which he was
surrounded, he returned to the side of the bed, and addressed me thus,
with long and fearful intervals: "If ye be the deil, rise up, an'
depart in peace out o' this house—afore the bedstrae take kindling
about ye, an' than it'll maybe be the waur for ye— Get up—an' gang
awa out amang your cronies, like a good—lad—There's nae body here
wishes you ony ill—D'ye hear me?"
"Friend," said I, "no Christian would turn out a fellow creature on
such a night as this, and in the midst of such a commotion of the
"Na, if ye be a mortal man," said he, "which I rather think, from
the use you made of the holy book—Nane o' your practical jokes on
strangers an' honest foks. These are some o' your Oxford tricks, an'
I'll thank you to be ower wi' them.—Gracious heaven, they are brikkin
through the house at a' the four corners at the same time!"
The lass Tibby, seeing the innkeeper was not going to prevail with
me to rise, flew toward the bed in desperation, and seizing me by the
waist, soon landed me on the floor, saying: "Be ye deil, be ye chiel,
ye's no lie there till baith the house an' us be swallowed up!"
Her master and mistress applauding the deed, I was obliged to
attempt dressing myself, a task to which my powers were quite
inadequate in the state I was in, but I was readily assisted by every
one of the three; and as soon as they got my clothes thrust on in a
loose way, they shut their eyes lest they should see what might drive
them distracted, and thrust me out to the street, cursing me, and
calling on the fiends to take their prey and begone.
The scene that ensued is neither to be described, nor believed, if
it were. I was momently surrounded by a number of hideous fiends, who
gnashed on me with their teeth, and clenched their crimson paws in my
face; and at the same instant I was seized by the collar of my coat
behind, by my dreaded and devoted friend, who pushed me on, and, with
his gilded rapier waving and brandishing around me, defended me against
all their united attacks. Horrible as my assailants were in appearance,
(and they had all monstrous shapes,) I felt that I would rather have
fallen into their hands, than be thus led away captive by my defender
at his will and pleasure, without having the right or power to say my
life, or any part of my will, was my own. I could not even thank him
for his potent guardianship, but hung down my head, and moved on I knew
not whither, like a criminal led to execution, and still the infernal
combat continued, till about the dawning, at which time I looked up,
and all the fiends were expelled but one, who kept at a distance; and
still my persecutor and defender pushed me by the neck before him.
At length he desired me to sit down and take some rest, with which I
complied, for I had great need of it, and wanted the power to withstand
what he desired. There, for a whole morning did he detain me,
tormenting me with reflections on the past, and pointing out the
horrors of the future, until a thousand times I wished myself
non-existent. "I have attached myself to your wayward fortune," said
he; "and it has been my ruin as well as thine. Ungrateful as you are, I
cannot give you up to be devoured; but this is a life that it is
impossible to brook longer. Since our hopes are blasted in this world,
and all our schemes of grandeur overthrown; and since our everlasting
destiny is settled by a decree which no act of ours can invalidate, let
us fall by our own hands, or by the hands of each other; die like
heroes; and, throwing off this frame of dross and corruption, mingle
with the pure ethereal essence of existence, from which we derived our
I shuddered at a view of the dreadful alternative, yet was obliged
to confess that in my present circumstances existence was not to be
borne. It was in vain that I reasoned on the sinfulness of the deed,
and on its damning nature; he made me condemn myself out of my own
mouth, by allowing the absolute nature of justifying grace, and the
impossibility of the elect ever falling from the faith, or the glorious
end to which they were called; and then he said, this granted,
self-destruction was the act of a hero, and none but a coward would
shrink from it, to suffer a hundred times more every day and night that
passed over his head.
I said I was still contented to be that coward; and all that I
begged of him was, to leave me to my fortune for a season, and to the
just judgment of my creator; but he said his word and honour were
engaged on my behoof, and these, in such a case, were not to be
violated. "If you will not pity yourself, have pity on me," added he:
"turn your eyes on me, and behold to what I am reduced."
Involuntarily did I turn round at the request, and caught a half
glance of his features. May no eye destined to reflect the beauties of
the New Jerusalem inward upon the beatific soul, behold such a sight a
mine then beheld! My immortal spirit, blood, and bones, were all
withered at the blasting sight; and I arose and withdrew, with
groanings which the pangs of death shall never wring from me.
Not daring to look behind me, I crept on my way, and that night
reached this hamlet on the Scottish border; and being grown reckless of
danger, and hardened to scenes of horror, I took up my lodging with a
poor hind, who is a widower, and who could only accommodate me with a
bed of rushes at his fire-side. At midnight I heard some strange
sounds, too much resembling those to which I had of late been inured;
but they kept at a distance, and I was soon persuaded that there was a
power protected that house superior to those that contended for, or had
the mastery over me. Overjoyed at finding such an asylum, I remained in
the humble cot. This is the third day I have lived under the roof,
freed of my hellish assailants, spending my time in prayer, and writing
out this my journal, which I have fashioned to stick in with my printed
work, and to which I intend to add portions while I remain in this
pilgrimage state, which, I find too well, cannot be long.
August 3, 1712.—This morning the hind has brought me word from
Redesdale, whither he had been for coals, that a stranger gentleman had
been traversing that country, making the most earnest inquiries after
me, or one of the same appearance; and from the description that he
brought of this stranger, I could easily perceive who it was. Rejoicing
that my tormentor has lost traces of me for once, I am making haste to
leave my asylum, on pretence of following this stranger, but in reality
to conceal myself still more completely from his search. Perhaps this
may be the last sentence ever I am destined to write. If so, farewell
Christian reader! May God grant to thee a happier destiny than has been
allotted to me here on earth, and the same assurance of acceptance
Ault-Righ, August 24, 1712.—Here am I, set down on the open moor
to add one sentence more to my woful journal; and then, farewell all
beneath the sun!
On leaving the hind's cottage on the Border, I hasted to the
north-west, because in that quarter I perceived the highest and wildest
hills before me. As I crossed the mountains above Hawick, I exchanged
clothes with a poor homely shepherd, whom I found lying on a hill side,
singing to himself some woful love ditty. He was glad of the change,
and proud of his saintly apparel; and I was no less delighted with
mine, by which I now supposed myself completely disguised; and I found
moreover that in this garb of a common shepherd I was made welcome in
every house. I slept the first night in a farm-house nigh to the church
of Roberton, without hearing or seeing aught extraordinary; yet I
observed next morning that all the servants kept aloof from me, and
regarded me with looks of aversion. The next night I came to this
house, where the farmer engaged me as a shepherd; and finding him a
kind, worthy, and religious man, I accepted of his terms with great
gladness. I had not, however, gone many times to the sheep, before all
the rest of the shepherds told my master, that I knew nothing about
herding, and begged of him to dimiss me. He perceived too well the
truth of their intelligence; but being much taken with my learning, and
religious conversation, he would not put me away, but set me to herd
It was lucky for me, that before I came here, a report had
prevailed, perhaps for an age, that this farm-house was haunted at
certain seasons by a ghost. I say it was lucky for me, for I had not
been in it many days before the same appalling noises began to prevail
around me about midnight, often continuing till near the dawning. Still
they kept aloof, and without doors; for this gentleman's house, like
the cottage I was in formerly, seemed to be a sanctuary from all
demoniacal power. He appears to be a good man and a just, and mocks at
the idea of supernatural agency, and he either does not hear these
persecuting spirits, or will not acknowledge it, though of late he
appears much perturbed.
The consternation of the menials has been extreme. They ascribe all
to the ghost, and tell frightful stories of murders having been
committed there long ago. Of late, however, they are beginning to
suspect that it is I that am haunted; and as I have never given them
any satisfactory account of myself, they are whispering that I am a
murderer, and haunted by the spirits of those I have slain.
August 30.—This day I have been informed, that I am to be banished
the dwelling-house by night, and to sleep in an out-house by myself, to
try if the family can get any rest when freed of my presence. I have
peremptorily refused acquiescence, on which my master's brother struck
me, and kicked me with his foot. My body being quite exhausted by
suffering, I am grown weak and feeble both in mind and bodily frame,
and actually unable to resent any insult or injury. I am the child of
earthly misery and despair, if ever there was one existent. My master
is still my friend; but there are so many masters here, and every one
of them alike harsh to me, that I wish myself in my grave every hour of
the day. If I am driven from the family sanctuary by night, I know I
shall be torn in pieces before morning; and then who will deign or dare
to gather up my mangled limbs, and give them honoured burial.
My last hour is arrived: I see my tormentor once more approaching me
in this wild. Oh, that the earth would swallow me up, or the hill fall
and cover me! Farewell for ever!
September 7, 1712.—My devoted, princely, but sanguine friend, has
been with me again and again. My time is expired, and I find a relief
beyond measure, for he has fully convinced me that no act of mine can
mar the eternal counsel, or in the smallest degree alter or extenuate
one event which was decreed before the foundations of the world were
laid. He said he had watched over me with the greatest anxiety, but
perceiving my rooted aversion towards him, he had forborn troubling me
with his presence. But now, seeing that I was certainly to be driven
from my sanctuary that night, and that there would be a number of
infernals watching to make a prey of my body, he came to caution me not
to despair, for that he would protect me at all risks, if the power
remained with him. He then repeated an ejaculatory prayer, which I was
to pronounce, if in great extremity. I objected to the words as
equivocal, and susceptible of being rendered in a meaning perfectly
dreadful; but he reasoned against this, and all reasoning with him is
to no purpose. He said he did not ask me to repeat the words, unless
greatly straitened; and that I saw his strength and power giving way,
and when perhaps nothing else could save me.
The dreaded hour of night arrived; and, as he said, I was expelled
from the family residence, and ordered to a byre, or cow-house, that
stood parallel with the dwelling-house behind, where, on a divot loft,
my humble bedstead stood, and the cattle grunted and puffed below me.
How unlike the splendid halls of Dalcastle! And to what I am now
reduced, let the reflecting reader judge. Lord, thou knowest all that I
have done for thy cause on earth! Why then art thou laying thy hand so
sore upon me? Why hast thou set me as a butt of thy malice? But thy
will must be done! Thou wilt repay me in a better world. Amen.
September 8.—My first night of trial in this place is overpast!
Would that it were the last that I should ever see in this detested
world! If the horrors of hell are equal to those I have suffered,
eternity will be of short duration there, for no created energy can
support them for one single month, or week. I have been buffeted as
never living creature was. My vitals have all been torn, and every
faculty and feeling of my soul racked, and tormented into callous
insensibility. I was even hung by the locks over a yawning chasm, to
which I could perceive no bottom, and then—not till then, did I
repeat the tremendous prayer!—I was instantly at liberty; and what I
now am, the Almighty knows! Amen.
September 18, 1712.—Still am I living, though liker to a vision
than a human being; but this is my last day of mortal existence. Unable
to resist any longer, I pledged myself to my devoted friend, that on
this day we should die together, and trust to the charity of the
children of men for a grave. I am solemnly pledged; and though I dared
to repent, I am aware he will not be gainsaid, for he is raging with
despair at his fallen and decayed majesty, and there is some miserable
comfort in the idea that my tormentor shall fall with me. Farewell,
world, with all thy miseries; for comforts or enjoyments hast thou
none! Farewell, woman, whom I have despised and shunned; and man, whom
I have hated; whom, nevertheless, I desire to leave in charity! And
thou, sun, bright emblem of a far brighter effulgence, I bid farewell
to thee also! I do not now take my last look of thee, for to thy
glorious orb shall a poor suicide's last earthly look be raised. But,
ah! who is yon that I see approaching furiously—his stern face
blackened with horrid despair! My hour is at hand.—Almighty God, what
is this that I am about to do! The hour of repentance is past, and now
my fate is inevitable. —Amen, for ever! I will now seal up my little
book, and conceal it; and cursed be he who trieth to alter or amend!
END OF THE MEMOIR.
What can this work be? Sure, you will say, it must be an allegory;
or (as the writer calls it) a religious PARABLE, showing the dreadful
danger of self-righteousness? I cannot tell. Attend to the sequel:
which is a thing so extraordinary, so unprecedented, and so far out of
the common course of human events, that if there were not hundreds of
living witnesses to attest the truth of it, I would not bid any
rational being believe it.
In the first place, take the following extract from an authentic
letter, published in Blackwood's Magazine for August, 1823.
"On the top of a wild height called Cowanscroft, where the lands of
three proprietors meet all at one point, there has been for long and
many years the grave of a suicide marked out by a stone standing at
the head, and another at the feet. Often have I stood musing over it
myself, when a shepherd on one of the farms, of which it formed the
extreme boundary, and thinking what could induce a young man, who had
scarcely reached the prime of life, to brave his Maker, and rush into
his presence by an act of his own erring hand, and one so unnatural and
preposterous. But it never once occurred to me, as an object of
curiosity, to dig up the mouldering bones of the culprit, which I
considered as the most revolting of all objects. The thing was,
however, done last month, and a discovery made of one of the greatest
natural phenomena that I have heard of in this country.
"The little traditionary history that remains of this unfortunate
youth, is altogether a singular one. He was not a native of the place,
nor would he ever tell from what place he came; but he was remarkable
for a deep, thoughtful, and sullen disposition. There was nothing
against his character that any body knew of here, and he had been a
considerable time in the place. The last service he was in was with a
Mr. Anderson of Eltrive, (Ault-Righ, the King's burn,) who died about
100 years ago, and who had hired him during the summer to herd a stock
of young cattle in Eltrive Hope. It happened one day in the month of
September, that James Anderson, his master's son, went with this young
man to the Hope to divert himself. The herd had his dinner along with
him, and about one o'clock, when the boy proposed going home, the
former pressed him very hard to stay and take share of his dinner; but
the boy refused, for fear his parents might be alarmed about him, and
said he would go home: on which the herd said to him, 'Then, if ye
winna stay with me, James, ye may depend on't I'll cut my throat afore
ye come back again.'
"I have heard it likewise reported, but only by one person, that
there had been some things stolen out of his master's house a good
while before, and that the boy had discovered a silver knife and fork,
that was a part of the stolen property, in the herd's possession that
day, and that it was this discovery that drove him to despair.
"The boy did not return to the Hope that afternoon; and, before
evening, a man coming in at the pass called The Hart Loup, with a drove
of lambs, on the way for Edinburgh, perceived something like a man
standing in a strange frightful position at the side of one of
Eldinhope hay-ricks. The driver's attention was riveted on this strange
uncouth figure, and as the drove-road passed at no great distance from
the spot, he first called, but receiving no answer, he went up to the
spot, and behold it was the above-mentioned young man, who had hung
himself in the hay rope that was tying down the rick.
"This was accounted a great wonder; and every one said, if the devil
had not assisted him it was impossible the thing could have been done;
for, in general, these ropes are so brittle, being made of green hay,
that they will scarcely bear to be bound over the rick. And the more to
horrify the good people of this neighbourhood, the driver said, when he
first came in view, he could almost give his oath that he saw two
people busily engaged at the hayrick, going round it and round it, and
he thought they were dressing it.
"If this asseveration approximated at all to truth, it makes this
evident at least, that the unfortunate young man had hanged himself
after the man with the lambs came in view. He was, however, quite dead
when he cut him down. He had fastened two of the old hay-ropes at the
bottom of the rick on one side, (indeed they are all fastened so when
first laid on,) so that he had nothing to do but to loosen two of the
ends on the other side. These he had tied in a knot round his neck, and
then slackening his knees, and letting himself down gradually, till the
hay-rope bore all his weight, he had contrived to put an end to his
existence in that way. Now the fact is, that if you try all the ropes
that are thrown over all the outfield hay-ricks in Scotland, there is
not one among a thousand of them will hang a colley dog; so that the
manner of this wretch's death was rather a singular circumstance.
"Early next morning, Mr. Anderson's servants went reluctantly away,
and, taking an old blanket with them for a winding sheet, they rolled
up the body of the deceased, first in his own plaid, letting the
hay-rope still remain about his neck, and then rolling the old blanket
over all, they bore the loathed remains away to the distance of three
miles or so, on spokes, to the top of Cowan's-Croft, at the very point
where the Duke of Buccleuch's land, the Laird of Drummelzier's, and
Lord Napier's, meet, and there they buried him, with all that he had on
and about him, silver knife and fork and altogether. Thus far went
tradition, and no one ever disputed one jot of the disgusting oral tale.
"A nephew of that Mr. Anderson's who was with the hapless youth that
day he died, says, that, as far as he can gather from the relations of
friends that he remembers, and of that same uncle in particular, it is
one hundred and five years next month, (that is September, 1823,) since
that event happened; and I think it likely that this gentleman's
information is correct. But sundry other people, much older than he,
whom I have consulted, pretend that it is six or seven years more. They
say they have heard that Mr. James Anderson was then a boy ten years of
age; that he lived to an old age, upwards of fourscore, and it is two
and forty years since he died. Whichever way it may be, it was about
that period some way, of that there is no doubt.
"It so happened, that two young men, William Shiel and W. Sword,
were out, on an adjoining height, this summer, casting peats, and it
came into their heads to open this grave in the wilderness, and see if
there were any of the bones of the suicide of former ages and centuries
remaining. They did so, but opened only one half of the grave,
beginning at the head and about the middle at the same time. It was
not long till they came upon the old blanket—I think they said not
much more than a foot from the surface. They tore that open, and there
was the hay rope lying stretched down alongst his breast, so fresh that
they saw at first sight that it was made of risp, a sort of long
sword-grass that grows about marshes and the sides of lakes. One of the
young men seized the rope and pulled by it, but the old enchantment of
the devil remained,—it would not break; and so he pulled and pulled
at it, till behold the body came up into a sitting posture, with a
broad blue bonnet on its head, and its plaid around it, all as fresh as
that day it was laid in! I never heard of a preservation so wonderful,
if it be true as was related to me, for still I have not had the
curiosity to go and view the body myself. The features were all so
plain, that an acquaintance might easily have known him. One of the
lads gripped the face of the corpse with his finger and thumb, and the
cheeks felt quite soft and fleshy, but the dimples remained and did not
spring out again. He had fine yellow hair, about nine inches long; but
not a hair of it could they pull out till they cut part of it off with
a knife. They also cut off some portions of his clothes, which were all
quite fresh, and distributed them among their acquaintances, sending a
portion to me, among the rest, to keep as natural curiosities. Several
gentlemen have in a manner forced me to give them fragments of these
enchanted garments: I have, however, retained a small portion for you,
which I send along with this, being a piece of his plaid, and another
of his waist-coat breast, which you will see are still as fresh as that
day they were laid in the grave.
"His broad blue bonnet was sent to Edinburgh several weeks ago, to
the great regret of some gentlemen connected with the land, who wished
to have it for a keep-sake. For my part, fond as I am of blue bonnets,
and broad ones in particular, I declare I durst not have worn that one.
There was nothing of the silver knife and fork discovered, that I heard
of, nor was it very likely it should: but it would appear he had been
very near run of cash, which I daresay had been the cause of his utter
despair; for, on searching his pockets, nothing was found but three old
Scots halfpennies. These young men meeting with another shepherd
afterwards, his curiosity was so much excited that they went and
digged up the curious remains a second time, which was a pity, as it is
likely that by these exposures to the air, and from the impossibility
of burying it up again as closely as it was before, the flesh will now
fall to dust."
The letter from which the above is an extract, is signed James Hogg,
and dated from Altrive Lake, August 1st, 1823. It bears the stamp of
authenticity in every line; yet, so often had I been hoaxed by the
ingenious fancies displayed in that Magazine, that when this relation
met my eye, I did not believe it; but from the moment that I perused
it, I half formed the resolution of investigating these wonderful
remains personally, if any such existed; for, in the immediate vicinity
of the scene, as I supposed, I knew of more attractive metal than the
dilapidated remains of mouldering suicides.
Accordingly, having some business in Edinburgh in September last,
and being obliged to wait a few days for the arrival of a friend from
London, I took that opportunity to pay a visit to my townsman and
fellow collegian. Mr. L—t of C—d, advocate. I mentioned to him
Hogg's letter, asking him if the statement was founded at all on
truth. His answer was, "I suppose so. For my part I never doubted the
thing, having been told that there has been a deal of talking about it
up in the Forest for some time past. But, God knows! Hogg has imposed
as ingenious lies on the public ere now."
I said, if it was within reach, I should like exceedingly to visit
both the Shepherd and the Scots mummy he had described. Mr. L—t
assented at the first proposal, saying he had no objections to take a
ride that length with me, and make the fellow produce his credentials:
That we would have a delightful jaunt through a romantic and now
classical country, and some good sport into the bargain, provided he
could procure a horse for me, from his father-in-law, next day. He sent
up to a Mr. L—w to inquire, who returned for answer, that there was
an excellent pony at my service, and that he himself would accompany
us, being obliged to attend a great sheep fair at Thirlestane; and
that he was certain the Shepherd would be there likewise.
Mr. L—t said that was the very man we wanted to make our party
complete; and at an early hour next morning we started for the ewe
fair of Thirlestane, taking Blackwood's Magazine for August along with
us. We rode through the ancient royal burgh of Selkirk,—halted and
corned our horses at a romantic village, nigh to some deep linns on the
Ettrick, and reached the market ground at Thirlestane-green a little
before mid-day. We soon found Hogg, standing near the foot of the
market, as he called it, beside a great drove of paulies, a species of
stock that I never heard of before. They were small sheep, striped on
the backs with red chalk. Mr. L—t introduced me to him as a great
wool-stapler, come to raise the price of that article; but he eyed me
with distrust, and turning his back on us, answered, "I hae sell'd
I followed, and shewing him the above-quoted letter, said I was
exceedingly curious to have a look of these singular remains he had so
ingeniously described; but he only answered me with the remark, that
"It was a queer fancy for a woo-stappler to tak."
His two friends then requested him to accompany us to the spot, and
to take some of his shepherds with us to assist in raising the body;
but he spurned at the idea, saying, "Od bless ye, lad! I hae ither
matters to mind. I hae a' thae paulies to sell, an' a' yon Highland
stotts down on the green every ane; an' then I hae ten scores o' yowes
to buy after, an' if I canna first sell my ain stock, I canna buy nae
ither body's. I hae mair ado than I can manage the day, foreby ganging
to houk up hunder-year-auld banes."
Finding that we could make nothing of him, we left him with his
paulies, Highland stotts, grey jacket, and broad blue bonnet, to go in
search of some other guide. L—w soon found one, for he seemed
acquainted with every person in the fair. We got a fine old shepherd,
named W—m B—e, a great original, and a very obliging and civil man,
who asked no conditions but that we should not speak of it, because he
did not wish it to come to his master's ears, that he had been engaged
in sic a profane thing. We promised strict secrecy; and accompanied by
another farmer, Mr. S—t, and old B—e, we proceeded to the grave,
which B—e described as about a mile and a half distant from the
We went into a shepherd's cot to get a drink of milk, when I read to
our guide Mr. Hogg's description, asking him if he thought it correct?
He said there was hardly a bit o't correct, for the grave was not on
the hill of Cowan's-Croft, nor yet on the point where three lairds'
lands met, but on the top of a hill called the Faw-Law, where there was
no land that was not the Duke of Buccleuch's within a quarter of a
mile. He added that it was a wonder how the poet could be mistaken
there, who once herded the very ground where the grave is, and saw both
hills from his own window. Mr. L—w testified great surprise at such a
singular blunder, as also how the body came not to be buried at the
meeting of three or four lairds' lands, which had always been customary
in the south of Scotland. Our guide said he had always heard it
reported, that the Eltrive men, with Mr. David Anderson at their head,
had risen before day on the Monday morning, it having been on the
Sabbath day that the man put down himself; and that they set out with
the intention of burying him on Cowan's-Croft, where three marches met
at a point. But it having been an invariable rule to bury such lost
sinners before the rising of the sun, these five men were overtaken by
day-light, as they passed the house of Berry-Knowe; and by the time
they reached the top of the Faw-Law, the sun was beginning to skair
the east. On this they laid down the body, and digged a deep grave with
all expedition; but when they had done, it was too short, and the body
being stiff, it would not go down, on which Mr. David Anderson looking
to the east, and perceiving that the sun would be up on them in a few
minutes, set his foot on the suicide's brow, and tramped down his head
into the grave with his iron-heeled shoe, until his nose and skull
crashed again, and at the same time uttered a terrible curse on the
wretch who had disgraced the family, and given them all this trouble.
This anecdote, our guide said, he had heard when a boy, from the mouth
of Robert Laidlaw, one of the five men who buried the body.
We soon reached the spot, and I confess I felt a singular sensation,
when I saw the grey stone standing at the head, and another at the
feet, and the one half of the grave manifestly new digged, and closed
up again as had been described. I could still scarcely deem the thing
to be a reality, for the ground did not appear to be wet, but a kind of
dry rotten moss. On looking around, we found some fragments of clothes,
some teeth, and part of a pocket-book, which had not been returned
into the grave, when the body had been last raised, for it had been
twice raised before this, but only from the loins upward.
To work we fell with two spades, and soon cleared away the whole of
the covering. The part of the grave that had been opened before, was
filled with mossy mortar, which impeded us exceedingly, and entirely
prevented a proper investigation of the fore parts of the body. I will
describe every thing as I saw it before four respectable witnesses,
whose names I shall publish at large if permitted. A number of the
bones came up separately; for with the constant flow of liquid stuff
into the deep grave, we could not see to preserve them in their places.
At length great loads of coarse clothes, blanketing, plaiding, &c.
appeared; we tried to lift these regularly up, and on doing so, part of
a skeleton came up, but no flesh, save a little that was hanging in
dark flitters about the spine, but which had no consistence; it was
merely the appearance of flesh without the substance. The head was
wanting; and I being very anxious to possess the skull, the search was
renewed among the mortar and rags. We first found a part of the scalp,
with the long hair firm on it; which, on being cleaned, is neither
black nor fair, but of a darkish dusk, the most common of any other
colour. Soon afterwards we found the skull, but it was not complete. A
spade had damaged it, and one of the temple quarters was wanting. I am
no phrenologist, not knowing one organ from another, but I thought the
skull of that wretched man no study. If it was particular for any
thing, it was for a smooth, almost perfect rotundity, with only a
little protuberance above the vent of the ear.
When we came to that part of the grave that had never been opened
before, the appearance of every thing was quite different. There the
remains lay under a close vault of moss, and within a vacant space; and
I suppose, by the digging in the former part of the grave, that part
had been deepened, and drawn the moisture away from this part, for here
all was perfect. The breeches still suited the thigh, the stocking the
leg, and the garters were wrapt as neatly and as firm below the knee as
if they had been newly tied. The shoes were all opened in the seams,
the hemp having decayed, but the soles, upper leathers, and wooden
heels, which were made of birch, were all as fresh as any of those we
wore. There was one thing I could not help remarking, that in the
inside of one of the shoes there was a layer of cow's dung, about one
eighth of an inch thick, and in the hollow of the sole fully one fourth
of an inch. It was firm, green, and fresh; and proved that he had been
working in a byre. His clothes were all of a singular ancient cut, and
no less singular in their texture. Their durability certainly would
have been prodigious; for in thickness, coarseness, and strength, I
never saw any cloth in the smallest degree to equal them. His coat was
a frock coat, of a yellowish drab colour, with wide sleeves. It is
tweeled, milled, and thicker than a carpet. I cut off two of the skirts
and brought them with me. His vest was of striped serge, such as I have
often seen worn by country people. It was lined and backed with white
stuff. The breeches were a sort of striped plaiding, which I never saw
worn, but which our guide assured us was very common in the country
once, though, from the old clothes which he had seen remaining of it,
he judged that it could not be less than 200 years since it was in
fashion. His garters were of worsted, and striped with black or blue;
his stockings gray, and wanting the feet. I brought samples of all
along with me. I have likewise now got possession of the bonnet, which
puzzles me most of all. It is not conformable with the rest of the
dress. It is neither a broad bonnet, nor a Border bonnet; for there is
an open behind, for tying, which no genuine Border bonnet, I am told,
ever had. It seems to have been a Highland bonnet, worn in a flat way
like a scone on the crown, such as is sometimes still seen in the west
of Scotland. All the limbs, from the loins to the toes, seemed perfect
and entire, but they could not bear handling. Before we got them
returned again into the grave, they were all shaken to pieces, except
the thighs, which continued to retain a kind of flabby form.
All his clothes that were sewed with linen yarn were lying in
separate portions, the thread having rotten; but such as were sewed
with worsted remained perfectly firm and sound. Among such a confusion,
we had hard work to find out all his pockets, and our guide supposed,
that, after all, we did not find above the half of them. In his vest
pocket was a long clasp knife, very sharp; the haft was thin, and the
scales shone as if there had been silver inside. Mr Sc—t took it with
him, and presented it to his neighbour, Mr. R—n of W—n L—e, who
still has it in his possession. We found a comb, a gimblet, a vial, a
small neat square board, a pair of plated knee-buckles, and several
samples of cloth of different kinds, rolled neatly up within one
another. At length, while we were busy on the search, Mr. L—t picked
up a leathern case, which seemed to have been wrapped round and round
by some ribbon, or cord, that had been rotten from it, for the
swaddling marks still remained. Both L—w and B—e called out that
"it was the tobacco spleuchan, and a well-filled ane too;" but on
opening it out, we found, to our great astonishment, that it contained
a printed pamphlet. We were all curious to see what sort of a pamphlet
such a person would read; what it could contain that he seemed to have
had such a care about? for the slough in which it was rolled, was fine
chamois leather; what colour it had been, could not be known. But the
pamphlet was wrapped so close together, and so damp, rotten, and
yellow, that it seemed one solid piece. We all concluded, from some
words that we could make out, that it was a religious tract, but that
it would be impossible to make any thing of it. Mr. L—w remarked that
it was a great pity if a few sentences could not be made out, for that
it was a question what might be contained in that little book; and then
he requested Mr. L—t to give it to me, as he had so many things of
literature and law to attend to, that he would never think more of it.
He replied, that either of us were heartily welcome to it, for that he
had thought of returning it into the grave, if he could have made out
but a line or two, to have seen what was its tendency.
"Grave, man!" exclaimed L—w, who speaks excellent strong broad
Scots: "My truly, but ye grave weel! I wad esteem the contents o' that
spleuchan as the most precious treasure. I'll tell you what it is, sir:
I hae often wondered how it was that this man's corpse has been
miraculously preserved frae decay, a hunder times langer than ony other
body's, or than even a tanner's. But now I could wager a guinea, it has
been for the preservation o' that little book. And Lord kens what may
be in't! It will maybe reveal some mystery that mankind disna ken
naething about yet."
"If there be any mysteries in it," returned the other, "it is not
for your handling, my dear friend, who are too much taken up about
mysteries already." And with these words he presented the mysterious
pamphlet to me. With very little trouble, save that of a thorough
drying, I unrolled it all with ease, and found the very tract which I
have here ventured to lay before the public, part of it in small bad
print, and the remainder in manuscript. The title page is written, and
is as follows:
THE PRIVATE MEMOIRS
OF A JUSTIFIED SINNER:
WRITTEN BY HIMSELF.
FIDELI CERTA MERCES.
And, alongst the head, it is the same as given in the present
edition of the work. I altered the title to A Self-justified Sinner,
but my booksellers did not approve of it; and there being a curse
pronounced by the writer on him that should dare to alter or amend, I
have let it stand as it is. Should it be thought to attach discredit to
any received principle of our church, I am blameless. The printed part
ends at page 340, and the rest is in a fine old hand, extremely small
and close. I have ordered the printer to procure a fac-simile of it, to
be bound in with the volume.
With regard to the work itself, I dare not venture a judgment, for I
do not understand it. I believe no person, man or woman, will ever
peruse it with the same attention that I have done, and yet I confess
that I do not comprehend the writer's drift. It is certainly impossible
that these scenes could ever have occurred, that he describes as having
himself transacted. I think it may be possible that he had some hand in
the death of his brother, and yet I am disposed greatly to doubt it;
and the numerous distorted traditions, &c. which remain of that event,
may be attributable to the work having been printed and burnt, and of
course the story known to all the printers, with their families and
gossips. That the young Laird of Dalcastle came by a violent death,
there remains no doubt; but that this wretch slew him, there is to me
a good deal. However, allowing this to have been the case, I account
all the rest either dreaming or madness; or, as he says to Mr. Watson,
a religious parable, on purpose to illustrate something scarcely
tangible, but to which he seems to have attached great weight. Were the
relation at all consistent with reason, it corresponds so minutely with
traditionary facts, that it could scarcely have missed to have been
received as authentic; but in this day, and with the present
generation, it will not go down, that a man should be daily tempted by
the devil, in the semblance of a fellow-creature; and at length lured
to self-destruction, in the hopes that this same fiend and tormentor
was to suffer and fall along with him. It was a bold theme for an
allegory, and would have suited that age well had it been taken up by
one fully qualified for the task, which this writer was not. In short,
we must either conceive him not only the greatest fool, but the
greatest wretch, on whom was ever stamped the form of humanity; or,
that he was a religious maniac, who wrote and wrote about a deluded
creature, till he arrived at that height of madness, that he believed
himself the very object whom he had been all along describing. And in
order to escape from an ideal tormentor, committed that act for which,
according to the tenets he embraced, there was no remission, and which
consigned his memory and his name to everlasting detestation.